Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/desistito: per un periodo mi sono identificata come genderqueer/non binaria, ma non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi legati alla transizione, e oggi mi identifico come donna bisessuale mascolina e non conforme al genere. Provo disforia di genere dai 12-13 anni circa, negli anni Novanta, ma è rimasta costante e si è attenuata con l'età, e ho scelto di conviverci anziché transitare perché sentivo che la transizione medica non poteva darmi ciò che volevo davvero. A trent'anni mi sono fatta rimuovere le tube per eliminare la possibilità di una gravidanza, e questo mi ha resa felice. Sono critica verso l'attuale movimento trans, in particolare verso quella che vedo come una «cancellazione delle butch» che spinge le donne mascoline verso la transizione, e credo che la transizione debba essere una scelta personale e non un obbligo. Ho 35 anni, vivo in una zona repubblicana della California e in genere sto bene a vivere come donna mascolina.
Storia completa
I was born female and have always been female. I first felt gender dysphoria around age 12-13, during the 1990s, when being trans was not something I even knew existed as an option — I grew up in a red area of California where homophobia was a serious issue. I described my distress at 12-13 as about '500x' what it is today. I came out first as bisexual and then as lesbian as a teenager; my parents were accepting of my male interests, male dress, and my coming out. I was bullied and called slurs in elementary and middle school in the 1990s, and straight people assumed I was lesbian because of how I looked.
I identified as genderqueer/non-binary for a period of time but never took testosterone or any hormones for transition. I stopped identifying that way because I don't identify as trans — my question was always 'if I'm trans then wtf am I I transitioning to if I'm non-binary.' I now identify as a masculine/GNC woman, sometimes describing myself as a tomboy or butch bisexual. I am 35 years old as of 2021, bisexual, and I have always been attracted to women.
I have had dysphoria regarding my gender my entire life, as long as I can remember — I have always wanted to be the other gender. I said I would 'literally' have swapped bodies with a natural-born straight guy as a teen if given the opportunity. However, I decided against medical or social transition because transitioning would not have given me the power and freedom of being a heterosexual cis male, and I wasn't interested in being 'a short guy with erectile dysfunction or a micro penis and scars.' I have found more happiness being a very weird non-conforming female. My dysphoria has stayed incredibly consistent throughout my life and has never gotten worse, though it is 'much less so as I've gotten older.'
I had my tubes removed in my thirties to eliminate the specter of pregnancy — I don't want kids anyway, and the idea of being pregnant was too incongruent and would make me dysphoric again. I said I did that partly because of how I feel about gender. I also went on testosterone cream (from a compounding pharmacy) at a low dose for my sex drive for a while, but it did nothing to help me feel any differently. I tried the depo shot to stop my periods but it didn't work (breakthrough bleeding), and I gave up my search for a period-free life because I didn't like how I felt on female hormones (estrogen in the pill) — they make me feel terrible.
I have never had any surgeries related to transition. I cross dress a lot — I wear boxer briefs, men's oversized t-shirts, suit pants, vests, cargo shorts, work boots, and sometimes a three-piece fitted suit to lesbian events. I keep my hair long but unkempt and cut in one chunk, and I pluck my eyebrows. I have an hourglass shape and am tall, 'the size of an average man,' with a naturally low voice. I have never been able to pass as male.
I grew up before trans was a thing and didn't know what trans was. I believe my masculinity is natural, not social — I don't know if I just am this way or had more testosterone exposure in the womb. I met a butch lesbian woman at a young age, around 12, at a local queer youth center, which I think benefited me. I have always lived my life as a manly woman.
I am philosophically gender critical and against gender, though I don't fully align with gender critical feminists because 'they can be dicks on some issues.' I believe gender dysphoria is created by society and gender roles. I am critical of the current trans movement, particularly what I call 'butch erasure' — I feel that masculine women like me are being pushed to transition rather than accepted as they are. I worry that today's environment would push young GNC people toward permanent changes. I don't support a ban on transition but believe it should be a personal choice, like plastic surgery, not a mandate or something considered necessary for happiness. I think the medical technology is 'barbaric' and that FTM outcomes and complication rates are poor.
I have been in a relationship with my boyfriend for a decade (as of 2021). I have had mostly male relationships as well as w/w relationships. I have also had a wife at some point (I mention learning salsa dancing with my wife). I live in a red area of California. I have a best friend I made online who is an Iraqi national. I attend lesbian events in California, including the Dinah, pretty much every year.
I was excluded and bullied in school. I experienced homophobia growing up. I have not described any mental health diagnoses, but I described being miserable at 13 and feeling 'in the wrong fucking body.' I don't describe current depression or suicidal ideation for myself.
I have not described regret about transition since I never medically transitioned. I do express that identifying as genderqueer/non-binary didn't help me and made me feel more of an outsider. I am generally content now, saying I've 'made peace' with my body 'for the most part' and that I feel '100 percent myself' as a masculine woman, though I still feel the incongruity sometimes.
I have not engaged in formal advocacy or activism, but I do speak up on forums and challenge what I see as bad statistics and narratives about detransitioners and GNC people.