Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nato maschio, mi sono identificato come trans (compreso, a un certo punto, come non binario) e ho desistito prima di perseguire ormoni o interventi, grazie al fatto di aver fatto terapia e di essermi preso cura meglio di me stesso fin da presto. Ora mi identifico come uomo eterosessuale che ha desistito e sta bene con se stesso, e attribuisco la mia disforia a narcisismo, ossessione e voglia di ciò che non potevo avere più che a un'identità fissa. Sono critico verso la transizione così come è praticata oggi, soprattutto per i giovani, e vedo l'autoginefilia e il narcisismo come motori poco discussi della transizione. Non descrivo ideazione suicidaria o autolesionismo da quando ho desistito, e il mio rimpianto riguarda il tempo perso e l'intrappolamento mentale più che specifici cambiamenti medici.
Storia completa
I was born male, and I identified as trans for a period before desisting. I don't have a precise timeline for when my dysphoria first appeared or when I came out, but I can point to a few anchors: by March 2024 I had already desisted, and I referenced getting therapy and taking better care of myself before I reached what I called the "FAFO stage," which suggests I pulled back from transition before doing anything irreversible. I don't believe I was ever so far committed to transition that I could have confronted whether I had autogynephilia at that point — I never made it to hormones or surgery as far as my posts describe, and I'm grateful for that. In April 2024 I wrote, "I'm so glad I got therapy and took better care of myself before I hit the FAFO stage," which is probably the clearest statement of how I avoided worse outcomes.
Looking back, I think what drove my dysphoria was a mix of narcissism in the clinical sense — a rejection of self — and a kind of wanting what I don't have. I've described dysphoria as basically "oneitis": a real feeling, but one you conjure yourself through obsession and that goes away by focusing on other things. I also think wanting to be a woman while being attracted to women as a heterosexual man is like having your cake and eating it too — you want to both obtain an object of desire and embody it, which I see as a very human but ultimately egocentric impulse. I've said plainly, "You're still a man even if you feel out of place as one. I sure do, and always have," and "You would have to be born a woman" to be one. Once I desisted I realized that wanting something I couldn't have wasn't unique — people want to be taller, famous, have different upbringings — and that "Growing up is making a space for yourself in the world via what you can actually do. Chasing dead ends is for people too afraid to grow up."
Therapy was the pivotal process for me. It helped me get to a better place before things went further, and I've contrasted that with people who "never come to peace with themselves" and remain unhappy. I also noticed hostility in queer spaces even before I desisted, simply because I was more or less comfortable with myself and they weren't; I found the constant commiserating dragged down my own mental health, so I stopped spending time in those spaces. I've described those communities as places where "the worst thing you could ever be is a happy, well-adjusted person who likes themselves, eats right and exercises, and the best thing you can be is a self-mutilating suicidal narcissist." I've also said that a depressed person will always opt for immediate dopamine over long-term improvement, and that an entire movement made up of extremely depressed people gives advice informed by extremely depressed brains.
I don't describe any medical interventions, complications, or fertility concerns in these posts — my account is that I desisted before hitting the point of no return. On mental health, I don't name specific diagnoses for myself, but I frame my earlier state in terms of narcissism, obsession, and discomfort with reality, and I've said a person uncomfortable with reality is in need of therapy rather than affirmation. I don't describe trauma, abuse, assault, or family dysfunction in this transcript, and I don't describe family or partner intervention directly — though I did once reply to someone whose father told them to "take it back further," saying that didn't surprise me because any good person knows there's a deeper issue at the heart of this.
On sexuality, I describe myself as a heterosexual man who always felt out of place as one. I don't discuss internalized homophobia directly, but I do discuss internalized misogyny in the context of transmasc and nonbinary identification. I've written about having identified as nonbinary myself and now seeing it as "a sort of cowardly move away from womanhood" when I could instead have embraced being a gender-nonconforming woman — though that phrasing appears to be me quoting and amplifying someone else's words that I strongly agreed with, thanking them profusely. I've also said nonbinary identity is "straight up fucking gender essentialism" and that a lot of transmasc nonbinary people show "tons of internalized misogyny coupled with a desire to flee from traumatic associations to womanhood."
My regret is not about specific medical changes, since I don't describe any. It's more about time, energy, and the mental trap itself. I've said that transition keeps advancing because nothing works — people think one thing will be enough to finally feel right, get it, and it still isn't, so they push a little more. I've described affirming a person's delusion as enabling severe depression. The intensity of my regret seems moderate and stable rather than acute; I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm since desisting. I do describe anger — I've written that affirming statements toward people trying to identify this way fill me with rage, because I see it as enabling severe depression in someone who needs therapy, not a delusional false reality.
Currently I'd describe myself as a desisted heterosexual man who is comfortable with himself. My quality of life seems good — I described noticing hostility in queer spaces because I was more comfortable with myself than they were, and I've told someone else, "You don't need those rotten souls in your life... they resent you for making it out of the crab bucket." I don't describe career or family impacts.
On transition for other people, I'm broadly critical and opposed to how it's currently practiced, especially for young people. I've called the 1% regret statistic a reflection of sunk cost fallacy, described the movement as cultish, and criticized therapists for not being honest about autogynephilia. I've said AGP is treatable without transition and that you can get a taste of the feminine side without permanent medical treatments. I'm still fundamentally "live and let live" at the individual level — I wrote that if someone's happy I hope they are — but I'm angry at what I see as systemic dishonesty. I don't describe formal advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting in detrans communities.