Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto coming out come trans nel 2003, mi è stato diagnosticato un Disturbo dell’Identità di Genere, ho preso il testosterone solo per poco e ho fatto una mastectomia. Ho avuto dolore ai genitali e al seno iniziato più o meno quando ho preso il testosterone e mai del tutto scomparso, e ho smesso gli ormoni per motivi di salute. Mi pento di aver fatto piangere e preoccupare i miei genitori e vorrei che le persone avessero messo in discussione la mia identità trans invece di accettarla in silenzio. Oggi sono una critica esplicita della transizione, in particolare per i minori, e invito chi ha fatto detransition a contattare i propri medici per segnalare il rimpianto. Ho una carriera e dei figli, e mi sento fortunata di poter parlare senza rischi.
Storia completa
I came out as trans in 2003, when I was diagnosed with Gender Identity Disorder. I had expected people to challenge me or tell me I was wrong, but instead I got only a little pushback from friends, family and therapists — they thought some people really were trans but that I didn't seem manly enough or dysphoric enough, and they were confused about why I would try to pass as a gay man when gay men faced discrimination. Mostly they avoided talking about it. I now understand that their silence was just people avoiding confrontation, but at the time I took their tolerance as evidence that my trans identity was legitimate. I always had doubts that I was trans, or that anyone really was — I knew I was unhappy and didn't fit in but wasn't sure why, or if transition would help — but when other people tolerated or affirmed my identity, it made it easier to ignore those doubts.
I did experience what would today be called transphobic hate, plus anti-lesbian slurs, but even in those less accepting times few people directly confronted me. I didn't scream at people for not calling me he/him, didn't expect people to call me a guy until I passed, and didn't threaten self-harm to get what I wanted.
I took testosterone, but only briefly. I had pain that started around the time I took testosterone — I don't know for sure whether T was the cause, but it began then and hasn't fully disappeared. I also had a mastectomy; I've dealt with mastectomy scars and have experienced pain from breast forms pressing on the scars, as well as some leaking from the scars or nipples that I wanted to ask a doctor about. I stopped testosterone for health reasons. I never had a hysterectomy or removed my ovaries, so my estrogen levels should return to normal on their own, and I've advised others in my situation that taking estrogen is probably unnecessary and carries health risks like stroke or heart attack.
My dysphoria about my breasts and periods began at puberty, but other dysphoria started only after I had already decided I was trans. When I started trying to pass as male, I began caring about things like my wrist size and height that had never bothered me before. Binding my breasts made me focus on them more instead of ignoring them, because the binder's discomfort was a constant reminder. Looking at post-top-surgery photos and reading about surgeons made me fantasize more about surgery, and hearing other girls describe their dysphoria made me feel mine more acutely — feelings are contagious.
I regret making my parents cry and worry. I'm glad I was never one of those people who scream at their parents for misgendering or deadnaming them. I also wish people had laughed in my face when I said I was trans — I needed a wake-up call — and I think fewer people would transition if more people repeatedly and firmly challenged them.
I've come to believe that gender dysphoria should be considered a mental illness rather than a natural difference, that there is no proof of 'male brains' in female bodies, and that transition is risky, medicalized, and often regretted. I've been active in sharing articles and information about detransition, medical harms to minors, puberty blockers, and the weaknesses in transition research. I posted an article on r/AutismInWomen and got banned for it. I've spoken out publicly and feel fortunate that I'm not at risk of losing my job or having my kids threatened if I do. I believe detransitioners should contact their former surgeons and doctors to inform them of their regret, since regret rates are underestimated. I've also noted that I'm not at risk of losing my job or having my kids threatened, implying I have a career and children.
I've advised many people to wait, that most people grow out of these feelings, that the brain matures until about 25, and that passing consistently is rare regardless of when hormones start. I've suggested gratitude practices for coping with regret, and I've recommended therapy and purpose-building — finding hobbies, community, activism — as paths to recovery. I believe most detransitioners don't join a community, comparing it to how most ex-Christians don't join ex-Christian groups. I currently identify as a detransitioned woman and am critical of transition, particularly for minors.