Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna in desistenza sulla trentina che non ha mai fatto la transizione medica ma ci è andata abbastanza vicino a metà dei vent’anni da considerarmi parte di questa comunità. Sono stata intensamente disforica per gran parte della mia vita, in gran parte a causa di un’attrazione ossessiva per gli uomini, del disagio nell’essere desiderata sessualmente come femmina e del degrado sociale dell’essere femmina, e a circa 26 anni ho quasi iniziato gli ormoni prima di capire che volevo essere biologicamente maschio e non semplicemente vivere come un uomo, cosa che nessuna transizione poteva darmi. Non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi legati alla transizione, anche se a 29 anni mi sono fatta legare le tube, il che ha ridotto in modo significativo il mio disgusto per il corpo. Ora non mi identifico né come trans né come cis né come non binaria, rifiuto del tutto la teoria dell’identità di genere e mi aiuto vedendo il sesso come un fatto biologico accidentale e non come un’identità. Provo ancora disforia e amarezza per l’essere femmina, e in passato ho avuto pensieri suicidi legati al desiderio di essere maschio, ma la mia qualità di vita è migliorata sostanzialmente da quando ho fatto desistenza.
Storia completa
I was born female in the 1980s and I'm in my thirties as of 2020. I never took hormones, never had surgery related to transition, and never asked anyone to use opposite-sex pronouns, but I am certain that if I had been born five years later I would have fully transitioned by my current age. I came close enough that I consider myself a desister rather than someone untouched by the issue.
Growing up I had traditionally masculine interests, hobbies, and mannerisms. I was called a tomboy and called a dyke repeatedly in middle school. I kept my hair very short for most of my life and dressed only in jeans and a t-shirt until my mid-twenties. I hated everything associated with femininity and had no tools to process why. I remember always making the association that girl=bad since I could first form words, though the true severity of that vitriol hit me at puberty. I was small even as a child—I didn't hit 90 lbs until my senior year of high school—and I was constantly picked up, petted on the head, and physically harassed in ways nobody around me treated as a problem.
People assumed I was gay constantly. My dad was shocked when I told him I was dating a boy at 18. I started dating him largely because he was the first person to express interest and I felt social pressure not to turn a man down. I was confused about how unattracted to him I was, and briefly wondered if I was gay, before realizing I simply had specific tastes—I'm very unattracted to tall men because I'm short myself (5'2). I am intensely attracted to men. I view men through an intensely sexual lens, an all-encompassing desire I've carried for most of my life.
When I started having sex I felt repulsed, but for a confusing reason: I loved men's naked bodies and arousal, but was turned off when they were aroused by my female body. My own female anatomy disgusted me in a sexual setting. I preferred porn that didn't involve women and developed a lifelong interest in solo male and gay male porn. I discovered porn very early and have wondered how much it contributed to these feelings. I wanted to be dominant in bed, to penetrate, to be seen as male, and concluded I must really be a gay man deep down. I never told anyone—not friends, not the men I dated.
In my mid-twenties, around 26, I was depressed, had gained a lot of weight, and lost motivation. I was going to go to the doctor to start transition. I researched woman-to-man transitions obsessively. What stopped me was realizing the people I researched looked like men—and I didn't want to look like a man, I wanted to be one. I asked myself whether living as a 5-foot man with no penis would make my life more bearable, and the answer was no. I had to accept I could not be male, and that I couldn't even know I wanted to be, since I inherently cannot know what it feels like to be male. I concluded that fancying myself a gay man was disingenuous, appropriative, and fetishistic at its core.
After that realization I stopped cutting my hair short, stopped dressing overtly masculine, lost thirty pounds, and started doing what I liked regardless of gender coding. I got my tubes tied at 29, unmarried with no kids, and afterward felt far less revulsion toward my body and less afraid it could betray me. I also lift weights, which has helped me feel less physically weak, though men still mock me for not lifting as much as someone 100 lbs heavier and 8 inches taller.
I still have problems with men showing sexual appreciation for my body parts, and I still feel like I'm in the wrong sexual role at times. These feelings are most prominent in sexual settings rather than daily life, and they worsen around my period, which I attribute to the hormonal shift. They have diminished somewhat over the last several years, partly through experimentation with pegging and the like. I have no history of sexual trauma or abuse. I don't desire rough sex and have no urges toward masochism or sadism—I'm more of a body-worshiper in bed, wanting to be the one in charge of my partner's pleasure.
I have never wanted to be seen as a man purely for validation. My goal was to physiologically be male, and since that's impossible, gender identity was never good enough for me. I've also thought about how I'd feel about dating a detrans man—it feels like it would be freeing, to be with someone who wouldn't pin insulting gender biases on either of us. I have a male partner now, and while I love him, I find that when we're together in public or on business I effectively cease to exist to others—repair people, salespeople, everyone defers to him and ignores me, which tempts me toward being single again.
I've become openly hostile to gender identity theory. A friend insisted I was non-binary regardless of my feelings, which infuriated me. I don't identify as non-binary, I don't consider myself cisgender, and when people ask my pronouns I say it doesn't matter and they can pick. I've had therapists repeatedly try to affirm that I'm really a man and refer me to gender clinics, and when I refuse they lose interest or ghost me. I've largely given up on finding competent therapy. I've also stopped visiting certain gender-critical forums because of hostility toward men and toward straight women who date men.
I still experience dysphoria—wanting to be male—but I've reframed it. I think of myself as just an animal with an incidentally female body, and that female is a what, not a who. This has genuinely helped. I still feel bitter looking at adolescent boys thinking they get to be people while I didn't, and I still hate being female, mostly for the social treatment rather than the biology. I've thought about suicide in the past in connection with wanting to be male, but I'm still here, and my life is much less miserable since I renounced gender altogether.