Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una ragazza di 15 anni in desistenza che si identificava come maschio trans da circa 13 anni, finché ho sentito parlare di detransizione e mi sono interrogata. Ora mi identifico come lesbica cisgender non conforme al genere e sto prendendo provvedimenti per stare bene con me stessa. La mia identificazione come trans era legata a un'educazione religiosa e misogina, agli abusi di mio fratello, al bullismo, alla misoginia e omofobia interiorizzate, alla depressione, a un disturbo alimentare, all'autolesionismo e a tentativi di suicidio. Non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi e non mi è permesso fare terapia, quindi ho elaborato il mio trauma da sola. Sostengo le persone davvero transgender che fanno la transizione, ma vorrei non averne sentito parlare così giovane e vorrei che ai bambini non conformi al genere venisse offerta l'opzione di essere semplicemente maschiacci.
Storia completa
I was born female, and I'm a 15-year-old desisted girl writing this in June 2021. I want to lay out what led me to identify as a trans male and what it took for me to realize I was cis all along.
I was born to middle-aged, traditional parents. My mother has always been very religious and my father is misogynistic. They were strict and overbearing — no TV or movies above PG, nothing with LGBT themes or characters or a "liberal agenda." I wasn't allowed to leave the house without a parent because, in my mother's words, "you're a girl and you'll get kidnapped." I had to give up skateboarding because my mom yelled at me every time I practiced in the neighborhood or in front of the house without her supervision.
My brother, by contrast, was allowed to do what he wanted — he could watch movies and play video games unmonitored because he was a boy. My dad loved him and learned about his interests so they could do them together. My mom did no such thing for me: if I wasn't interested in playing dolls or dress-up, I wasn't allowed bonding activity or interaction with my parents. I was bullied at school for being the "weird girl" and "basically a boy." My brother was my only friend; he let me play Pokémon and share clothes with him, much to my mother's dismay. My dad started encouraging this, since he always said he wanted another son. He made me internalize masculine stereotypes — that I couldn't cry or enjoy feminine things like other girls if I was going to be this way. I believe this led me to have a mixed-gender early socialization.
That didn't last long. My mother soon became terminally ill and my brother became physically and verbally abusive to me. He cited his hatred of women for his abuses, and I was the only girl he had a power dynamic over. He would tell me that, as a man, he would always be above me — something my mother would always say as well — and that I should kill myself because he wouldn't cry and no one would care. The physical abuse didn't hurt nearly as much as the things he said to me.
My mom was already gaslight-y, guilt-trippy and mentally abusive, but she got worse when she got sick. She refuses proper treatment and acts like she's fine, so I have to take care of her and accompany her on daily errands while she preaches at me — conspiracy theories, religious doctrine, hatred of gay people, hatred of people who get vaccines, how women must be submissive to men. She would also tell me things like if she ever heard a voice telling her to kill me, she would. She'd point out my insecurities and say I was ugly, fat, stupid, antisocial and weird. For my own safety I can do nothing but pretend to agree with her. I live a double life, with my real self living solely within my mind, the internet, and a few close friends whom I came out to six months ago.
Around this time I was realizing to myself that I was a lesbian — a secret I will keep from my mother to my grave. Ironically, my mother pushing femininity and gender roles onto me killed any aspect of femininity I once had. As a closeted lesbian and a girl with traditional masculine interests, I was a prime target for bullying. Some said I was basically a guy, that I'm not attractive to men because that would be gay, and started calling me a male name and pronouns. By then I embraced it. I thought it was the solution to all my problems: my ongoing trauma, internalized misogyny, internalized homophobia, my depression, anxiety, possible undiagnosed personality disorders, body dysmorphia, my eating disorder, me hurting myself and my suicide attempts — I could fix it all by being male. This wouldn't have happened to me if I were a man. My family would love me for who I was. I wouldn't have to care about how I looked or acted. I would be straight.
Thoughts of transition and hatred for my breasts, my hair, my genitals and my voice followed. I manifested dysphoria within myself and obsessed over it, believing transition to be the only way I could ever be happy. I first heard of being transgender at age 11 and thought that must be me. At 13 I was sure. Then, at 15, when I came out as a lesbian to my first real friend group, I became constantly surrounded by trans ideology on the internet. Everyone in that friend group is female and identifies as some form of trans or non-binary, which made my dysphoria feel worsened and more validated. I suspect some of them are in a similar position, but I'm too scared of coming off as an asshole to bring it up.
It took me hearing about detransition to question myself. Nobody on the internet confided in me otherwise — they all strongly affirmed I was trans, and the validation was euphoric, until I began trying to work through my trauma myself (I am not allowed therapy) and realize why I felt the way I did. I still felt masculine, so I confided to a couple of friends that I might be genderfluid. Nobody told me I could be a masculine cis girl. I had to figure that out on my own. I hated my voice because people took female voices less seriously and I got creepy comments when it was high; I hated my breasts because of sexualization and my mother's weird comments about them; I hated my genitals because they remind me I can never escape my trauma or do my life over. Now I'm taking steps to be myself as much as I can, and realizing I didn't have to choose between being a religious, submissive, feminine straight woman and being a man made me just a little less stressed.
I considered talking to a school counselor, but I've always been terrified they'd legally have to tell my parents or get CPS involved, which I think could do more harm than good at this point. I'm embarrassed that I jumped to the conclusion that I must be transgender for so long; I think many people overlook that it's normal for teenagers to have identity crises and little to no sense of self. I am not against actual transgender individuals transitioning, but I wish I personally hadn't heard of it at such a young age. I wish somebody had given me the option to be a tomboy or a masculine cis girl. I hope we can create a world where gender-nonconforming kids can be themselves and traumatized kids can get the help they need, and a better world for young cis tomboys and tomgirls so they don't think they need to change if that's not the right choice for them.