Tutte le storie

Un ragazzo gay nella sua testa, senza bisogno di ormoni

Femmina · Desistito/a221
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/desistito: non ho mai fatto una transizione medica, anche se per un periodo mi sono identificata sperimentalmente come uomo e mi consideravo un uomo gay in un corpo di donna. Ora accetto di essere di sesso femminile come un semplice dato di fatto, come la mia altezza, e sono felicemente sposata con un marito femminile, senza figli per scelta e di una franchezza brusca e sicura di sé. Attribuisco la mia disforia di allora a un'infanzia da bambina genitorializzata, a una madre debole e a un padre manipolatore e alla misoginia interiorizzata, più che a una condizione medica che esiste a prescindere. Sono critica verso la transizione medica dei giovani, verso gli spazi trans-affermativi che zittiscono le domande e verso quella che vedo come una tendenza di casalinghe di mezza età a dichiararsi non binarie. Non ho mai fatto una transizione medica, quindi non descrivo rimpianti chirurgici o ormonali miei, ma ho una profonda comprensione per chi li ha.

Storia completa

I was born female and I have never medically transitioned — that is the first thing I want to be clear about, because I spend a lot of time in detrans spaces and people sometimes assume otherwise. I never medically transitioned and so I'm not in the same position as those who did, but I fully sympathize with those who were and are. I understand the anger, and I don't think telling others how to feel about the trauma they went through is going to be well received. Trauma is traumatic. Scars are for life. Growing up, I hated being female. I was never a girly girl and never will be a girly girl. There are stereotypical female traits that I absolutely hate and do not embrace in any way: acting clueless or silly, simping, makeup, turning everything into a question, being indirect instead of direct. I daydreamed about being a man — being a man might have been easier for me, socially. At one point I was experimentally considering myself a man, and even then it was as a gay man, because I am definitely attracted to men. I assumed I was a gay man in a woman's body. A lot of that, I now think, traces back to my family. My mom was a doormat for a narcissistic and emotionally manipulative dad. They were both highly intelligent people, both PhDs, but as role models and parents they weren't great. My earliest role models of what it means to be male and female were along the lines of women = victims, men = in power. I was a parentified child — I had to take on a somewhat male role in the family because I couldn't trust the adults to make kind or wise decisions, and I felt the drive to protect my mom and siblings. I didn't date anyone until I was 23, because subconsciously I didn't want to end up like my mom. I was extra paranoid about accidentally winding up with a narcissistic asshole, so I was careful about relationships. I had never learned healthy relationship habits, thanks to terrible examples in my life, so I had a lot of trouble attracting kind, intelligent men — thank goodness I managed it later in life, though it took more than a decade. I value financial independence. I really do have a lot of traits that are stereotypically masculine — I tend to be the take-charge, responsible adult in relationships. But as a middle aged woman now, I accept being female as something that is just who I am, like my height and my eye color. I would have rather been born male, with the privileges that entails, and tall. But I don't believe that surgery and HRT can ever get anyone 100% to being a man or a tall person — 90%, sure, and maybe that is enough for most trans people, but it isn't real for me. I'm a woman because of the sexual blueprint I inherited at birth. It's not a feeling. It's not a way of being. It's just a fact, like being short. I no longer believe that gender dysphoria is a free-floating medical condition with no underlying causes, in the same way that alcoholism or eating disorders are not purely physical diseases. There is a psychological component that underlies these things, and it can be really hard to deconstruct and address. When I see young people with dysphoria I find myself wondering why being seen as a woman is so unpleasant — I suspect unexplored internalized misogyny, or a traumatic background, or something else. I also think gender stereotypes are at their worst in Hollywood and similar industries, and that people can internalize sexism that makes being a woman feel very unappealing. I'm happily childfree and happily tech-oriented and very blunt. My husband is feminine and does all the housework. We're happy this way. Lots of people in traditional roles are not so happy. If people come at me with stupid preconceived notions about how I should exist as a woman, eff them. I'm quite critical of how the medical system handles this. The medical system really shouldn't be so blasé about trans children — these are decisions that should be made in fully informed adulthood. I also think it's an ideology: if parents are looking for advice in a trans affirming subreddit but not seeking it in detrans spaces, they're not being unbiased or intellectually honest. Self doubts and questions should not be considered transphobia; when you shut down honest questions and self exploration, you have dogma. I got banned on another sub for mentioning this one. I've noticed what I see as a trend among 40s and 50s white women in my social circles declaring themselves nonbinary — every nonbinary person I know in real life is a housewife, married with kids, and well-off, and they say they're nonbinary when anyone will clearly clock them as a woman. I think they just don't like the invisible feeling of being a middle aged housewife; they want to feel special and they don't like the baggage that comes with being a housewife. I don't particularly like humoring them. I have a friend in her 40s, a housewife and mom who still wears makeup, gets spa treatments, isn't hiding her figure, and takes her kids to soccer practice, who now goes by they. Her oldest child is FTM trans, and I think that may have influenced the mom, and vice versa. The parents are separated but still living together, with a divorce planned for after their youngest leaves for college. I've supported people going either direction. I've told someone considering continuing to transition that if being seen as a woman makes you itch, maybe continuing is the path of least resistance for their future wellbeing — while also cautioning against major surgery as a teen or young adult. I've congratulated someone on finding a partner who lifted them out of the emotional gutter and told them screw societal standards about beauty, no one has to be a Barbie doll. Anger is a common and healthy reaction from people who escape a cult or a high demand religion, and some people are damaged forever — it is a tragedy and there are reasons to be angry about it.