Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition (FTMTF, 23 anni): ho preso testosterone per circa due anni a partire dai 18 e l’ho interrotto di colpo circa due anni fa. Ho fatto detransition perché la socializzazione maschile e il dover gestire di continuo come venivo percepita non valevano la pena, e la terapia mi ha aiutata a capire il trauma infantile e gli ideali dietro il mio odio per l’essere donna. Dopo una consulenza ho evitato la top surgery, ho ancora una voce più bassa e mascolina che in realtà mi piace e ho fatto la depilazione laser dei peli sul viso. Di tanto in tanto mi pento di aver fatto la transizione ma non mi sento rovinata, e oggi mi oppongo fermamente alla transizione fisica, compresi i bloccanti della pubertà, per chiunque abbia meno di 18 anni. Dire alla mia famiglia che stavo facendo detransition è stato più difficile che fare coming out come trans, e ho vissuto momenti imbarazzanti con persone queer che mi scambiavano per una donna trans.
Storia completa
I decided I was trans around 15 and was sure I was meant to be a man. I never envisioned myself as an adult or an old man — I later realized I only wanted to be a young adult man. Growing up Baptist, there was a lot of social pressure to be quiet and grow into a good wife, and I didn't think people took me seriously. I mostly wanted freedom, and I thought men were "allowed" to be independent. I had a lot of physical dysphoria and not very much social dysphoria, and the dysphoria I suffered through puberty and my teenage years was horrible.
I went to a therapist to get my letters to go on testosterone. That therapist was wonderful for non-trans things, but our talks about trans-ness were just "Are you uncomfortable with having a vagina?" "Yes" "Okay great." They told me I had no red flags and was just a straight-up trans person — which, in hindsight, I feel was itself a red flag. I started testosterone around 18 (I was not allowed to transition at all until I was 18) and was on it for about a year and a half to two years. I quit T cold turkey both times I went off it and had no issues psychologically, physically, or sexually, other than slightly more acne and some temporary hormone things like mood swings and libido changes. I never got facial hair from T, but I had enough dark hair on my face that it was noticeable, so I did laser hair removal on my face about two years ago, and I've also done laser on my breasts and stomach. The NP at my laser appointments told me I'd need touch-ups throughout my life.
Being on T and experiencing male socialization is what changed my mind. HRT doesn't magically make you a cisgender guy — you always have that "trans" adjective hanging over you, which stresses you out and makes you overthink using the bathroom and your wardrobe every day. I thought I'd do hormones and be a guy and fit in with cisgender men, understand them, and be able to do the things they do. It just doesn't happen that way. Being treated as a man was super weird and made me very uncomfortable, which was a big part of why I detransitioned. Identifying as trans pointed out all the ways I wasn't cis; admitting I cannot be a cis man and being a trans man felt worse than being a cis woman, and softening the dysphoria that way means it doesn't affect me in most aspects of my life now.
I also seriously considered top surgery and had a consultation. The surgeon asked why I wanted it and I said I wanted to swim and feel more at home in my body. On the drive home I realized I hadn't been swimming in years, I could bind with a sports bra, and I liked my chest during sex. I realized I feel awkward and exposed when I'm not dressed like a nun in public because I didn't pass anyway — I was afraid of being sexualized regardless of how I identified. Top surgery wasn't covered by insurance, so it would have been around 10-20k out of my and my parent's money. Even if I got it, I would never be one of the 6ft cisgender guys I idolized — I'd just look like myself but slightly flatter and down 10k. I got a swimshirt and sports bra instead and was fine swimming from then on. I'm very grateful I decided against the surgery.
I stopped binding recently and bought a couple of bras — a big win — though I've had some random pain in my ribs/breast area since changing my undergarment habits. I've been doing laser hair removal on my facial hair and, the longer I've been off T, the less coarse it's gotten; it's now fine enough that I can use Nair instead of shaving every other day, which lasts all week and makes me feel much better about my skin. I also started going by my middle name because I hate my birth name, and using my middle name gave me a more normalized reason to have a different name.
Therapy after detransition helped me understand why I hated being a woman and what childhood trauma and ideals had been instilled in me that made me wish I was male — I just wish someone had offered those ideas before I took HRT. It took a long time to convince my family that transition was the "right" choice, and I worried about how to tell them it wasn't; I ended up approaching it as a "learning more about myself" thing. Telling my family I was detransitioning was worse than coming out to them as trans. Their response has felt dismissive, like they almost don't believe me and think I'm going to change my mind again. I have a friend who has only socially transitioned and, as the only person they know who medically transitioned, seems to be banking their future hopes on me.
I'm currently a detransitioned woman — 23, off T for about two years, FTMTF. I look like a regular cis girl but my voice is lower and pretty masculine; I actually prefer my post-T voice to my pre-T voice. My identity is still somewhat queer and my partner is a trans girl. I have a good mix of cis and trans friends. Because of my voice, liberal queer people often assume I'm a trans woman, which bothers me — I've had to say "Actually I'm not on estrogen, I'm a cis girl..." I find it obnoxious how much the queer community focuses on what's in someone's pants. On hookup apps I get ghosted about 75% of the time by straight guys after dates, which I assume is because they think I have a penis. Two years off T, my clitoris is back to a pretty standard size — slightly larger than most — and doesn't get hard the same way. Doctors' computer systems still ask me at every appointment if I'm still taking T.
I do regret transitioning from time to time, but I don't believe it ruined my life — one wrong decision doesn't ruin you forever, and I grew as a person in many ways and in my faith that I wouldn't have otherwise. God gave me a different relationship with femininity and my transition was part of the path He put me on. I now believe no one under 18 should physically transition, including puberty blockers and binding; I wasn't allowed to transition until 18 and believe being deterred gave me the space to change my mind later. I keep my mouth shut about this in many aspects of my life, though being open about my detransition experience has opened good conversations with trans friends and family. I support continuing detransition surveys and believe our experiences are beneficial to the trans community. I think insecurity, dysmorphia, and mental illness need to be examined before pushing medical transition, and that there are many reasons people have gender dysphoria beyond being trans.