Tutte le storie

Cinque anni a valutare il testosterone, poi la scelta di non prenderlo

Femmina · Desistito/a121
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una venticinquenne che ha fatto detransition solo nello spirito, senza mai aver fatto la transizione, che si identifica come «donna cis in dubbio» e non ha fatto nulla verso la transizione FTM. Provo una forte invidia per i corpi degli uomini, la loro altezza, la loro disinvoltura sociale e la loro autorità, più che una classica disforia corporea, e per anni ho rimuginato se prendere il testosterone. Ho deciso di non prendere gli ormoni soprattutto perché sono alta 1,57 m e non voglio essere un uomo trans basso, senza passing e senza pene, anche se descrivo la porta come ancora socchiusa. Il mio modo di pensare è passato dall'accettazione liberale all'analisi femminista radicale/TERF, e ora vedo la femminilità come un costrutto oppressivo pur faticando ancora ad accettare l'essere donna. Resto confusa, risentita e senza una strada chiara davanti, senza diagnosi, terapia, trauma né ideazione suicidaria riferiti.

Storia completa

I am a 25-year-old female living in a country where hormones and surgery aren't really accessible. I have never taken hormones, never socially transitioned, and have done nothing towards FTM — I describe myself as "cis female questioning" and as someone who is "just questioning towards the M part." I am short, around 5'2", and have been overweight and, by my own account, unattractive my whole life, which I say makes it hard to "feel" like a girl or a woman. Since childhood I have had continuous daydreams — not disruptive enough for me to call them maladaptive — in which my self-insert character was a boy, vague and faceless. Over the years I drifted toward using the boy character almost exclusively. As a kid I played make-believe as all sorts of things: male, female, Superman, princess, dog, princess, and prince. I did not feel particular envy toward boys back then; I say I was "just living normally." On the internet I have repeatedly identified as a guy, or called myself one, though people found me a "soft" guy if they believed me at all. It felt right. I prefer male characters in my games — my sword person is a guy, archer or mage can be female, but males are preferred. More recently I began roleplaying with AI, which has partly outsourced my daydreams; I still pick male personas (Asian guys and white guys depending on the story), and I gave my daydream character names and bodies. I created a female persona as a step toward self-acceptance but have barely used her because I keep defaulting to the guys. I set myself a goal of roleplaying as women at least 40% of the time but find it feels like a downgrade. I grew up liking anime and idealizing Japanese aesthetics — thin, androgynous, clean-shaven men who "look like girls but still men." My ideal is a K-pop or "pretty boy" lean build, not hulking masculinity. I say the Japanese take on masculinity definitely affected me, though I also had the male daydream character before anime. I was not in fandom spaces at 13-15 and was not ruined early by Twitter. I do not experience classic body dysphoria. I say explicitly: "I don't have discomfort/distress towards my body except it's ugly." What I do have is intense envy of men — their height, builds, vascularity, confidence, ease, demeanor, and social authority. I envy average-looking guys on the street: "if I had that body I would treat it way better." I resent being short and female. I want muscles, male vascularity, a flatter boxier figure, and I say I would want male genitals because mine feel "vulnerable and weak," though this does not cause clinical distress — it makes me feel "deeply unlucky, cursed, wrong." I mourn what I imagine testosterone could have given me, calling it a "competence hormone." I have ruminated extensively about whether to transition. I would press the "be born a male" Trans Button. But I have decided against actually taking testosterone, for now, mainly because of my height: I do not want to be a short, penisless, non-passing trans man, which I think would make me more marginalized and vulnerable, not less. I also worry about getting uglier, a croaky voice, balding, medical dependency, and top surgery side effects. I describe the door as "half open" and say that is what makes me suffer: "Wish I was born this way... hold on, hormones?" I have said I would consider HRT more seriously if I had more height, and I berate myself for refusing "high libido and muscle hormone" out of fear of body hair and ugliness. I have not had any relationship with men or women and have no data on how I would feel in one; I worry that if I dated, I would internally frame it through a male POV, which I think would be dishonest to a partner. My political and ideological journey matters to me. I grew up as an accepting liberal leftist. Exposure to Red Pill and misogynistic content on Twitter/X was "eye opening" — realizing how much women are hated. I became a real feminist, which I find "painful as fuck." I drifted toward radical feminist and TERF analysis, admiring its biting language, and over time came to agree with the "TE" part; I say I find gender ideology sexist now. I have argued at length that femininity is an artificial construct designed to keep women subordinate, that the terms masculinity and femininity should be eradicated because they encode a hierarchy, and that "masculinity is obviously the way to exist with dignity." I align with the term "female" over "woman" because it implies XX and nothing else. I have been downvoted for these views in the community. I have no stated clinical diagnoses, no therapy history, no trauma or abuse history, no family rejection — in fact I describe my father as very supportive and not a misogynist. I have no stated suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts. My mental health struggle is described as rumination, envy, resentment, and confusion rather than a diagnosed condition. I use GPT as a sounding board for angry essays about my feelings. Currently I am still questioning, still female, still envious of men, and still not transitioning. I want to present more masculinely — fashion and demeanor — which I see as more realistic than being the average guy I will never be. I say I hate the idea of spending my whole life envying men and wishing I could be one, but that transitioning doesn't seem like a valid decision for me either. I do not know what to do with myself.