Tutte le storie

Credeva di essere un maschio — prima che essere trans fosse un'opzione

Femmina · Desistito/a233
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/desistenza e non ha mai fatto la transizione medica; sono nata femmina negli anni '80 e per circa metà dell'infanzia ho creduto privatamente di essere un maschio, ma allora essere trans non era un'opzione culturale. Oggi mi identifico semplicemente come maschiaccio e donna, e sono sconvolta all'idea che se fossi cresciuta più tardi in Occidente probabilmente sarei stata spinta alla transizione. Consiglio ai giovani disforici e in dubbio di fare una terapia regolare, di affrontare i traumi di fondo e i problemi di salute mentale e di evitare interventi irreversibili. Ho partorito e gestisco i cicli abbondanti con la pillola anticoncezionale. Non dichiaro rimpianti, ideazione suicidaria o autolesionismo.

Storia completa

I was born female, and I grew up in the 1980s — I've said plainly, "I too was born in the eighties." Trans identity was not something in the culture when I was growing up, so I never transitioned; instead I kept a private belief to myself: "I never conformed to the stereotypes, I thought for probably half of my life that I was a boy." I describe myself as having always been a tomboy, and I still am. I don't frame what I experienced as dysphoria. When someone asked me to clarify, I said, "I wouldn't call my experience a dysphoria. I just believed that I was a boy. And I kept this belief a secret, at the back of my head. It would surface at times when I would be comparing myself with other girls or boys... and would see all the 'masculine' traits in me: aggression, leadership, STEM-alignment, etc. Hatred for everything 'feminine': make up, fashion, small talk, drooling over guys. A tomboy." My family pushed hard conformity. My parents would scold me for "looking not feminine enough," and then, once I did look feminine enough, they would "compliment" me by saying I could go earn money in the red light district — I called that "F*cking gross." I tried "performing my gender" briefly during my teens but felt "super weird," and attention from men didn't help either. I was "always the weird one," unable to understand my classmates' behaviour and priorities. What helped me stay true to myself, in retrospect, was "associating with the subcultures where nonconformity was praised and valued — punks, goths, metalheads." I never went fully into those scenes, but seeing them in the city, talking to them online, and "headbanging besides them validated my sense of self." Sometimes I try to adopt their style so my outside matches the inside, but then I "just feel weirdly exposed." Other supports: sports and training gave me "connection to my body" and a circle of friends outside my classmates; time and studies kept my mind busy away from intrusive body thoughts; and I eventually "moved far far away from my parents" and am "very fine with myself now." I also credit having "a no-fucks attitude" and simply not conforming. I have never been on hormones or had any transition-related surgeries. On the medical side, I did have heavy periods as a teen that were manageable, and after giving birth they became unmanageable — heavy bleeding, staining towels, two packs of pads a week — so I went on birth control pills, which after some trial made my periods much lighter and shorter. I have given birth, so I have at least one child; I post on r/detrans partly "as a mom." I now think of myself simply as "a desister and a woman" — "So I never was trans, and as such I never 'stopped' being trans. I'm just me, this is how I am." I am horrified by the current culture of medical transition for young people: "should I have been born later and in the West, I'd be transed. Horrified by the rushing to affirm unrealistic teen fantasies, by the destroying of self and body while lying that this will somehow help feel better. It won't." I believe kids need "good role models, mental health care, programs to help families and children, anti-bullying programs. Not hormones or surgeries." I am quite active in advising dysphoric and questioning young people, especially on r/detrans. My advice generally includes: don't base identity on something fragile; work with a regular (non-gender) therapist on underlying trauma; consider that dysphoria often co-occurs with "autism, OCD, ADHD, depression, anxiety"; get off the internet, which is "too toxic for vulnerable people"; occupy yourself with real-world activities; and treat trans identity as "a performance, a coping mechanism... an identity to hide under" whose root causes (sexual trauma, strict gender roles, internalized homophobia, other mental conditions) need to be addressed directly. I've told people considering surgery that "Periods are temporary, surgery is forever" and warned that after surgery "you'll be a medical patient for the rest of your life." I've also advised people not to voice their doubts to trans-identified friends, saying "they will just push you to take the surgery." I don't describe myself as experiencing regret, since I never transitioned; my emotional stance is more one of horror at what might have happened to me and sympathy for those who did transition. I have no stated suicidal ideation, self-harm, or mental health diagnoses of my own.