Tutte le storie

Sei anni di disforia risolti dalla terapia del trauma

Femmina · Desistito/aPrima disforia 19 → Transizione sociale 19 → Desistenza 253,4K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Mi sono identificata come non binaria per circa sei anni, dai 19 ai 25, e ho desistito senza mai fare una transizione medica: ho preso in considerazione testosterone e top surgery e portavo un binder, ma non ci sono mai arrivata. La mia disforia, soprattutto per il seno, derivava da un'aggressione sessuale in adolescenza più omofobia e misoginia interiorizzate; la terapia del trauma (compresa l'EMDR) iniziata a 25 anni l'ha in gran parte risolta. Ora mi identifico come donna omosessuale (lesbica) che ha desistito, non conforme al genere e senza alcuna identità di genere, e a 30 anni sto molto meglio mentalmente. Prima della terapia avevo un'ideazione suicidaria passiva legata alla disforia al petto, che dopo si è in gran parte fermata. Sono critica verso i bloccanti della pubertà, il «sesso del cervello» e l'erosione della parola lesbica, ma ho compassione per il mio io del passato e per le persone che fanno la transizione.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up in what I now describe as a traumatic girlhood — I was sexually assaulted as a teenager, an experience that haunted me for more than ten years before I ever dealt with it directly. I also grew up Christian, and in high school I was the sober, sexless girl trying to avoid what I felt was inevitable heterosexual sex, a closeted lesbian in denial while my female friends experimented with drugs and sex. I started shaving around age 14 and stopped in my twenties. I didn't question my gender at all until I went to college. There I met other trans people in real life for the first time, learned that being nonbinary was an option, and around age 19 I went from questioning and "cis" to queer and nonbinary. I used they/them pronouns and was, in my own words, "gung-ho" about it — firm but polite about pronouns, making waves in office culture in my early twenties. I identified as nonbinary for about six years, ages 19 to 25. I never medically transitioned: I considered testosterone and top surgery, wore a binder (though not extensively enough to cause noticeable change), but never went through with either. I'm grateful I didn't. Looking back, I understand the nonbinary identity as a coping mechanism. I was a traumatized, neurotic, closeted lesbian, and I found a way to be something other than what I was. I took my despair at being sexualized, objectified, and violated and projected it onto despair at being a woman. I didn't want to believe I was using gender identity to cope with trauma, because I find it abhorrent when people insist someone is gay because they were assaulted — but I think this is different. I was interested in girls long before a boy touched me; I just didn't question my gender until college gave me the vocabulary. Girlhood was traumatic, so I was terrified of womanhood. I also felt I wasn't feminine enough to be an ideal woman and wasn't confident enough in my nonconformity to be like the butch women I admired, so I felt I couldn't be a woman, or at least not fully. Around age 19 I also entered the polyamorous world almost by default — the people I was interested in were partnered and in open relationships. I was with three trans women over the years (A, B, and D), plus a fourth partner (C) who wasn't trans. It was on-again, off-again, long-distance at times, and complicated. I haven't done polyamory since breaking up with D in 2019 and don't intend to again. I was diagnosed with panic attack disorder and had undiagnosed OCD, PTSD, and ADHD at the time. I also had what I now recognize as HOCD and sexuality OCD — years of agonizing over "What am I really?", whether my past relationships with men were compulsory heterosexuality (they were), whether I was bisexual (I'm not), and whether I was a bad person for only wanting same-sex relationships. I did compulsive, failed "DIY conversion therapy" on myself, trying to unpack my genital preference, which made me miserable. I obsessed over whether I was harming lesbians or hurting trans women by identifying the way I did. I hated myself. The turning point came at age 25, when I finally started therapy for the sexual trauma that had been haunting me for over a decade. I found a therapist who specializes in sexual trauma and EMDR, and she is firmly on my side that I don't need to "unpack" my genital preference. Trauma therapy is what let me come back to my body: the dysphoria around my breasts — which was 100% about the assault, not about the breasts themselves — essentially vanished. I stopped blaming my body for what somebody else did to it. I also did grounding body-scan meditations in therapy, which were hard at first (I cried a lot when I realized how difficult it was to describe my sensations) but improved over time. The pandemic was, in my metaphor, the nail in the coffin. By 2019-2020 I was already on my way out because of homophobia I'd experienced in queer community — friends who didn't accept same-sex attraction and gave me grief for not liking penis — and then COVID put things in perspective: as long as the people I love are alive to tell me they love me, what does it matter what they call me? I desisted around age 25. I tearfully told my mom I'd realized I'd been afraid of being a woman because being a girl was traumatic; she met me with nothing but love, no "I told you so." My dad said he figured I'd get there eventually and hadn't wanted to push me. Both had been supportive throughout — my mom is a librarian who always found books about whatever I was into, including when I identified as nonbinary. What helped most was reading radical feminism rather than just blocking anyone who disagreed, and re-discovering feminism generally — therapy and feminism healed me more solidly than queer theory did. I also had the benefit of knowing older butch lesbians through my parents; without those role models I think I'd still feel lost. The core intellectual shift was divorcing "woman" from gender entirely. I came to understand "woman" as the dictionary definition — an adult female human being, a mature human of the sex that produces ova — the way a mare is an adult female horse or a hen an adult female chicken. It says nothing about personality, interests, style, or social roles. That freed me from trying to perform womanhood. I now say I don't have a gender identity at all; cis and trans are a false dichotomy that presumes everyone has a gender. When people ask my pronouns I say it doesn't matter to me anymore as long as the intent is respectful. I'm a teacher, and I'm open with my students: "I identified as nonbinary for about 6 years and used they/them but now I don't have a gender identity. My sex is female and I made my peace with that." I tell students they can talk to me about gender and that I'll defend their self-expression, while gently emphasizing that gender is a social construct and the people who love them love who they are, not what they are. I also apologized to coworkers who had worked hard on my pronouns, telling them I hoped they didn't feel it was for nothing; they were chill, some relieved. I kept my chosen name, Maxwell (Max), as a nickname alongside my given name — my work nickname is a mashup of the two — but I never legally changed it and I'm glad, since I'd hate to lose my middle name. I introduce myself with my given name to strangers. These days I'm a gender nonconforming, homosexual (lesbian), female woman. I shave nothing, let my body hair grow, wear clothes from the men's section for the pockets, reject heels and flats, wear a kippah nearly every day and ask barbers to keep my faux-payot when they shave my head, and keep a dead bat preserved in lucite next to my bed alongside my plushies. I still have feminine mannerisms and I love singing low and swearing. I'm now 30 (as of May 2025) and in a much better place mentally than I was. I did experience passive suicidal ideation tied to my chest dysphoria — thoughts like "if I got breast cancer and needed a double mastectomy I wouldn't be too upset" — which mostly stopped after proper trauma therapy. I also had a period where I was so self-monitoring I couldn't stop imagining myself in the third person and found myself swatting at the imaginary voyeur; therapy helped with that too. On relationships: I went on a couple of dates with a detrans woman who had been on T and had top surgery and found her unmistakably and attractively a woman. I've dealt with internalized lesbophobia and the "predatory lesbian" stereotype, which I had to actively eject from my mind. I've also experienced a friendship breakup with trans friends over these issues that left me flabbergasted at how they spoke to me, though I've since found better friends. I've never medically transitioned, so I'm careful to say I desisted rather than detransitioned, and I try to hold compassion for my past self — she had her heart in the right place but was traumatized and misguided. I do worry about people I see as having been misled, and I've been critical of puberty blockers (I don't think interrupting a developmental stage is safe, worrying about arrested mental and emotional development), of the culture that nudges minors toward threatening suicide to get transition, of "brain sex" as junk science, and of the erosion of the word lesbian. I was banned from me_irlgbt for being active here. I posted an article about a woman who pretended to be nonbinary to expose a medical scandal at Kaiser Permanente, and I noted that Plume advertised on Tumblr, "a social media chock full of young women with autism and or adhd." I'm not opposed to medical transition for others — I think it can relieve real pain — but I don't believe it makes someone literally the other sex, and I think detransition or desisting should never require a return to gender conformity.