Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I am neurodivergent — I have ADHD, and I also deal with OCD and BPD. English is my second language, so please forgive any grammar mistakes.
My dysphoria started when I was growing up with male friends. They had this connection and happiness I felt I couldn't achieve: they could skate, go out at night, have sleepovers, be gross, play video games. I thought I couldn't do those things as a girl because it was either not accepted or dangerous. I always idealized boyhood because it seemed so carefree — stereotypically you can do whatever you want, go places without being randomly sexualized or mocked. I envied that, because women "simply can't." I never fit in with girls, only with boys.
Then YouTube started recommending me videos from Kalvin Garrah, Storm Ryan, Noah Fince and similar creators, and I became hyperfixated on trans topics — my ADHD makes me prone to hyperfixations, which is also, I think, what makes neurodivergent people so "loyal" to a belief once they hold it. YouTube then recommended "egg_irl meme compilation" videos, and if you know that subreddit you know how that goes — the brainwashing is crazy. I was obsessed with those YouTubers and their relationships with each other; Ryan and Kalvin had an ideal "brotherhood" that I craved. I essentially triggered my own dysphoria. The cherry on top was egg_irl, because no "cis" person is going to question their gender, right? No "cis" person has ever experienced dysphoria! I came to believe that being trans was the explanation.
I have lurked a lot in eating disorder communities, and the way they affirm and encourage others, and how they act and feel, is very similar to what trans spaces do. That comparison is part of what made me question things.
I don't have a detailed medical timeline in what I've shared publicly, but I have spoken about detransitioning and about how gender dysphoria is an awful, debilitating condition that is really hard to get "cured" — even people who pass and have lived as trans for years experience it, and the same is true for many detransitioners. I believe the pain gets lower the more you learn to accept yourself and understand the condition and your own life. I've encouraged others to try therapy again with a new psychologist if the first one didn't help, because I seriously believe anyone can motivate themselves to keep living and get out of depression with the right time and attention.
I now think gender dysphoria is a mental illness that can be a sign of underlying conditions such as depression or autism. Most of us in the detrans community are autistic or neurodivergent, and I'd urge people to get scanned for autism — us girls get underdiagnosed because of sexism. I also think gender dysphoria gets more attention because the trans community is centered around it, while most of us struggle with other mental illnesses first. I've suggested that a possible better treatment for therapy-resistant sex dysphoria could be a personal physical transition without switching to opposite-sex pronouns, terms, or calling yourself the opposite sex.
I distinguish sharply between being gay and being trans. Gay people never desist — gayness is a tendency, not a belief, and it doesn't have to affect your style, expression, voice, hobbies, friend groups, or body structure. Being trans affects every action and has to have harmful side effects; it's a set of beliefs, not tendencies. I don't like being grouped with a type of people that has affected me and others physically and mentally just because of my homosexuality. I believe normal therapy on dysphoric people works but isn't encouraged because the fast answer is HRT and plastic surgery, and in some places there isn't even a full two-year diagnostic anymore.
I don't think acknowledging biological sex is wrong, and I think people in trans discourse have a cult mentality. I've tried to reach people by using analogies, explaining carefully and nicely, and trying to reach conclusions together — that's what has helped me and others understand detransition, gender nonconformity, and the harms of trans activism. When someone asked about a sister who was questioning her gender, I suggested getting to know her better emotionally and helping with the depression first, since transitioning is almost always based on underlying issues apart from gender dysphoria.
I've also dealt with mental health struggles of my own: my OCD and BPD make it hard for me to smoke even when friends do, and I get paranoid when I'm high, so I avoid it even with friends because I'd rather be side-eyed for a minute than feel like I'm dying mentally for six or seven hours. I've advised someone else in crisis to tell their mental health professionals they were considering suicide and to ask their parents to switch doctors if the current ones weren't helping.
I've been active in the detrans community, thanking people for their videos, and I've expressed happiness when I see other detransitioners doing well — one woman in particular I called beautiful and said I was happy she's helping so many people. When I saw someone post a story similar to mine, only a year apart, I was glad they had found themselves.
I don't regret transition in a way I've spelled out publicly, but I do see the whole pipeline — the YouTube recommendations, egg_irl, the craving for male friendship — as something I did to myself, and I've described it as "the brainwashing is CRAZY" with an "ugh" at the end. I'm still working on accepting myself and understanding the condition.