Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto la transizione sociale per essere accettato dagli amici LGBT e sfuggire allo stigma di essere un uomo bianco cis, ma ho fatto detransition quando ho capito che potevo avere dei privilegi ed essere comunque una brava persona, e che la mia preferenza per abiti e comportamenti femminili non richiedeva di cambiare genere. Oggi mi identifico come maschio cisgender, femminile, androgino, skater e gamer, e sto bene con questa identità, senza fastidio se mi sbagliano genere o mi scambiano per non binario. Non provo disforia di genere né parlo di interventi medici in questi post, quindi non sono dettagliati rimpianti medici specifici. Ho opinioni critiche ma sfumate sulla cultura trans moderna, credendo che possa rafforzare stereotipi di genere regressivi e che l'affermazione cieca faccia danni, pur rispettando il fatto che alcune persone siano davvero trans. Sostengo che le persone dovrebbero essere non conformi al genere all'interno del proprio sesso di nascita piuttosto che fare la transizione per adattarsi ai ruoli sociali.
Storia completa
I am a detransitioned male. I started to socially transition because I wanted to fit into the ever-growing group of LGBT friends I had, and also because the cis white man is often painted as the villain of just about everything. Being told you're part of a wider societal problem by being cis, white, and a man hurt, and transitioning meant I would no longer be part of that societal problem. I acknowledge I have privilege in those areas, but what made me detransition was accepting that I can have privilege in all those areas and still be a good person.
I am comfortable being a feminine man. Pink and purple are my favourite colours, I like low-flowing clothes, and I buy a lot of my clothes from the women's section — not because I identify as a woman, but because I like how they look. Women's jeans come in more colours than men's, so I buy them, and it means nothing for my gender. I shave my armpit hair, wear women's jeans, cardigans, and eyeliner, and people genuinely assume I'm non-binary because of it, but I'm not — I'm just an overgrown emo kid. I identify as a skater and gamer far above identifying as a man. I don't really think about my gender except in the context of the society it's placed in; it isn't an innate feeling of 'me'. If someone calls me she on the phone, which happens a lot, I don't care — I just acknowledge my voice isn't as deep as most men's and move on. I don't get feelings of insecurity around it. I have never woken up and thought 'I feel like a man today'. What makes me a man is all the life experience I've had that correlates with those shared by other men.
I don't identify strongly as a man because I don't really know what a man means now that it doesn't mean adult human male, and I actually have way more feminine traits than masculine. It's really liberating to know that as a male I can act however I want with no expectation to act a certain way. I'm comfortable being a feminine man because most men are, they just don't want to admit it because they think it makes them weak, which I consider misogynistic.
I resonate more with the detrans community, but I recognise we're not a monolith and not always right. I think both the trans and detrans communities have problems, constantly being at war with each other, and that the truth of what society needs is somewhere in the middle. Trans people need to be respected and listened to, and not every trans person is making a mistake, but some people are misunderstanding something like body dysmorphia for gender dysphoria, and asking for more safety precautions isn't necessarily transphobic if done maturely. I believe blind affirmation causes more detransition cases and harms the case for transitioning. I think if someone believes being trans is innate and unwavering but is themselves detrans, they got it wrong at some point, so they should support a non-affirming, investigative approach since they know better than anyone that people don't always know who they are.
I have a partner who came out as non-binary and, by their own admission, behaved like a cartoon man when they first came out because they only knew what being a man was based on sexist stereotypes. I know a lot of Gen Z people through my work; not one of them identifies as a tomboy or tomgirl, but a lot of them identify as non-binary, and I don't think it's a coincidence that non-binary gained ground as tomboy/tomgirl lost ground. I think autistic people tend to categorise experiences into belonging to a male or female group, and stacking enough atypical behaviours leads them to conclude they must be trans, when really non-binary is just the standard human experience of not being 100% masculine or feminine. I think a lot of autistic people, especially young females going through puberty where sexualisation is more intense and uncomfortable, gravitate towards non-binary identity as a way to make sense of themselves and belong to a group. I believe some autistic people are genuinely trans, but most who identify as non-binary aren't.
I think modern trans culture reinforces gender roles and is in some ways regressive, assuming you're the opposite gender because you fall into the roles of the opposite gender, which is counterproductive and reinforces sexist stereotypes. It's misogynistic to assume that any masculine behaviour a girl exhibits makes her a man, and equally misogynistic to assume a feminine man is weak and therefore a woman. I think it's far more liberating for a woman to like male-dominated things without thinking she must be a man. I don't have gender dysphoria, and if someone doesn't feel discomfort when referred to as anything, that's probably a sign they don't have gender dysphoria either and aren't trans. I don't experience regret about specific medical interventions because I don't discuss undergoing hormones or surgeries in these posts — my detransition was primarily social and identity-based. I currently identify as a cisgender, feminine, androgynous male and am comfortable in that identity.