Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I grew up in a liberal home with an immigrant mother, and looking back I understand that my gender dysphoria had roots in internalized homophobia and misogyny. My family enforced the idea that stereotypes about gay people — that gay men are effeminate and gay women masculine — were incorrect and offensive, but in reality they were just uncomfortable with effeminate men and masculine women. My appearance was strictly controlled and I was never allowed to cut my hair. My mom had her own discomfort with the female gender role and femininity; my first trips to buy bras and explanations of periods were overcast by her shame, with the underlying theme that we all wished these things about our bodies didn't exist but had to deal with them.
I also have trauma from a sexual assault and from emotional abuse, plus what I describe as the trauma that comes from being a lesbian in a world where my experience is an afterthought. These experiences left me struggling with dissociation from my body and a feeling of being lost in a world where nobody would look out for me but me. I looked for an answer to my alienation and loneliness, and being transgender or nonbinary fit right in, because in my experience it can explain any deep pain.
Queer ideology and social circles were a major factor. I went to a queer youth group starting from when I was a young teen until my lower 20s, beginning around age 13 or 14. Most of the female-assigned people there identified as trans. This was my first exposure to the idea, and it was hammered home both in person and online that if you're a good person you don't question anyone's gender identity, and that you don't base your sexuality on physical anatomy but on gender identity. From about 13 until about 23 I believed these ideas with my whole heart. I had five female-assigned gay friends in high school and four of them transitioned. Two of my gay friends transitioned medically suddenly in their lower 20s, and I know one of them did it during a prolonged manic episode.
My first night at the queer youth group, I immediately was interested in a girl I saw who introduced herself with male pronouns. She was butch but not medically transitioned, and it was surprising and hard for me at first, but I caught on because I wanted to be good and wanted friends. Experiencing crushes on trans men led me to believe for a very long time that I liked "men." I honestly believe I wouldn't have entered relationships with cis males if this manipulation hadn't been present. I identified as bi/pan/queer from young teenage years until around 22. I practiced forcing myself to "see" people "as their gender" even when signs of their natal sex were present, and I policed my own thoughts about who I was attracted to to conform to what queer theory told me was a good person.
I never medically transitioned. I did not take hormones or have any surgeries. In my early 20s I began to express masculinity, and it felt totally different than the feminine mask I'd been wearing until that point. This was when I began to double down on my belief that I was trans, and I may have pursued it much further. I had friends who'd tell me I "couldn't be cis" because of my understanding of trans experiences.
What changed everything was coming across detransitioned people online through a real-life friend connection to someone who desisted. My mind was pretty much blown — nobody used to talk about detransition at all, or about dissatisfaction, unpredictability, or dangers with medical transition. In my earlier 20s I read an account of a young detransitioner and the whole "born in the wrong body" framework crashed to pieces for me. I also read a personal essay by Max Robinson about transition and detransition on 4thwavenow that changed my life when I read it about six years ago; it was the first time I'd ever heard of detransition. I felt totally betrayed by the amorphous queer "community" that had told me nobody regrets or reverses transition and that everyone has an innate gender identity findable with enough soul searching.
A specific "aha" moment came from reading a personal essay by a young 20s detrans lesbian who'd had surgical and hormonal intervention beginning in her teens, about the relationship abuse she experienced from a trans woman and how not being able to name that her partner was male left her lost. I had been identifying as a lesbian for a few years by then and was inclusive of trans women in my definition of lesbian. My system was shocked when I realized I'd been manipulated into being sexually open to males through the loophole gender identity presented. This issue — pressure for lesbians to accept trans women as sexual partners — was specifically what led me to read radfem material and to my realization that I don't believe in gender identity.
I eventually lost all my friends from the queer youth group because I shared a comic on my Tumblr by a detransitioner about wishing her therapist had told her that not feeling like a woman can be a result of trauma. My FTM friend confronted me and said I was transphobic if I wouldn't date a trans woman. That friendship remains unrepaired.
I came to the conclusion that I don't see how gender dysphoria is different from any other kind of body dysmorphia, and that the concept of gender identity no longer has influence in my life. My life has greatly improved since I've decided to live that way. I now identify as desisted — I don't identify as cis or trans at all, I don't identify with the cis/trans framework. I'm a butch lesbian. What I'm certain of is that my body is biologically female. I've identified as butch for almost a decade and as a lesbian for about 11 years as of 2024. I thought I was bi from ages 12 to 21.
I have PTSD, which has caused black-and-white thinking that therapists have helped me work on. I also have OCD. I take Zoloft, which I find very helpful, especially with therapy added. I've had three different therapists over the past five or so years, one from a specifically LGBT org, and they all heard and understood and supported me. My current therapist is totally supportive of my views and agrees with many of them. I also do a virtual DBT group, which I joined last year and find very helpful; DBT has been life changing for me. I got into reiki when I was into trans stuff and found it a life-changing experience that helped my health, so I have more spirituality now than when I was young, though I was raised atheist.
On causes, I point to internalized homophobia and misogyny, trauma including sexual assault and emotional abuse, queer ideology and social circles, and broader cultural misogyny. I also think people drawn to escapism and vivid imaginations may be drawn to transition — I loved Warrior Cats as a kid and read them endlessly, and I think people who dove into fantastical worlds wholeheartedly may have been more likely to be drawn to transition. I see transition as a coping mechanism and as socially contagious in the sense that the reaction to body/gender feelings becomes the contagious part. I also relate my breast dysphoria partly to being a flat-chested child and not wanting the big change of puberty.
I have a fraught relationship with body modification generally — I've viewed modifying my body as evidence of being ashamed of it because of beauty standards, and I think I'm not a good candidate for transition because I have body dysmorphia and long-standing issues with plastic surgery. I have a lot of sensory trouble with my breasts; I gave up wearing bras when I was trans-identified but now wear sports bras for working out and True & Co or nothing otherwise because other bras cause pain and panic. I don't shave. I have tattoos and enjoy modifying my body in those ways but resist steroids for health reasons.
Menstruation has been a major ongoing issue. My period started at age 11 and the pain became such a persistent monthly problem that I couldn't keep up with team sports. My athletic performance declined, I gained weight and no height, and adult coaches only cared about winning meets. I came in last at the last track meet I attended the year I got my period because of pain, and that was the beginning of coming in last every race. I plan my life around my period and relate to my sex almost as a chronic illness.
I've experienced significant social isolation and ostracism from my old queer friends, most of whom are now trans. I'm outcast from many of them. I've been called a TERF more times than I can count for doing nothing, and one of my partners and I received months of online and in-person harassment for being "terfs" just because we are gay. I've been put on the spot many times about my gender beliefs in progressive spaces, and as a person of color I sometimes feel white people seek my validation in a way that makes me uncomfortable. I was harassed by young boys as a child — squirted in the face with a spray bottle and asked "are you a boy or a girl." I was in a female-only detrans online space several years ago that was a very toxic, hostile-to-men environment, and I later got involved peripherally with a radical feminist detransition crowd that I had to leave due to interpersonal abuse by a woman named Dev (Devorah Zahav); I describe that group as cult-like.
I had an abusive relationship with a man as a lesbian, which nobody around me could see, and that hurt and informed my worldview for a long time. I've ended up in sexual situations with trans women simply due to social pressure and the way I internalized that to convince myself I was into both sexes. I'm currently in a long-term relationship with a woman; I've had a non-binary partner for almost 2 years and a current girlfriend. I'm still polyamorous. I've had an IUD removed.
On regret: I don't regret hormones or surgeries because I never medically transitioned. What I regret is the manipulation — how I was manipulated by trans ideology and social circles, and by our larger culture of misogyny and gaslighting women and gay people. I find the realization that the gender ideology I believed in was predicated on manipulative pillars to be traumatizing. I feel anger and grief about lost time in queer ideology, about blocked understanding of my own lesbianism, and about losing friendships. I also have guilt and shame about feeling like a burden for not sharing prevailing beliefs. The pain of social isolation from not believing in gender is something I say is why a lot of people stay believing.
I've done some advocacy in the sense of sharing detransition resources, posting on this subreddit, and being outspoken, though I say I don't soapbox. I had an activist job in my past life. I posted one thread about myths regarding age 25 and brain maturity. I recommend DBT, therapy, women's festivals, the Lesbian Connection magazine, and lesbian feminist blogs to others. I attend women's music festivals regularly and find being topless among women life-changing for my body image.
My current views: I believe people must do what they must to get through this life, so it's not my place to judge or prescribe behavior to others, and I respect others' choices. At the same time I hold dialectically that transition is harmful and that I don't believe in "true trans," while also respecting what other people need. I'm critical of medical transition, puberty blockers, and youth medicalization, and I sympathize with those looking to change laws to prevent transition though I'm unsure if that's the right path. I don't think an individual trans person is violent against women solely by being trans. I don't use the word "cis" for myself but think calling it a slur is childish. I'm currently in a more solitary lifestyle but was more social until recently, usually in queer circles as a lesbian, where I was almost always the only GNC female using "she." I'm an artist — visual art is my main joy in life — and I've worked as a nude model at a local art university.