Tutte le storie

A guardare il dibattito da fuori, difendendo il diritto di parola dei detransitioner

Maschio · Desistito/a342
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un maschio biologico a mio agio nell'identificarmi come uomo e non descrivo una transizione o detransition personale. Anni fa ho provato una certa invidia verso l'altro sesso, ma l'ho risolta col tempo e grazie alla relazione con la mia compagna. Sostengo il diritto dei detransitioner di fare la transizione, la detransition e di parlare delle proprie esperienze, e critico l'ostilità nei loro confronti. Incoraggio i giovani ad accettare il proprio corpo col tempo invece di prendere misure drastiche. Non ho descritto alcuna transizione medica, condizione di salute mentale o ideazione suicidaria.

Storia completa

I was born male and have identified as a man my whole life. I don't have a personal transition or detransition story to tell — I come to this community mostly as someone who comments and supports others. What I do have is a long-standing set of views about gender, bodies, and the pressures people face, which I've shared over time. I've told people going through puberty not to do anything drastic, saying that people tend to accept their body and who we are as they age, and that males hate their bodies too. I've advised someone struggling with dating to get off dating apps because they 'will destroy you' and instead join team sports and activities to meet women. I've asked people whether they have any kind of social circle, however small. On gender itself, I've argued against broad generalizations — I pushed back on the idea that 'a woman will never be as strong and as smart as a man,' pointing out that I'm a bio male who has met blindingly smart women and admirably strong ones, and that sex determines nothing; abilities count for nothing if you don't employ them. I've also commented on sexual aggression, saying that girls face sexual aggression from men but shrug it off, and describing an anecdote about women acting sexually forward with gay men. I've reflected on my own position in relation to gender envy. I told someone to change their 'envy' to admiration, saying I was many years ago in a similar position but changed my mind over time. I described my significant other as 'the other side of this my coin, unfathomably beautiful, and she was made for me as I was made for her,' and said 'this gender was bestowed upon me at birth, and probably if I was born the other I would be in a similar position, wishing for what I don't have.' That suggests I experienced some envy of the other sex in the past but resolved it through time and through my relationship. I've been broadly supportive of people's right to detransition, calling criticism of detransitioners 'covert misandry and sectary behaviour' and arguing that each person does this for their own wellbeing, and if they realize they never needed to transition and feel comfortable being who they were born as, that's their right, including their right to talk about it. I've also expressed sympathy for people who've been betrayed or mistreated, saying 'you can put the other cheek and walk away, and still some people will stab you in the back for the shit of it.' I've commented supportively on people's appearance and transition progress, telling one person that on first glance they look like a guy but up close I can see clear feminine traits and that they're 'on the right path,' and reassuring them that people will slowly start referring to them as a girl. I've also complimented many posters' photos. I don't discuss any medical interventions, surgeries, hormone use, therapy, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, or fertility concerns in these posts. I don't describe myself as detransitioned or as having transitioned at any point. My current identity is that of a man who is comfortable with the sex he was born as, supportive of detransitioners' rights, and generally encouraging of people to accept themselves over time rather than take drastic action.