Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che ha fatto detransition, che ha fatto la transizione sociale e medica a partire dai primi vent'anni dopo essere stata attratta da Tumblr, dalla teoria queer e dalle comunità trans, sottoponendomi in circa un decennio a top surgery, isterectomia (con ovaie conservate) e falloplastica completa. Dopo la falloplastica, andata bene fisicamente, ho capito che l'intera narrazione della «discrepanza corpo/cervello» era falsa e mi sono disillusa dalla transizione, smettendo il testosterone intorno al 2022 e scegliendo di continuare a vivere socialmente come uomo, dato che la detransition sociale non mi darebbe nulla. Ho passato circa un anno a piangere il mio corpo originale e mi sono ripresa da un decennio di malattie croniche che collego allo stress dell'epoca della transizione, e ora mi sento felice, in salute e ottimista, pur restando arrabbiata per il tempo, i soldi e il rischio per la fertilità. Sono critica verso l'ideologia di genere e l'assistenza affermativa e ho cercato ricerche detrans da presentare in ambito universitario. Attualmente mi identifico come una femmina che vive come uomo, un «immigrato nella mascolinità», e avrei fatto detransition del tutto se fossi stata più all'inizio del percorso.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up fine being a girl — proud of beating boys at games, generally unfeminine, and not thinking anything was wrong with my body beyond normal teenage body image concerns. Puberty was uncomfortable, and developing breasts knocked me down: I didn't like feeling vulnerable, sexualized (especially by adults), or like people would take me less seriously. I dressed to hide my body, and after moving to a small town away from friends I was treated like an outcast for being "ugly" aka unfeminine. I moved back to my hometown, started dressing better once I figured out I liked girls, and chose any opportunity to get out of women's spaces — but I didn't think I wasn't female, just gay. I was a GNC/butch lesbian.
Being trans didn't occur to me until I met trans people after moving to a city post-high school and found social media where I could lurk trans community spaces. I initially rejected the idea of transitioning FTM and identified with what we'd now call non-binary (I used "genderqueer" before that term was in use) for about 4 years, but eventually realized I was only using that identity out of fear of being seen as lesser for being perceived as a man in my circles. I started binding when encouraged by trans people I met in college — I was large and binding hurt. After two years of identifying as neither male nor female and struggling with binders, I decided to get top surgery. I did an enormous amount of research, didn't avoid gender critical ideas (I started as a radical feminist so my opinion of men was extremely negatively biased and I didn't want to become a man), and constantly asked myself if this was really true or just me running from body image issues or low self-esteem. In hindsight I was in serial abusive relationships where nobody believed I was the one experiencing violence because my partners were very feminine women, I was constantly told I had honorary male privilege as a butch woman, and none of my friendships or familial relationships were stable or healthy. My life was a mess and I had no idea, so I couldn't perceive the source of my bodily alienation.
Despite my best efforts, I had a mastectomy while still identifying as genderqueer — before changing my name or gender marker — and started testosterone a month after surgery. I immediately regretted the surgery; my body looked raw and bloody, though I healed extremely well with great outcomes. I was disturbed that part of me was disposed of in a medical waste bin after routine breast cancer testing came back negative. I tapered onto T injections (starting at .25mg/ml, up to .75, back down to .6), got off injections after 2 years as I became avoidant about shots, moved to topicals and then creams, went back to injections briefly, then back to creams until I quit. I was on testosterone for about 8.5–9 years total, started when I was nearly 24 and fully developed (no puberty blockers ever). I was "transed by tumblr and queer theory in post secondary at 23."
T gave me energy, acted as a mild antidepressant, changed my attention span, increased libido, dropped my voice, thickened and curled my hair, made my face round for a couple years, caused acne for about 2 years, moved fat away from my thighs and butt, added body and chest hair, developed a beard (really kicking in around year 7), made my nose and other cartilage bigger, my larynx, and I gained an inch of height. I loved the muscle gains. After nearly a decade medically transitioned and stealth, I had top, hysto (I kept my ovaries — I was hellbent on keeping them, never under illusions about wanting to be a medical patient for life, and always knew I wanted kids), and all stages of phalloplasty (RFF donor site, about 2 years before 2022, plus testicular implants and tattooing, vaginectomy and burial). My phallo went perfectly — no complications, swift recovery, sensation, can stand to pee, no donor site damage — but it didn't make me feel whole.
That's when the whole logic fell apart. My brain had to integrate having a dick and balls into its somatosensory map, and it became clear I couldn't keep telling myself I had a body/brain mismatch — "that just isn't how brains or any type of biology works." I started reading detrans stuff during my recovery from stage 1 and eventually pieced together what happened to me. I'd gone into surgery certain I'd feel complete afterward; instead I realized I'd been chasing a mirage when I started planning the next surgery to fix my hips. I'd never expected to want lower surgery when I first booked a top consult.
I quit T about 8.5–9 years in, roughly summer 2022, after coming to terms with everything. I've been off T for over two years as of early 2024. My labs showed my ovaries producing normal female sex hormones again and T in a normal range for an adult female, no obvious damage. I'm pursuing fertility assessment and egg harvesting. Short-term off T I had mood swings, irritability, lower energy, and loss of easy muscle; my hair texture immediately straightened, body hair shed, beard got thinner (stable now at about 75–80% of its potency on T), and my voice lightened only slightly. I pass well — other FTMs on my campus don't even glance at me — and I've decided to remain living socially as a man. I have no interest in detransitioning socially: it would cost thousands in hair removal and reversal surgeries without improving my quality of life, and I was masculine to begin with. I consider myself an immigrant to "man" as a social category — a naturalized citizen of manhood — and my goal is to integrate into that community on its own terms, honoring regular masculinity rather than projecting female ideals onto it.
I've been completely out of queer circles. I stay in touch with some FTM friends from the phallo journey who are as critical of the gender circus as I am, and I've found I have much more in common with people outside the LGBT scene. I've been able to speak totally freely with friends — including people I've met recently — about having been sucked into the spell of transition as a cure-all, that I probably wouldn't have transitioned with a competent assessment or the right support systems, and people still treat me like a regular guy. My social life improved when I thought it would take a hit.
I went through about a year of being "kind of fucked up" mourning the loss of my natural body and feeling I'd done this unnecessarily to myself, but I'm happy now. I've worked on the deficits that led me here: I recovered from about a decade of chronic illness (rotating dietary intolerances, fibro-esque chronic pain, chronic fatigue, brain fog) that started right before I medically transitioned, which I attribute partly to the stress of perceiving every slight as an attack while absorbed in trans activist logic. An immunologist assessed me as on the edge of developing autoimmunity before I addressed root causes. What helped was daily exercise, 8–9 hours of sleep, home-cooked whole foods diet (no processed food or sugar, healthy fats, pastured meat, fermented veggies), and the DNRS program for limbic system injuries from an abusive childhood and prolonged pesticide exposure. I'm now pain-free with stable digestion and have reintroduced foods I hadn't eaten in nearly a decade.
I exercise, spend time barefoot in nature, gardening, in large bodies of water, have hobbies, friendships, and I'm back in school pursuing paths I set aside to transition. I think of dysphoria now as body dysmorphia to be ignored — "the whole thing is an illusion" — and I try not to feed the thought. I regret that I did this to myself: the money, time, blood, sweat, and tears spent getting somewhere for little reason while my friends built careers and families and had fun in their 20s. I'm still mad about the risk to my fertility — "I knew I wanted kids and did everything to preserve my fertility despite all this, and I'm still mad!" — though I kept my ovaries and they're functioning. The grief has abated and I feel happy and optimistic about my future. I don't think transition is real or good for children; I'm critical of gender ideology and affirmative care, and I've sought out detrans/honest trans research to present as counterweight in a university setting. If I were earlier in my transition I would have detransitioned. I might go back on T if my ability to pass declines, but I'd rather not.