Tutte le storie

Cinque anni da uomo, poi il ritorno al proprio corpo

Femmina · Detransizionato/a107
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione: ho vissuto come uomo per cinque anni prima di scegliere la detransizione, e ora parlo apertamente della mia esperienza nelle comunità di detransizione. Sono nata femmina, ho fatto la transizione con gli ormoni e la depilazione laser che ha distrutto in modo permanente i follicoli piliferi. Sono arrivata a vedere la mia disforia come radicata nel mio ambiente e nelle mie esperienze e non nella biologia o nell'anatomia del cervello, e sono scettica sia verso gli studi medici citati a sostegno di un'identità di genere innata sia verso il concetto di essere trans come «stato mentale». La mia fede cristiana è importante per me, e credo che la detransizione sia stata un ritorno all'accettare come Dio mi ha fatta. Ora incoraggio gli altri — soprattutto i giovani — a «essere ciò che sono» invece di scegliere ormoni e interventi per tutta la vita, che credo non renderanno mai una persona completa.

Storia completa

I am a detransitioned woman. I lived as a man for five years before deciding to detransition, and I have been open about that journey in online detransition communities. I have described the issue of gender dysphoria as "an issue in the mind based on experience" — something rooted in what happens to a person rather than something innate or biological. I was born female. My transition involved hormones, and by the time I was considering detransition I had already reached a point where I felt there was "no turning back" in some respects. I had also had laser hair removal on some area of my body, and I have discussed with others how laser permanently destroys hair follicles so testosterone would not regrow that hair, and that over-the-counter remedies would likely be a waste of money. I mentioned platelet-rich plasma (PRP) treatments as a possible but unstudied option for hair regrowth and recommended talking to a provider experienced in hair regrowth procedures. Coming out to my parents was a significant fear. I worried they would reject me, but I came to believe they would actually be relieved — I wrote that they "most likely will be filled with joy" and that I imagined the pain they went through during my transition. I advised others in similar positions to get off hormones as soon as possible and tell their parents how they feel, while also warning them to be careful about who they confide in because "not everyone will have your best interest in heart." My faith is important to me. I believe people are "wonderfully made in the image of GOD" and that the world tells us that is not enough. I frequently invoke God's love and blessing in my posts, and I see my detransition as partly a return to accepting how I was made. I am skeptical of the medical and ideological frameworks around transgender identity. I have read the studies on brain structure and found them unconvincing — I pointed out that white matter studies show many people with the same brain structure as trans people are not trans, and that identical twin studies show twins with the same DNA and brain structure can differ in sexuality and gender identity. I concluded that if gender identity were genetically entrenched there would be no option but to be one way or the other, and that based on the data and the many stories in detransition groups, identity is shaped by each person's environment and experiences. I also noted that the "glorious side" of transitioning is shown publicly while the despair of those who regret it is hidden. I have a critical view of how "trans" is defined. Based on the definition I was given for five years — that being trans is a "state of mind" not requiring medical intervention — I argued that once you believe you are the opposite sex you are trans, and once you change your mind you are detransitioning. I pushed back on the distinction some make between "desisting" and "detransitioning," saying I had never heard anyone say they are desisting and asking what exactly they would be stopping from. I am skeptical of gender ideology more broadly, noting at one point that a claim "goes against gender ideology, I thought gender was socially constructed." I encourage others to "be what you are" rather than play a role, arguing that trying to be something you can never be is "a formula for a lifetime of depression" and that "never ending drugs and surgery will never make you whole." I have advised young people especially — I mentioned 16 as "a very tender age where it is easy to be influenced" — not to take drugs with long-lasting effects while still figuring themselves out. I did not feel comfortable being myself until I was almost 20 years old, which I described as early compared to many people. I have been open that I struggled with wanting everyone to like me or think I was cool. I encourage others to be uncomfortable for a while as they adjust to who they truly are, saying "your skin fits only you." I have been affirming toward others who are detransitioning, telling one person they were "very pretty either way" and that the joy in their face showed they made a great choice. I have also asked others what made them feel detransition was right for them and whether they wanted to go back on hormones or try to capture masculine feelings without drugs.