Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition, uscito da un periodo di convinzione ideologica, depressione, solitudine e pensieri suicidi, e che ora descrive la propria vita come più appagante di prima. In questi commenti non ho fornito una cronologia medica o di transizione dettagliata, ma ho detto di essere stato un ragazzo e di essere ora un uomo, e di essere stato un tempo legato a un'ideologia che governava i miei pensieri. Sono nettamente critico verso l'attivismo trans, paragonando il trattamento riservato da quella comunità a chi fa detransition a quello dei gruppi religiosi che scomunicano gli apostati, e credo che molte persone che pensano di essere trans non lo penseranno più verso i venti-trent'anni. Sostengo il perseguire un senso più che la felicità e sono stato critico sia verso il femminismo radicale sia verso l'antireligiosità di riflesso. Non ho descritto alcun rimpianto specifico per procedure mediche né ideazione suicidaria attuale.
Storia completa
I have never posted a thread of my own here — only commented — so what follows is drawn from my comments over roughly a year, from May 2019 to May 2020.
I came to this community as someone who had already been through a period of ideological conviction and had come out the other side. I have described, in reply to someone else's despair, my own history: "I've been through dark times similar to yours. I've been lonely, I've been depressed, I've been suicidal, I've been self destructive, and I've been attached to an ideology that held me back." I did not name that ideology explicitly in the transcript, but I framed it as something that governed my thinking — "people don't have ideas, ideas have people" — a phrase I said I chewed on and which "brought me down to my lowest point ever. Then I built back up." I have not given dates or ages for when that conviction began, when I came out, whether I socially or medically transitioned, or when I detransitioned, so I will not invent them.
What I have said about my own life is that I am now a man: "I was a boy and now I am a man." I have also said that I have "a life more fulfilled now than I did before" and that my life is "full of people who care about me and I care about them." I did not specify whether I arrived at living as a man through transition or through some other route, and I have not mentioned hormones, surgeries, puberty blockers, or any medical intervention at all.
On the substance of what I believe, I have been consistently critical of trans activism as a political project rather than a care project. I told one person that their language of "internalised transphobia" revealed that their ideas about what trans is, what dysphoria is, and what gender is came from "the activist end of the trans ideology," and that the people spreading it "don't want the best for you, they want you to be a tool to defeat their political enemies." I compared the treatment of detransitioners within the trans community to how various religious groups treat their apostates: "You are leaving a religion and being excommunicated. They will hate detrans people more than cis people as the numbers grow." I used Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, fundamentalist Muslims, and Scientologists as my analogies.
I have also been sceptical of the framing of trans identity as settled and self-evident. I told one commenter, "Many people who think they are trans, or as they put it, know they are trans, turn out to not be come late 20's and early 30's." I pushed back on the idea that offence should be a basis for banning people on this subreddit: "The entire premise of this sub is offensive to the radical left. I'd rather not make offense the bar for bans... We could all be better off with thicker skin, rather than thicker walls." I have argued that the trans activist narrative is not promoted in media outside of Reddit, and compared the social climate to "the colonial era and no one is allowed to deny god exists. Inside or outside of the church."
I have also been critical of radical feminism, telling a self-described radical feminist that being a radical means "you can't be humble, because being radical means you are right," and that I remembered "when I was able to abandon a lot of old beliefs in the development of my identity and I thought I was losing too much. I thought that I would rather die than to have been so wrong, to owe so many apologies, and to suffer the embarrassment of asking forgiveness."
On advice to others, I have consistently pointed people toward meaning rather than happiness: "Happiness and meaning aren't the same thing. And happiness isn't sustaining through hard times. It doesn't stop depression or hold manageable mental illness in check." I have recommended taking on burdens for others as a route to meaning: "Idle hands are the devils workshop, but worse, idle minds are the devils home. You need meaning in your life, and providing for others the service you can will give you meaning. There is no meaning but what you make." I have been broadly sympathetic to religion as "a cultural repository of wisdom from the past" while warning against churches that might use people, and I have rejected the language of "allyship" as inappropriate to personal relationships: "You shouldn't want allies, that is for war. You should want friends, mentors, acquaintances, and importantly a significant other."
I have not described my family, my relationships in detail, my career, my sexuality before or after any transition, my mental health diagnoses, or any specific therapy I have had. I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond participating in this community. I have not described regret over specific medical procedures because I have not mentioned any.