Tutte le storie

Un cambio di nome in pandemia, poi la scoperta che volevo solo sembrare un ragazzo

Femmina · Desistito/a505
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata che ha fatto la transizione sociale e cambiato nome durante la pandemia ma non ha mai fatto la transizione medica, in parte grazie ai miei genitori che mi hanno rallentata. A 17 anni, nel 2023, ho capito che in realtà non volevo essere maschio, volevo solo sembrare un ragazzo, e ho desistito, facendo la detransizione per circa 8 mesi fino all'inizio del 2026. Ora mi identifico come «non trans, solo un maschiaccio» e ho trovato un vero conforto nell'essere una femmina che si veste in modo mascolino invece di cercare di diventare qualcosa che non potrò mai essere. La mia principale difficoltà attuale è la vergogna e la pressione di mia madre per i miei capelli corti e la mia presentazione mascolina, nonostante il sostegno del mio ragazzo. Ho opinioni critiche sull'attuale inquadramento dell'identità trans e sul ruolo delle norme di genere.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up being allowed to dress and play however I wanted — I played with cars, wore boys' shoes, avoided skirts, and generally 'cross-gendered' without anyone objecting. It felt very freeing. I was always very masculine in my interests. During the pandemic, around 2020-2021, I was exposed to what I now describe as 'the whole trans epidemic' and convinced myself I was trans. I socially transitioned and changed my name. My mother was accepting but grieving. I posted comparison photos of '2 years ftm' versus later '8 months mtf' — the ftm period involved no hormones, and the mtf period also involved no hormones. I never medically transitioned: no hormones, no surgery, no puberty blockers. My parents didn't let me make any rushed decisions, and I'm eternally grateful for that. What actually shifted things for me was a realisation in 2023, when I was still 17: my issue wasn't 'wanting to be male' but the fact that I'm not male, and transitioning will never make me male. In my words, I could look male, but I wouldn't be it. That made me realise I'd rather be a fully functional female, dressing like a guy, than 'a sterile butchered female with guy hormones.' I told my mum I didn't want to proceed with hormones or anything else I'd talked about. I changed my name back. I detransitioned — as of early 2026 I was about 8 months into detransitioning, with photos spanning from 2021 through transition and ending in 2024. I did still want to keep a masculine presentation: cut my hair short like a guy, dress like a guy. At first my mother was fine with it, but after 4+ years she began insisting I 'have to be like a girl' — look like a girl, dress like a girl. She even said my boyfriend wouldn't find me attractive like this, even though he had explicitly told her he likes my short hair and doesn't like it long. One morning I got my hair dyed and cut as usual, and she gave me the silent treatment because she'd wanted a 'girl' cut rather than a guy's cut. She'd insisted on taking me to a hairdresser that time (I'd been cutting it myself with a razor for ages) and then threatened not to pay for it. She frequently says she's embarrassed by and ashamed of me. I don't understand why my hair matters to her — I dislike her hair and don't care. A key insight for me was that as a child I was absolutely allowed to dress as I wanted; once I hit puberty it became 'horrific'; when I thought I was trans it became acceptable again; and now that I'm just a tomboy, it's horrific again. I found real comfort in knowing I could just be a girl who looks like a guy instead of hurting my body trying to be something I can never truly be. Once I realised that my genitals shouldn't dictate what I like, I started feeling much more comfortable in my female body — it felt like I could be me as I was born, but also me the way I wanted to be. I now hold fairly critical views of transition as it's currently framed. I've argued that gender norms have to exist for trans people to even exist, that many trans people don't have surgery so their core issue is societal rather than biological, and that abolishing social norms would abolish the category of 'trans' itself. I also distinguish between what I see as okay ('I feel uncomfortable in my body, I want hormones to change it') and not okay ('call me a guy because I am a guy now'), while saying people should do what they want in their own house but I have a right to my opinion. I also observe that in my life being trans was normalised far more than just being a tomboy, which I think helps explain why many girls say they're trans rather than simply being plain tomboys. I'm not opposed to other people's choices, but I'm clear about my own boundaries and opinions. I have a boyfriend. English isn't my first language. I currently have blue hair and keep it short and masculine, sometimes cut by myself with a razor, sometimes professionally. I don't describe any acute mental health crisis or suicidal ideation in these posts; the main emotional pain I describe is my mother's shame and pressure around my presentation.