Tutte le storie

Esami del sangue e Clomid: l’avvertimento di un’endocrinologa da r/detrans

Femmina · Detransizionato/a621
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una persona che ha fatto detransition o desistito, attiva all’inizio del 2020 su r/detrans, che si basa sulla propria esperienza con gli ormoni e su un possibile ipogonadismo permanente per mettere in guardia gli altri su cambiamenti irreversibili, perdita di fertilità e danni endocrini. Ho sostenuto che il testosterone sia molto più dannoso per i corpi femminili di quanto lo siano gli estrogeni per i corpi maschili, ho criticato i bloccanti della pubertà e la medicina del consenso informato e mi sono identificata come gender critical/radfem. Avevo conoscenze cliniche o di endocrinologia e spingevo per esami del sangue, Clomid/hCG e controlli endocrinologici per chi smette gli ormoni. Ero critica ma non assolutista verso la transizione, inquadrandola come scelta personale solo dopo piena comprensione dei rischi. Resto scettica verso i protocolli medici di affermazione di genere e sostengo una comunicazione dei rischi più rigorosa.

Storia completa

I came to the detrans community in early 2020 as someone who had already been through transition-related medical decisions myself and who had strong opinions about the risks involved. I never gave a full step-by-step autobiography in these posts, but pieces of my own situation show through: I told another poster that I had a 'similar situation here' when discussing testosterone's effects on the female body, I referenced having been on hormones myself, and I spoke with real familiarity about gynecomastia, HPTA suppression, bloodwork, and endocrinology. My own medical history, as far as it appears, involved hormones and at least some degree of medicalization that I now regard as dangerous. When someone asked me directly how long I had been on female hormones and whether I was AMAB or AFAB, I didn't answer in the transcript, but my answers to others suggest I had personal experience with suppressed hormones and possible permanent hypogonadism. I repeatedly warned others that after a few years on exogenous hormones the HPTA (hypothalamic-pituitary-testicular axis) has a very low chance of recovering on its own, that fertility may be permanently lost, and that bloodwork for testosterone, estradiol, LH, and FSH is essential. I recommended Clomid and hCG to try to restore natural production and fertility, and I noted that testosterone replacement therapy, if needed, is generally a lifelong commitment. On the physical side, I told people bluntly that gynecomastia after estrogen use is essentially permanent and that 'the entire gland and breast tissue is removed in top surgery, there's nothing to grow back' — implying I understood surgical anatomy from the other direction. I also told a poster considering coming out that they should 'stop hormones immediately,' which reads like advice I wish I had acted on sooner myself. I was deeply skeptical of the medical establishment's handling of transition. I argued that 'testosterone has much more significant and dangerous effects on the female body than estrogen on the male body,' that it raises stroke, heart disease, and kidney failure risk, that hysterectomies are 'generally required after a few years on T,' and that there is 'no real bottom surgery for females' with results 'nowhere near as advanced as MtF.' I compared the doses prescribed to teenage FtM transitioners unfavorably to female bodybuilder steroid cycles, pointing out that bodybuilders use lower doses, cycle rather than cruise, and use less androgenic compounds like Anavar — and that reputable hospitals document these dangers for bodybuilders while ignoring them for trans patients. I said I knew a 20-year-old on 1000mg test undecanoate every 10 weeks whose doctor was already recommending a hysterectomy after two years. I was also critical of puberty blockers, saying 'that is NOT true' when someone called them safe and reversible, pointing to Lupron horror stories and arguing that children whose hormones are suppressed 'do not fully develop their brain, which requires estrogen to grow.' I posted an article from 4thWaveNow on the different types of gender dysphoria and how detransitioners present clinically. I was wary of medical gatekeeping that pushes people toward irreversible steps: I warned a poster that their friends encouraging a double mastectomy was strange unless dysphoria was suicidal in severity, and I said 'whenever you're being encouraged to remove body parts in order to be a part of a community you really need to take a step back and think about whose interests are really at heart.' I also flagged sexual factors in transition decisions, telling one person to 'explore if this is more of a sexual thing than a sex-identity thing' based on their post history, and I answered 'Autogynephilia' when someone asked about a related concept. I was politically engaged too: I shared and criticized Oklahoma's bill to ban non-gender-affirming therapy, arguing it would make it a felony for doctors not to affirm a child's gender identity and would produce false positives and detransitioned adults with irreversible changes and infertility. Despite my critical stance, I wasn't absolutist. I said things like 'this is America, you do you' and acknowledged that if dysphoria was severe enough to be suicidal, transition might be worth considering — but only after full informed consent about risks. I described myself as coming at the issue 'from a body health preservation standpoint' and letting the poster decide whether mental health benefits outweighed physical costs. I mentioned that 'some of us are in the medical profession and focus on endocrinology,' suggesting I had clinical or scientific training that informed my views. I was supportive and encouraging toward people who had detransitioned or were considering it — congratulating progress, asking people to share their stories, and telling someone only 19 days off hormones that they'd 'probably be back to normal in a month or two.' I gave practical advice about Labcorp/Quest bloodwork, private lab testing services, birth control after periods return, and freezing sperm before starting hormones. I also told people struggling with self-image that they had 'worth beyond what you look like' and urged them not to 'destroy your body with hormones and surgery.' I identified politically and culturally with gender-critical feminism, stating plainly: 'Unpopular opinion: Most people here are also a bit gender critical and radfem.' Overall, I came across as someone who had been through the medical system myself, come out skeptical, and was using my knowledge — possibly professional — to warn others about irreversible consequences, fertility loss, and the gap between what clinics promise and what the endocrinology literature actually shows.