Tutte le storie

Un decennio di genere, poi il risveglio dalla setta

Maschio · Detransizionato/a1,2K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Ho desistito da un'identità trans/non binaria circa dieci mesi prima di marzo 2023, dopo oltre un decennio in cui il genere è stato centrale nella mia vita, e sono un maschio che ha fatto detransizione. Ho smesso il testosterone e ora mi imbarazza la mia passata identificazione, che descrivo come 'risvegliarsi da una setta'. Da quando ho desistito provo sofferenza, alienazione e sentimenti nichilisti, e a volte piango per il silenziamento delle prospettive di detransizione. Credo che la non conformità di genere venga medicalizzata e che le comunità trans propaghino la stessa 'logica della disforia', pur continuando a sostenere la non conformità di genere e a vedere la transizione come ultima risorsa. Mi batto per le voci di chi ha fatto detransizione e critico i media che equiparano la detransizione al suicidio.

Storia completa

I had identified with gender nonconformity and trans identity for over a decade before desisting, and by March 2023 I was roughly ten months off testosterone. I described the experience of changing my mind as feeling like 'awakening from a cult,' and said I now lived 'in embarrassment of my past.' I had previously identified as nonbinary and had dysphoria, which I described as 'an aversion to identifying with my sex.' I came to believe that being trans was 'more of an idea than an essential quality' and that 'transition is something you do, not something you are.' I felt that a 'fallacious identity that dissociated me from my sex made me more dysphoric and insecure,' and I was glad I desisted. I was deeply distressed in early 2023, sometimes to the point of crying, about what I saw as the silencing of detransition perspectives and the pressure of what I called a 'quasi-religious dogma.' I felt alienated from friends because I did not feel safe discussing these thoughts openly, and I described an aversion to and fear of 'discourse' rather than of trans people themselves. I experienced strong nihilistic feelings since desisting, about my place in time and 'the absurd construct of society,' and I said I wanted empathy and love rather than being treated 'like an injured subject.' I worried that gender nonconformity was being medicalized by 'our patriarchal society and medical industry,' and that gender ideology oversimplified difficult psychological and sociocultural relationships with gender. I worried that the belief 'identity ≠ sex' encouraged people to develop dysphoria by giving them 'maladaptive identities.' I compared trans communities to anorexia communities and to a multiple-personality-disorder community that tells members their other personalities are real, saying such a community 'sounds horrifying' but also 'familiar.' I also noted a nonbinary friend who wanted to 'microdose e' believing estrogen was therapeutic like CBD, and felt this had become 'far too casual and simplified.' I reflected with embarrassment on having posted, a decade before desisting, on International Women's Day that people should stop supporting cis women and read queer theory instead — 'a male telling people to stop listening to women on a day dedicated to them.' I noted that when I propagated gender ideology I received tons of support on social media. I had a cis girlfriend at some point whose voice I found sexy and confident. I believed detransitioners disprove the ideology of innate gender and wrong bodies, and had faith that our existence alone would change the discourse on gender in time. I criticized media equating detransition to suicide as 'detransphobic,' and argued that trans people are likely higher than 1% of the population while also pointing out the inconsistency in activists' arguments about that figure. I supported gender nonconformity, masc women, femme men, and cultural exploration, but felt transition should be 'the last stop on a long journey of self exploration.' I worried some people don't give themselves a grace period to integrate gender nonconformity before 'jumping into an identity and design of a new person they imagine, as an impulsive escape.' I cautioned others against letting trauma distort their worldview and pushed back on sexist 'pussification of men' conspiracy thinking within the detrans community. I did not describe any specific therapy, medical complications, or fertility concerns in these posts.