Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Ho fatto la transizione a 14 anni dopo aver assorbito le convinzioni di Tumblr, ho vissuto come uomo trans per circa tre anni con ormoni e un intervento e ho detransizionato intorno al 2014, dopo aver trovato modi migliori per gestire una disforia reale, confermata da un medico, e dopo essermi disillusa dalla comunità. Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione, che non si identifica né come trans né come cis e si descrive semplicemente come detrans; non mi sono mai pentita di aver detransizionato e la mia disforia si è risolta. Il principale danno duraturo è il danno a costole e seno dovuto al binding, per cui sto valutando un intervento correttivo, e ho la EDS. Ho incontrato ostilità e tentativi da parte di persone trans di farmi rifare la transizione, il che mi ha fatto paura di parlarne anche con la mia psicologa. In linea di principio sostengo la modifica del corpo, ma credo che HRT e interventi dovrebbero essere dai 18 anni in su, con una supervisione diagnostica molto migliore.
Storia completa
I first came out as trans when I was 14, around 2011, and lived as a trans man for about three years. My gender dysphoria was real — it was confirmed by multiple doctors, and I was given a GID diagnosis. At the time I was heavily on Tumblr, and I absorbed the beliefs of people around me, partly in an effort not to be a bigot. I genuinely believed my extremely stereotypically masculine personality was a sign of being trans, that I was 'a boy in a girl's body.' I admired the bodies of men and wanted that for myself.
In hindsight, several things were driving it. I wanted to escape the expectations placed on me as a woman — to be demure, quiet, sexual, do whatever men wanted, put all my effort into pleasing others without consideration for myself. I am a survivor of childhood sexual abuse (CSA) and I am asexual, and my history made me feel intense disgust at the objectification of women I saw everywhere. So I wanted nothing to do with womanhood and didn't see myself as a woman. I also had significant bottom dysphoria at the time, but I ultimately decided against bottom surgery: the available phalloplasty options would have made me more dysphoric, and I'm very short, so I felt I would never be able to pass and never achieve the body I was after. I felt like no matter what I did, I couldn't get there.
I transitioned medically — I took hormones and had surgery, and I bound my chest during that period. I also did laser hair removal, though for reasons unrelated to transitioning; I had roughly 4–6 sessions before falling off the schedule, and it eventually came back.
Detransition happened gradually rather than through any single realization. I found better ways to manage the dysphoria, became disillusioned with the trans community, and just... stopped. I accepted my biological reality and realized how absurd it was to change myself to fit the expectations of a society I hated. I was never going to be a biological man, which is what I really wanted, and a trans man is a poor imitation that provides none of the things I actually wanted out of transition. I was not being my 'authentic self' by taking hormones and getting surgery. I now know that the alienation I felt from the stereotypes and gender roles associated with womanhood is a near-universal experience, and that being a woman just means having certain physical physical characteristics, nothing more. I detransitioned around 2014 — by 2022 I described myself as having been detransitioned for 8 years.
I never regretted detransitioning. Accepting myself as gender non-conforming and knowing I don't have to change myself for anyone has made me far happier than being trans ever did. I've accepted my body as it is, which has gotten rid of any lingering dysphoria. I don't think I've ever seen someone complete their transition who wasn't living in crippling fear of being clocked, with deep-seated hatred of all the body parts they couldn't change. I would take a body swap if it were offered, but I've made peace with my body.
There are some lasting physical consequences. The binding I did during transition caused problems with my ribs and breasts. I've been looking into breast reduction surgery to fix these problems, though I wouldn't mind completely getting rid of them, and I've considered using my GID diagnosis to get the surgery. I've also considered taking testosterone to improve muscle growth, and because some research suggests testosterone helps reduce pain associated with EDS (Ehlers-Danlos syndrome), which I have. I feel very conflicted about this: it was the transition that caused the problems with my breasts in the first place, so it feels like giving gender ideology a pass to fix the problems it caused. Taking testosterone also puts me in a weird grey area — I feel I couldn't be considered detrans even though I have no intention of transitioning to male, but I also don't feel trans.
Mental health-wise, my depression was at its peak when my gender dysphoria was at its peak. GD made me hate my body and myself far more than I ever did before becoming aware of it. Even though before I was gender non-conforming, I didn't hate myself nearly as much as I did in the trans period. I did often feel it was unfair that people gave me so much shit for not conforming, but as far as I'm concerned that's their problem, not mine.
I have memory issues now, which combined with how long ago I detransitioned makes it hard to pinpoint exactly what made the dysphoria go away. I also have EDS.
On the social side, I've had a hard time talking about detransition. Trans people have repeatedly told me I'm not allowed to talk about my own experiences because they believe I was never trans, even though I lived as a trans man for 3 years. Groups of trans people have tried to make me retransition because they believed I was trans and lying to myself about it — this wasn't a one-off. I've been accused of being a TERF based on nothing. Because of this, I was afraid to mention my detransition history to my psychologist, even though her bio page said she was LGBT friendly, since my history contradicts the general trans party line and I didn't want to risk getting the same pushback. I generally avoid being defensive because it makes people assume I'm a TERF; instead I call people out directly and focus entirely on my own experiences.
I don't identify as trans, but I don't see myself as cis either — both imply certain experiences I don't share. I usually just describe myself as detrans. I'm critical of gender as a concept in the literal sense, but I don't agree with the vast majority of what people who call themselves gender critical believe, so I don't think the term fits me. I believe everyone should have the right to do whatever they want with their own body so long as it doesn't hurt others, which seems at odds with most GC beliefs.
I think body modification is fine in general — I see transitioning as just another form of body modification, having nothing to do with changing your sex or gender but rather just your appearance. But I think you should be 18+ for HRT/SRS/etc., like you need to be 18+ for a tattoo. I also think more research is needed into properly distinguishing dysphoria that can be treated without transition from dysphoria that can be treated by transition, or other disorders that can mimic it, and there needs to be far more oversight so you can't walk out of one appointment with HRT. Everyone should get all relevant information and a full differential diagnosis screening. Honestly I don't think changing your body to fit a social role ever ends well — people should do it because they want the physical changes, not because they hope people will treat them differently. I'm frustrated by how detransitioners who were minors when we transitioned are blamed, when in no other context are children blamed for following bad medical advice from their doctors. I've advocated for detransitioners being able to speak about their experiences and for the community to stop silencing us.