Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina che ha desistito, che a 16 anni ha detto ai genitori di essere FTM ma non ha mai fatto una transizione medica. Ora mi identifico come femmina mascolina e androgina, un maschiaccio, e ho accettato di essere femmina e che non sarò mai maschio. Faccio risalire il mio desiderio di transizione al bullismo infantile sul mio aspetto, all'odio di me stessa per un aspetto mascolino e a omofobia e misoginia interiorizzate che funzionavano da identità trans di fuga. Ora sono all'università, vado bene socialmente, anche se ripresentarmi a persone che mi conoscevano come trans è imbarazzante. Ho opinioni fortemente critiche sulla transizione medica per gli altri e ho fatto un attivismo informale cercando di dissuadere le persone da ormoni e interventi.
Storia completa
I came out to my parents as transgender (FTM) at 16, after showing what I felt were no real signs of gender issues beforehand. I've recently desisted from identifying as transgender. I'm 19 years old now, at university, and I'm loving it — I want to get as involved as possible with societies and roles on campus and make as many friends as possible; I'm not just there for the degree, I'm there to grow, learn, and explore my fields of study.
I've overanalysed my own reasons for transitioning, but recently realised the cause was fairly simple. Growing up, I constantly had boys telling me I was ugly, and each time it was like a stab to the chest. I'd look in the mirror and see an ugly, manly-looking girl and absolutely despise myself — enough to want to destroy that version of me and try to pass as male, so that my masculine appearance didn't seem out of place and even became a benefit because it let me pass. I literally saw no future for myself as an ugly, masculine girl. I had ambitions, but in my mind my appearance was a deal-breaker, so out of self-hatred and desperation I latched onto transitioning as the way to change my life. I've also noted that internalised homophobia and misogyny had manifested themselves as an escapist trans identity, even though on paper I can state that I'm not homophobic and don't idealise men.
I never medically transitioned — I've said explicitly that I didn't medically transition. So there's no medical timeline for me. I came to terms with desisting by realising I would never be male and would only ever be a poor impersonation of a man. I had to disconnect from the whole idea of gender and just see it as 'I am who I am, and who I am is female.' I don't connect to the label of girl or woman because I've been conditioned to associate those words with femininity, which is the problem; I want to age like me — a tomboy/androgynous female. Accepting that I'm female and will never be male, and deciding that this didn't have to define me, is what allowed me to detransition/desist. I'm allowed to want toned muscles, short hair, narrow hips, even to look confusingly androgynous or pass as male — it just makes me a masculine female, not a male.
I've not fully come to terms with how easily trans ideology infiltrated my mind, though I've elsewhere suggested it 'stole 4 years of my life' (this figure appears in advice I gave to someone else, so I hold it loosely for myself). Finding masculine female role models really helped me and broadened my view of what women are allowed to be; it's a relief to know I can keep men's clothing and short haircuts without changing my entire identity. Most of my role models are real-life people I know personally rather than celebrities. Radical feminist essays and poetry have helped me immensely with loving myself and appreciating femaleness; I've recommended Magdalen Berns, Arielle Scarcella's videos, and searching #tomboy on Instagram to others. I'm not a lesbian.
I have wonderful, supportive parents who never made me feel lesser because of my femaleness and always encouraged me to follow my passion and be successful in any field of my choosing. I'd say my gender dysphoria was not so much triggered by societal factors but comes largely from the biological differences between male and female bodies, and my odd desire to inhabit the male body rather than the female body.
The hardest part socially has been reintroducing myself at university. I'm trying to work out the least awkward method of reintroducing myself to every friend and acquaintance, knowing they will always see me as someone with a confusing gender experience. I wish I had never stopped loving myself, so that I would never have tried to be someone else and ended up in this mess. I want to date people who are attracted to females; I don't want people thinking I have a penis or that my chest is just a bra full of tissues, as that would complicate my situation further.
I now hold strongly critical views about medical transition for others. I've told a parent of a gender-questioning boy that medical transition means irreversible changes that will leave him infertile and a poor impersonation of femaleness, and advised finding a therapist who challenges transness rather than automatically affirming it. I've described someone as a 'textbook case for future detransition' and cited mental illness and sexual trauma as common reasons people transition. I've argued that transitioning won't make someone a cis guy — the illusion is stripped off when clothes come off — and that feeling a brain-body disconnect doesn't mean a different body would be a better fit, since I've had this body all my life. I've suggested therapy, meditation, and sport hobbies before pursuing a medical path, and told people to stop watching trans men's YouTube vlogs and start watching detransition videos. I've also advised someone post-transition to make peace with their body as it is now and break the cycle of body-hating, telling them 'You are not ruined, you are simply evolving.'
I don't describe myself as regretting specific medical procedures since I didn't undergo them, but I do express regret about the whole episode — wishing I'd never stopped loving myself, and not yet having fully come to terms with how the ideology took hold. Overall I'm functioning well: I'm thriving at university, building friendships, and focused on growth.