Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition, che ha fatto la transizione sociale al liceo e ha desistito a 16 anni, senza mai fare una transizione medica perché ero minorenne e i miei genitori non l'hanno permesso. Sono stata spinta verso la transizione dalla misoginia interiorizzata, da un gruppo di amici che mi assecondava e da un GSA che ora vedo come simile a una setta e di adescamento, e verso la detransition dalla lettura di studi medici, dei file trapelati della WPATH e dal vedere i danni a lungo termine di ormoni e interventi su coetanei FTM più grandi. La detransition mi ha portato grave bullismo e ostracismo da parte della comunità trans della mia scuola e mi ha costretta a cambiare scuola, ma ora sono orgogliosa di essere donna e schietta sulle mie opinioni. Ho sofferto di ansia sociale per tutto il tempo e sono critica verso la transizione medica, soprattutto la chirurgia genitale e l'intervento medico sui minori. Ho 20 anni nel 2024 e mi batto per altri giovani che mostrano gli stessi campanelli d'allarme che avevo io.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in a small high school of about 1000 students. I first started questioning my gender around 13, when I was going through puberty — I wish someone had told me then that it is normal to feel like your body isn't yours while it changes so rapidly, and that transitioning wouldn't make it feel more like mine. My social anxiety was really bad, and the only place I ever felt accepted was my friend group, which was made up largely of FTM and non-binary females, most of whom were autistic (I am not autistic). I joined my school's GSA, which I now believe did a lot of things schools shouldn't be doing — I've described it elsewhere as "a form of grooming disguised as affirmation."
I socially transitioned during high school, and when I did I was met with overwhelming support and love-bombing, and made lots of new friends who turned out to be really bad people in the end. I never medically transitioned — I was a minor and my parents didn't allow it. I desisted at 16. When I stopped socially transitioning and went back to identifying as a girl, I was met with hostility from almost all the FTM members of the GSA and suffered severe bullying that made my social anxiety much worse; I had to move schools because of it. Even the teachers stopped supporting me and told me I had to "deal with the consequences of my actions" after originally being supportive and pushing me toward social transition when I was unsure. I later described the GSA as seeming "like a cult" — it was all about affirming, and if you had any doubt you got shut down. There was a lot of internalised misogyny there, and they held stereotypes about women I didn't relate to, which made me think I mustn't be a woman as a result.
Looking back, I attribute a lot of my transition to internalised misogyny and an enabling friend group. I think a lot of it came from seeing men as "cooler" or "more interesting" than women, and from yaoi depicting female characters as "annoying obstacles" to gay relationships, which alienates girls and makes them feel lesser. I also think media stereotypes about women lead many girls to be uncomfortable with how the world perceives them, which we mistake for being trans. I used to be very uncomfortable with she/her pronouns or being called a woman until I realised how many different kinds of women there are.
What actually drove me to detransition was understanding the immense health risks associated with transitioning — reading medical studies, learning from older peers who are medical students, and seeing how negatively hormones and surgery affected many adult FTMs I knew as a teenager. I read the leaked WPATH files and found them "really terrifying" and confirming of everything I thought about the trans medical industry. I'm now 20 (turning 20 in 2024) and I desisted at 16, so my last few years as a teenage girl were, looking back, the best years — no need to affirm any identity, just being me with my interests surrounded by lots of girls and boys with similar interests.
I'm really glad I desisted and I'm proud to be a woman who doesn't need to succumb to gender stereotypes. I have a stereotypically "masculine" personality and interests in extreme metal, I have long hair and like feminine clothes, but personality-wise I meet more men who are similar than women — that doesn't make me any less of a girl. I'm not afraid to voice my opinion these days, even if a lot of people in the trans community don't like hearing my story. I know a few younger kids who think they're trans and show all the symptoms I did that were red flags leading to my detransition, but they won't listen to us. I like to subtly convey that trans isn't cool and try to set a positive example outside of gender stereotypes.
Mental health-wise, I suffered from social anxiety; a lot of the FTMs at my old high school were dealing with trauma, autism, depression and eating disorders. I've become critical of the medical side: I think bottom surgery is an abhorrent idea that shouldn't be allowed for the most part, I'm less concerned about breast implants or mastectomies but think they should be approached with caution, and I believe genital alteration is a form of mutilation, including circumcision absent medical reason, noting the brain isn't finished developing until 25. I've also observed that a lot of trans people I used to know are suffering long-term effects from HRT but insist it isn't the hormones. I completely support people of different sexualities and believe they shouldn't have their community destroyed. I'm proud to be a detransitioned woman.