Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Ho iniziato la detransizione nel 2023, dopo essermi identificato come trans e aver vissuto come uomo, smettendo gli ormoni e facendo i conti con un seno residuo di coppa B dovuto al testosterone. Provo ancora disforia e a un certo punto ho detto di considerarmi ancora transgender, anche se ho scelto di non proseguire con ulteriore transizione medica. Perdere i miei gruppi di amici trans quando ho fatto coming out come detrans mi ha ferito profondamente e mi ha spinto a criticare la politica e il gatekeeping della comunità trans. Ora mi batto con forza contro la transizione dei giovani, contro la chirurgia senza una certezza al 100% e per la copertura assicurativa delle cure legate alla detransizione, pur dicendo di accettare in generale le persone trans. Sono una persona che ha fatto detransizione, che si pente della decisione di fare la transizione ma continua a sostenere il diritto degli altri di fare la transizione da adulti.
Storia completa
I started detransitioning in early 2023 after identifying as trans and living as a man. By March 2023 I was asking whether it was best to quit hormones cold turkey, and later that month I was asking about chest reduction and breast size — I had B-cup breasts from testosterone and wondered whether they would shrink or become less pointy as I detransitioned. I described myself as mtftm in those posts.
Coming out as a detransitioner cost me my friendships. In April 2023 I wrote that trans friends and allies showed 'radiant hatred and anger' when I talked about my experience, and that these 'friends were never truly friends' — that they had used me as a political weapon for virtue signaling. By March 2024 I reported losing my friend groups and all support, with a trans friend of many years blocking me. I said the trans community 'cast me aside' and labeled me a traitor, and that a trans friend had a tantrum and broke down when I told her I was detransitioning.
My reasons for detransitioning were complicated. In June 2023 I posted that 'being Trans was absolutely brutal and difficult' and that in a perfect world without discrimination I would still be transitioning — so hardship, not just error, drove it. But I also framed it as a mistake: 'Yes, I made a mistake transitioning but... Just because I made a mistake, doesn't mean I have to continue making that same mistake.' I had been '99% sure... then 60%, and now, I'm detransitioning.' I also reported that my dysphoria actually got worse while transitioning — once I was 'all-in on becoming a woman,' I noticed the intricate details of my masculine body, and my depression and anxiety worsened. I questioned whether transition helps or hurts transgender people.
I still experience dysphoria. In April 2023 I wrote, 'I have dysphoria, but that dysphoria was not enough for me to justify medical transition or surgeries. I still consider myself to be transgender,' and titled a post 'You can be transgender and not transition.' So at that point I still identified as transgender while choosing not to medically transition. I did not describe surgeries in the transcript; my medical footprint mentioned is hormones (quitting) and the breast changes from testosterone.
I became an active advocate. I posted repeatedly that people with any doubt should stop — 'If you have any doubt, STOP NOW' — and that surgeries should never happen unless someone is 100% sure. I argued kids should not transition at all: 'A child cannot make an informed decision on hormone treatment... We don't trust children to cross the street without an adult. Why would we trust them to medically change their gender?' I posted that detransitioners deserve insurance coverage for medical care, arguing we 'have a right to seek comfort in our gender too, not just trans people.' I also pushed back against the idea that detransition is a minor 'oopsie,' saying it is 'a major problem that has life-long consequences for people who were misdiagnosed' and that people downplay it 'so we don't bring legal action for medical malpractice.'
At the same time, I remained supportive of trans people generally. In July 2023 I posted 'I still accept trans people,' saying 'Just because it wasn't for me does not mean transitioning is not a valid path for others,' and I defended the word 'cis' as not a slur, telling detransitioners to 'Stop siding with bullies' and not 'stab the trans community in the back.' I linked to hate crime statistics and ACLU legislative-attack data. Over 2024 my tone toward the trans community grew more critical: I called their politics 'ABSURD,' said I prefer hanging out with people outside the trans community, and speculated that trans people who reject detransitioners are 'just insecure in their own identity and don't want to be reminded that they're potentially making a mistake.'
On passing, I told others not to 'psych yourself out over whether or not you pass' since most detrans people pass to the general population, and I described myself as 'leaning masc' but making progress in mid-2023. I also advised someone to just get used to their appearance and 'Go outside and interact with people without trying to care about it too much. Most people don't notice or care.'
I found detransitioning harder than transitioning: 'It's way harder to detrans' because it requires pushing back against institutions and admitting a mistake. But I also told others it gets better: 'It is hard at first, but gets a lot better... you are saving yourself a life full of anguish and struggle.' I advised people to halt surgery until sure. The transcript does not mention suicidal ideation, self-harm, therapy, trauma, family, relationships, sexuality, or fertility.