Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione e che per diversi anni si è identificata come uomo trans senza mai fare la transizione medica, e che ora si considera in desistenza e non trans. Credo che il pensiero di tipo ossessivo, l’autismo non diagnosticato (diagnosticato in età adulta dopo un burnout), la misoginia interiorizzata, la sessualizzazione del mio corpo convenzionalmente attraente e l’esposizione online alla narrazione trans abbiano contribuito alla mia identità trans. La desistenza è arrivata quando ho capito che la transizione mi avrebbe fatta risaltare anziché confondermi, che non sarebbe mai stata definitiva, e leggendo i racconti di donne detrans. Nel momento peggiore pianificavo la mia morte e mi ritiravo da tutto, ma ora sto per lo più bene e sono tornata al mio livello di base di odio per il corpo, non più l’odio suicida che avevo quando credevo di non poter mai passare. Sono critica verso la transizione presentata come unica risposta e sostengo una valutazione migliore e la comunità detrans, pur credendo che la transizione sia giusta per alcune persone.
Storia completa
I was born female and have always been a tomboy since the day I was born. For several years I formally identified as a trans man, but I never took medical steps — no hormones, no surgery, no legal changes. I very genuinely believed I had a male mind trapped in a female body, and I saw transition as the only option for me; I never wanted to be the opposite sex so much as I believed I already was and needed a body to match. I held very binary trans, transmed/truscum views and saw myself as distant from "transtrenders."
Several things fed into that identity. I have always had many male-dominated interests and an educational background that was male-dominated, and I was often the only woman in the room. I hated my female secondary sex characteristics and wanted to get rid of them. I also think my body being conventionally attractive contributed a lot: I am petite, formerly athletic, at the lower end of the healthy weight category, with a defined waist-hip ratio, and no matter how I dressed it could not be hidden. I just wanted to blend in and be invisible, but instead received far too many sexual comments, and I hated the attention my body was getting me. I pretended to be male in online chatrooms as a teenager. I had always been distanced from girls and women, and wanted to blend in with men.
I was unhappy as a teenager, to the extent of suicidal ideation, but I never connected these things up until exposure to the trans topic, which indirectly suggested everything was due to being born in the wrong body. This seemed, at the time, like it had made my entire life make sense — my brain being "male" seemed to explain everything. All of my exposure to trans people was online; I have still yet to meet a trans identifying person personally that I am aware of. I was not a teenager when I came to identify as trans, but rather a young adult, and I felt with certainty that this had explained my entire life.
I desisted after years of identifying as male. A large part of what caused that was wanting to fit in and feel like I belonged, but eventually realising that transitioning would just make my life more difficult for a whole variety of reasons. I hated my body and I hated being a woman, but I realised I hated more the idea of standing out and taking up resources. Other things that contributed to desisting: the idea of being a permanent patient; the realisation that this would make me stand out rather than blend in; the realisation that I was obsessed; the realisation that transition would never be final and my dysphoric feelings would always be present; the realisation of my internalised misogyny; reading about the medical problems of trans people; feeling distanced from men by their sexuality; finally being able to empathise with women; a gradual change in perception in my 20s; and reading the accounts of detrans women. I also came to believe I lacked a lot of both insight and perspective to rationalise my feelings, even though the feelings themselves were very real.
I do think my obsessive-type thinking definitely contributed to me wanting to transition, and I believe there may be a link between disorders characterised by obsessive thinking and detrans people. I was diagnosed with autism in adulthood, several years ago, after burnout left me unable to function at the level I was before — this was after I spent years with a trans identity. I see that I am disordered, and I believe that both the restricted, repetitive and stereotyped patterns of behaviour/interests and the social interaction/communication impairments parts of the criteria played a huge part in me becoming burnt out, in me genuinely believing I was born with a male brain in a female body for several years, and in other difficulties throughout my life. I do not have a single school report card that does not mention how shy/quiet I was, and in school parent meetings it was always mentioned how I was not speaking at all in class; I still cannot speak properly. I was not diagnosed until adulthood, and I hope that shy girls without challenging behaviour are no longer overlooked. I have given up on finding an autism community I relate to, after reading all communities I found in all languages I understand — but r/detrans is the online community I have felt most belonging to.
Early in my desistance I wanted nothing to do with the trans community anymore. It was exhausting to constantly police the way I was feeling, and I felt like I was walking on eggshells; I felt betrayed. I have had multiple trans people try to "rescue" me for being in denial, try to insist I was never truly trans, or otherwise not believe me, and I have been extensively challenged and once given a hostile rant for sharing part of my story, with no apology — they just disappear. I feel most cautious around trans people as a result, though I constantly remind myself that the most hostile actors do not represent all trans people.
At my worst, I was also planning my death. I was withdrawing myself from almost everything, telling myself that I was a waste of space and they'd be better off without me. When I identified as trans and knew I would not pass, that caused me suicidal ideation — I hated my body before, but hated it more for never being able to pass. I am now back to my baseline level of hatred for my body, rather than the elevated, suicidal hatred I had. I am mostly alright now, though I still am not completely content with my body's conventional attractiveness and the attention it attracts.
I have not had surgery or hormones, so there are no medical complications or fertility concerns from transition to deal with, but I still have lasting social identity impacts from having formally identified as trans. I consider myself desisted rather than trans, and I do not think I am a minority in that among detrans people, though I find it tiring when trans people insist I must be trans in denial.
I am critical of how transition is presented to others. I am not trying to convince people not to transition — I personally believe there are some people whose quality of life would be best if they transitioned — but I am against affirmation, against people claiming they can tell who will clearly benefit from transition, and against presenting transition as the only answer to gender dysphoria. I believe anyone identifying as trans should be professionally assessed, not just for gender dysphoria but particularly for disorders associated with obsessive thinking patterns (eating disorders, addictions, OCD and related disorders, autism spectrum disorders). I have been an active advocate within the detrans community: pushing back against misconceptions from both trans and gender-critical outsiders, arguing against the misuse of detransition-rate studies, defending the subreddit during brigading and ban campaigns, and supporting the moderators. Parts of gender-critical ideology have helped me, though I am concerned that forceful extreme GC views push away curious or early-detransitioning people who could benefit from the space. I ideally wish detransition was not something people had to take sides on.