Tutte le storie

Temeva il «lo sapevo», poi ha trovato calore

Femmina · Desistito/a453
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata che dai 15 anni si identificava come FTM e ha desistito senza mai prendere ormoni né fare interventi. Ho rimandato la detransizione per paura di sentirmi dire «sapevo che era una fase», ma tutti hanno risposto invece con calore. Ora, a 22 anni, cerco di consigliare o mettermi in contatto con i giovani che stanno valutando la transizione, anche se per questo ho ricevuto minacce di morte. Sono critica verso la retorica della comunità trans e verso le minacce di suicidio usate contro chi fa detransizione. Ho ancora problemi di immagine corporea dovuti ad anni di binder.

Storia completa

I was born female, and I first identified as trans around age 15, when I was living as an FTM. I spent years on trans tumblr, where I saw what I describe as calls for violence against people the community didn't like, and I say that trans tumblr had been 'drooling over the prospect of an event like this for an entire decade' — which is why a recent mass shooting by a trans man didn't surprise me. I try not to be transphobic, because my experience shows me that the overwhelming majority of trans people are normal humans with exceptional vulnerabilities, but I want to criticize the harmful and disturbing aspects of the community rather than individuals. I desisted and physically never transitioned — I never had hormones or surgery, which is partly why I later asked other desisters what kept them from physically transitioning. I did bind, and I wore multiple XS sports bras for years; I feel like my breasts are 'long and flat on top' because of that, though I try to remind myself that many breast shapes exist and nobody could tell mine look that way because of binding. I also spent years post-desistance 'cramming myself into girly outfits' and wondering why I still felt dysphoric and goofy; I didn't learn to love my womanhood until I allowed it to coexist with powerful aesthetics. I now distinguish between wanting to feel feminine and wanting to feel happy in my female body. I delayed detransitioning for a long time because I feared the 'Ha, I KNEW you'd get over it!' response — I spent so long trying to prove it wasn't a phase that when it was a phase, I returned with my tail between my legs. That fear kept me down far longer than it should have. When I did tell people, everyone I had expected to respond with derision and 'I told you so' was warm, understanding, and compassionate instead. I worry other young people have that same fear and are being held down by it. I've compared leaving the experience to leaving a cult, and to being told 'you were never a true believer.' I'm now 22, and I see myself in every young FTM. My heart yearns to reach out to them, but I've been ganged up on and even given death threats when I try. I have no formal counseling background, but I compare myself to clergy who also lack formal training and still talk others through their issues. I've posted publicly offering to speak with parents about their minor daughters and to talk to young people considering transition, and I've invited people to message me. I'm critical of suicide threats used against detransitioners: I wrote that 'suicide is voluntary and optional' and that detransitioners were 'trained in' suicide ultimatums. I also argue that extreme speech should always be taken at face value, no matter where it comes from, and that 'I'm just venting' claims of harmless intent are always a lie.