Tutte le storie

La figlia di una pediatra ha fatto la transizione a 12 anni, così lei ha letto i dati della clinica

Femmina · Desistito/a267
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una persona che ha fatto detransition... no, sono una pediatra e una madre la cui figlia ha fatto la transizione sociale a 12 anni; al momento mi identifico come donna e non ho fatto né transizione né detransition. La transizione di mia figlia mi ha portata a documentarmi, a perdere fiducia nel modello di invio alle cliniche di genere dopo quattro pazienti pediatriche FTM e a iniziare a organizzarmi con altri medici per contrastare la posizione dell'AAP sulle cure affermative. Ho pubblicato un sondaggio su Sermo e programmato un articolo su KevinMD, e sostengo che i giovani non conformi al genere possano essere se stessi senza ormoni. Ho posizioni critiche verso la medicalizzazione rapida e verso le pretese autoginefiliche sugli spazi femminili, sostenendo al contempo chi trova da solo la strada per uscire dagli ormoni.

Storia completa

I am a pediatrician, and I came to this issue both professionally and personally. My own child — I have a daughter — suddenly announced she wanted to be a boy less than a year before August 2019; she socially transitioned at age 12, and by September 2019 she was 13, with the current plan being to start medical interventions when she turns 18. When that happened I started looking for information and was overwhelmed: "there's too much, and it doesn't hold true, and there's so much nonsense." I've reflected on how the culture has changed since I was young. We had lots of androgynous celebrities back then — kd lang, Boy George, Grace Jones, Tracy Chapman, Annie Lennox — whereas now, "if you're not a girly girl, well then you must be a boy. It's bullshit." I've told young people directly that they don't have to change their "perfect body" to express themselves, pointing them to GNC men like David Bowie, Boy George, and Prince, and urging them to "think past the binary." I've also said that treating a gay kid with hormones is, to me, "the real conversion therapy," and that trans ideology is pushing society in a more conservative direction by making gender roles rigid. My stance with my own child is: "I want to change the world, not my child's perfect body." Professionally, I didn't know much about trans issues until it became personal. I have seen four FTM pediatric patients in my own clinic in the four years before September 2019. My first three patients I simply referred to the local gender clinic. The third was 12 years old: she got diagnosed in the first five minutes of her first appointment with a "gender therapist," and was offered puberty blockers at the first visit to the endocrinologist. That experience made me realize that simply referring was maybe not a good idea. My fourth FTM patient was a 14-year-old girl with "high functioning autism"; I asked her what she actually wanted from transition — she did not want a beard, she did want a deeper voice, and mostly she wanted to be taller. Since she'd started her periods three years earlier, she was probably as tall as she was going to be, and testosterone would not help. She decided she'd be happy working with a speech therapist on her voice instead. My first red flag was when everybody — the TransActive leader, the endocrinologist — agreed that 99-100% of kids put on puberty blockers go on to full transition, stated as though it proved kids know their inner gender. I was skeptical that 99-100% of 11-12 year olds know what their lifelong situation should be, and that led me to do more research. I now believe there is no medical test, scan, or psychological evaluation that can tell who will persist and who will desist, and that the number who will desist is much larger than the number who will persist. I know that if I refer a child to the gender clinic they will be offered puberty blockers or cross-gender hormones and moved toward surgery quickly, and that kids put on puberty blockers move on to full medicalization almost 100%, even though blockers are presented as a completely reversible "pause." I am working to find other doctors who are also worried about how fast this is going, and we are forming an organization to call for more science and evidence-based medical practices. My professional organization, the American Academy of Pediatrics, came out for "affirmative care" about a year before September 2019, and they didn't ask me about that. I drew an analogy to the early-2000s expansion of the bipolar diagnosis and the marketing of second-generation antipsychotics like Risperdal and Abilify to rebellious kids — I had observed that and complained to no effect, and I said I was going to try to do more than complain this time. I ran a poll on Sermo.com (a Facebook-like site for doctors) asking what to do with a 12-year-old who says she wants to be a boy; only 10% said affirming care, most picked "Wait, what?" I also planned to have a similar article published at KevinMD.com, though I couldn't attend the AAP National Meeting because I'd used up all my PTO. I have also signed a petition related to this cause, saying "We are headed for a reckoning (or at least I hope we are)." I've been active in the community, offering to help people find doctors (since I'm a pediatrician), advising someone who had a hysterectomy at 28 to start a low-dose OCP rather than testosterone because "your vagina and urethra need estrogen," warning a detransitioned natal male about the blood-clot and stroke risks of estrogen (which rise sharply after about seven years), and recommending 4-7-8 breathing for panic attacks. I've praised people who contact their former "health" providers, saying we need to pierce the bubble that "it all goes swimmingly and nobody ever regrets this." I've expressed concern about young people being "guinea pigs" and about doctors who treat patients as "collateral damage." On related social questions, I've worried that isolation among young men may be driving mass shootings, and I've suggested that a person's family drama about men might be worth exploring with a therapist. I've been critical of autogynephilic adult males "insisting that the world participate in their crazy-ass LARPing," while saying that transsexuals who could pass have always existed among us. I've advised parents not to confront teenagers head-on about gender, warning it will "activate the oppositional reflex," and instead to listen first so the teen feels truly seen. I'm not a Christian and I'm not a big fan of the Federalist, though I've noted Walt Heyer's detransition resource site has many stories. I've also encouraged gender-nonconforming young people and celebrated stories of people who decide to be themselves without hormones: "We need more gender nonconforming humans in the world!"