Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto la detransizione: ho fatto la transizione sociale intorno al 2015, ho iniziato il testosterone nel 2018 circa e ho deciso di smettere gli ormoni a ottobre 2019 dopo aver capito che la vita era davvero migliorata per ragioni che non c'entravano con la transizione. Speravo che la transizione curasse un decennio di depressione, pensieri suicidi e bulimia, ma non è successo, e sono tornata al punto di partenza con quelle difficoltà. Il principale cambiamento fisico duraturo che rimpiango è la voce, che mi è costata la capacità di cantare, anche se ci ho fatto pace, e anche col tornare al mio vecchio nome. La mia compagna da sei anni, mia madre e mio padre mi hanno sostenuta nello smettere. Sono critica sia verso l'attivismo trans sia verso le posizioni critiche sul genere, voglio molta più ricerca e credo che la transizione possa essere giusta per una piccola minoranza e sbagliata per persone come me.
Storia completa
I was born female, and I first socially transitioned around 2015, four years before I decided to stop. I began hormone therapy about a year before October 2019, so roughly in 2018, after waiting about three years to get hormones through the gender clinic. I had been considering surgery and talking about it, but I kept delaying researching it and found myself dreading the day I would have to confront it. That avoidance was one of the first things that made me realize I was not really trans.
I had gone slightly overweight for a while, but life had genuinely gotten better: I lost weight, did more exercise, and I started to see that the happiness I attributed to transitioning was actually just life improving. For a short while I caught myself thinking I had to go through with it because of social expectations and because some changes were already irreversible, but then I reconsidered, reasoning that further changes would be even worse in that regard. Personality-wise I hate being a failure and I am someone who goes all in, which made it harder to admit I had made a mistake.
I had hoped transition might be the key to escaping a decade of depression, suicidal thoughts, and relapses to bulimia. I was wrong. My problem was not my gender, it was me, and I was back to square one. I also remember saying that if I had a pill that would make me not trans, I would take it in a heartbeat, which shows I should not have transitioned in the first place. I had thought I was mature enough at 21 when I began, and I was wrong.
When I decided to stop, in October 2019, I was surprised by how genuinely relieved I felt. I told people and saw understanding rather than the difficulty I had imagined. My partner of six years said she would love me no matter what; she is a gem. My mother was glad, and my father probably would be too. I planned to stop my injections and have what would presumably be my last appointment with the gender clinic to update them and possibly discuss my intentions.
Documentation was a real practical concern. I had not changed my passport, because the country of my nationality (not where I live) requires going through court to change it, while the country I live in does it easily with a recommendation. My bank account, my degree, and a newly signed tenancy agreement were all under my chosen name, so those had to be dealt with. I live in the UK with German citizenship. I decided I would probably just go back to my old name, even though I never liked it — it was very common and nothing unusual or bad, just a name I did not like, and possibly one of the reasons transition felt so good, to get rid of it. I planned to make more liberal use of my middle name, which is Korean and difficult for many people to pronounce, and sounds stupid in an English accent, especially alongside my hard-to-pronounce German last name. Eventually I decided to suck it up and stick with my old name: a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
Physically, my voice had changed and I was a little sad about it. I used to be a decent singer and did it a lot; transitioning made me pretty much unable to sing and too ashamed to try, and now I am okayish rather than good. Since I cannot go back, I focus on music in a way I can still enjoy. My Asian heritage gave me full head hair and sparse facial and body hair, except leg hair that has always been pretty dense, and I still have a cute Asian face. I am not overly concerned about these things. I also noted that I could probably pass as a woman if I dressed the part — a decent figure and a young, cute face help.
The biggest thing I had to work through was realizing I do not need my body to change for me to be me. I am not very feminine, but I am not that masculine either. I am just there, and me. I do not blame anyone else for the choices I made, but I am glad for the hurdles in my way — the passport difficulty and the three-year wait for hormones — and I am pretty happy I never got that far. I have seen people who are genuinely happy through transition, and maybe my mistake was thinking that was the path to happiness. I am happy for those it worked for, but the journey has ended for me, and I probably should not have taken the ride. Still, I am happy I know now rather than later.
On attitudes, I have never been a fan of trans activism; I think they do not have enough evidence for their claims, though I also think the gender critical group often does not either, and I believe feminism is wrong on many things as well, though it has good points and accomplishments. I was always against under-18s transitioning. I do not blame the surgeons too much — I blame the activists, because they made it common knowledge that it is okay and blocked scientific research by deeming it transphobic. I personally blame nobody but myself, since I was an adult. I do think some doctors and therapists are participating to a degree, but the machine around them is the main problem, and I doubt most doctors are fully aware of the negative consequences. I want real research: we need to know why dysphoria happens, what the consequences are, and how to identify who will regret it versus who will be happy. I am neither a TERF nor someone who thinks transition was just not for me; I think the whole thing is far more complicated than we imagine. I have defended the detransition community I participate in, while also calling out hostility toward biological men within it, and I operate on the principle that even if one innocent is among ten guilty, we should prioritize protecting the innocent, so everyone deserves to be heard.