Tutte le storie

Mi identificavo come maschio, senza mai fare la transizione, e ora per lo più indifferente

Femmina · Desistito/a365
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una femmina che ha desistito e che si identificava come maschio a livello sociale ma, per quanto emerge dai miei post, non ha mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi. Credo che la mia disforia fosse legata a disturbi alimentari, a un fidanzato abusivo e sessista e ad amiche misogine, e che iniziare antidepressivi/ansiolitici sia stato il fattore più importante per superare la mia lotta con il genere. Oggi mi sento in gran parte indifferente all’essere donna e mi descrivo come «solo una persona». Sono critica verso la transizione medica, soprattutto per i minori, e verso il linguaggio carino che normalizza la mastectomia. Non descrivo ideazione suicidaria né autolesionismo.

Storia completa

I have been posting in the detrans community through early 2023, and my comments paint a picture of someone who desisted socially rather than someone who went through hormones or surgery. When someone asked a research survey whether it was looking only for medically transitioned people or was open to social detransitioners and desisters, I asked the question myself, which suggests I fall into the latter category. I was born female. I never describe taking testosterone, getting top surgery, or any other medical intervention — in fact I explicitly warn others against altering their body surgically or medically if they have "ANY doubt whatsoever." My story is one of identifying as male socially and then coming out of it. What led me toward identifying as male, in my own telling, was a cluster of things. I've struggled with multiple eating disorders my entire life, and I noticed an overlap between having an eating disorder and having dysphoria: I only felt more comfortable about my body when I was identifying as male, because "men don't have to be skinny in order to be attractive/treated well." I also had a sexist, abusive boyfriend and misogynistic friends. In a long comment I explained that once I broke up with that boyfriend and stopped talking to those friends, "I realized that I wasn't striving to become a man, I was striving to become the kind of person that they wouldn't look down on." I told them to "rot." A specific moment of clarity came from a TikTok an FTM creator posted, captioned roughly "when you catch yourself doing something feminine," showing them in their car noticing a feminine hand mannerism and scrambling to look more manly. That was when I realized "gender is all just a big act." I questioned why I would give myself a hairy body, a beard, and a deeper voice just so strangers at Walmart or a McDonald's cashier would call me "sir" instead of "ma'am," when my family and friends already know who I am, and when it would cost thousands of dollars and damage those relationships. On medication, I said that getting medicated for my mental illnesses — antidepressants and anti-anxiety medication — was "probably the biggest factor in overcoming my struggle with gender." I don't name specific diagnoses beyond referring to mental illnesses. My current relationship to womanhood is detached rather than triumphant: "Being a woman doesn't mean much to me honestly. I just wake up and brush my teeth and drive to my job like any other person." I say I don't categorize people I see on the street as man or woman, just as person, and "that's what I feel like myself: just a person." I also offered encouragement to someone struggling, saying there's "no way for you to succeed or fail at being a female- you're already there," while telling them not to feel pressured toward anything stereotypically feminine. I don't describe any surgeries, hormone use, fertility concerns, or medical complications, because as far as my comments show I never medically transitioned. I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm. I don't give ages, dates of coming out, or dates of desistance. On advocacy, I'm critical of the current direction of trans activism, especially around minors. I've said that people are "fighting tooth and nail to have their ideologies surgically and medically enforced on children and it's terrifying," and I've mocked the framing that disagreement makes someone a "terroristic bigot." I find the cutesy language around mastectomy — "yeeting the teets" — gross because it ropes young girls into "this mess," and I worry that by the time they realize people oppose the trans movement for legitimate reasons it'll be too late and they're "vacuum-sealed into their affirmation bubbles." I've expressed sympathy for a detransitioning girl's post as "gut-wrenchingly sad" and hoped lurkers would see it as a cry for help and realize detransitioning isn't a hate crime. I'm also critical of detransitioners who debate on trans subreddits, saying it doesn't help our cause. I've shared an observation that a lot of FTMs seem obsessed with gay men — writing fanfiction and artwork depicting homosexual men together, roleplaying as promiscuous gay men in chat rooms — which I find "creepy... fetishization gone to the extreme," and I said the theory that they feel rejected as women but still want acceptance from men sounds accurate for some cases. Overall I come across as a desisted female who credits leaving an abusive relationship, cutting off misogynistic friends, and getting on psychiatric medication with getting past my gender struggle, and who now holds a skeptical, gender-critical view of transition while still feeling largely indifferent about being a woman.