Tutte le storie

Dall'euforia da testosterone a una critica femminista dei farmaci

Femmina · Detransizionato/a61
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition e ora ha una visione basata sul sesso e critica dell'essere donna e degli ormoni cross-sex. Paragono l'euforia degli ormoni cross-sex agli effetti delle droghe ricreative e sospetto motivazioni di profitto dell'industria farmaceutica, insistendo comunque che tutti hanno bisogno degli ormoni sessuali per la salute e che i medici che li negano dovrebbero risponderne. Le mie idee sul genere sono diventate sempre più femministe, compreso il rifiuto dell'idea che gli uomini siano protettori necessari e l'attribuire spiegazioni sociali al patriarcato. Comunico in inglese come seconda lingua.

Storia completa

I have been posting on Reddit for a few years now, and looking back at what I've written, I can see how my thinking has developed. In October 2022 I was mostly just chatting about movies and giving casual advice — I told someone to see a doctor about a symptom because "it could be something serious, but relax you are on time." By December 2022 I was already articulating a sex-essentialist view of womanhood. When someone was questioning what it means to be a woman, I told them plainly: "You are a woman. Being woman doesn't mean being 'femenine', just a person with female sex." That framing — woman as a biological reality rather than a performance of femininity — has stayed with me. It wasn't until November 2025 that I started writing directly about hormones and transition. I was responding to someone describing a euphoric feeling they got from taking hormones, and I was blunt with them: "Your body wasn't build for high dosis of exogenous hormones, let alone cross sex hormones. That thing you experienced is related to euphoric effects that can produce the steroids, even men who also consume them have that effect. It doesn't mean that you are built for it, it's like a kind of recreational drug." I compared the euphoria people report on cross-sex hormones to the effects anabolic steroids give men — essentially framing it as a drug high rather than an authentic signal. The next day I added that "Pharmaceutical industry use this to get a lot of money," which reflects my growing suspicion of the medical system's financial motives around transition medicine. In April 2026 I was engaging with feminist and political discussions. I pushed back on the idea that men are necessary as protectors, writing: "If all men on Earth disappeared, we wouldn't need them to protect us. Protect ourselves from what???" When someone offered an explanation, I attributed it simply to "patriarchy." I also gave some lighter advice to someone in Alabama about moving. On April 15, 2026, though, my position on hormones shifted in an interesting way. I was responding to someone who had been cut off from their hormones by doctors, and I urged them to fight for treatment: "You need to take your hormones to maintain a good quality of life. It's about health not aesthetic. You are too young to live like that, without sex hormones. That could have consequences in the future and life is only one." I told them to demand treatment from their doctors or sue them, invoking the Hippocratic Oath — noting in parentheses that English isn't my first language and explaining that doctors promise not to abandon patients. This tells me I distinguish between cross-sex hormones (which I see as recreational or cosmetic and financially motivated) and the necessity of sex hormones generally for health. I don't want anyone left without hormones entirely — that reads to me as a genuine medical abandonment. I don't talk much about my own direct experiences with transition in these posts, but my strong opinions about cross-sex hormones, my framing of womanhood as sex-based, and my suspicion of the pharmaceutical industry's role all suggest I've thought deeply about these questions, likely from personal experience. My most recent comment, from May 30, 2026, was removed by Reddit, so I can't recall exactly what I said there.