Tutte le storie

Non ha mai fatto la transizione, ma passa le giornate negli spazi detrans

Femmina · Desistito/a221
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna cis vicina ai detransizionati (una lesbica che ha fatto coming out con se stessa nel 2020) che non ha mai fatto una transizione medica ma si identifica come TERF e passa del tempo negli spazi di detransizione per interesse verso le questioni trans. Provo un disagio persistente verso i pronomi femminili, ho una storia di rapporto mentale con me stessa come uomo etero e un periodo di attrazione per le donne fatta di odio verso me stessa e feticizzazione prima di accettare la mia attrazione per lo stesso sesso. Sono antipsichiatria, diffidente verso i farmaci psichiatrici e critica verso la transizione come soluzione generale, pur riconoscendo che per alcuni può funzionare. Ho messo in guardia sui rischi del binding, sull'infertilità legata agli ormoni e sulla pressione a fare la transizione su persone non conformi al genere e autistiche. Al momento lavoro su me stessa prima di uscire con donne e non ho storia di transizione medica né rimpianti di detransizione miei da riferire.

Storia completa

I was born female and have always understood myself as a woman, though my relationship with that has been complicated. I've never wanted to be a man, and I've never seriously pursued transition, but I've spent a lot of time in detransition and gender-critical spaces because I'm interested in trans issues and find the discussions relevant to questions I've had about my own body, sexuality, and how I'm perceived. Growing up, English is my second language, and I've never felt comfortable being referred to as she/her — it feels demeaning and objectifying to me, though I put up with it in real life because people default to it. Online I prefer they/them, partly because text isn't inherently gendered and partly because I think pronouns should reflect how the speaker perceives the person, not the identity of the person referred to. I've also wondered whether some of that discomfort comes from internalized misogyny or from other people's misogyny. I've questioned my gender and think it's healthy for anyone to — cis people should question it too — but I always land back on being a woman, and I don't think it's good to obsess over gender or body either way. I've had some experiences that made me think about gender more: I've dreamed I was male, but it felt like wearing a character's body rather than being male myself; in dreams where I'm myself, I'm a woman. I've also related to a pattern of relating to myself as a straight guy mentally — looking up to male friends as role models, thinking I was attracted to women the way straight men are — while simultaneously believing you can't change your sex. In April 2020 I came out as a lesbian to myself, which I said was obvious in retrospect from the kinds of comments I was making. Coming to terms with that was hard: I described myself as having been a self-hating lesbian, said I still wished I could be attracted to male bodies, and admitted I'd had a fetishizing, objectifying way of being attracted to women because I thought my same-sex attraction didn't matter while I was presenting as straight. I said it would take a while before I felt comfortable actually dating a woman and that I wanted to work on myself first — get a haircut, clothes I actually like, and a cat. I've been critical of transition as a general solution, while acknowledging it can work for some people. I've said things like 'if you have to transition to fight your dysphoria and internalized misogyny, then you're just doing what it takes to survive,' and I've also said I don't think transition is the healthiest option for people dealing with trauma. I've expressed anti-transition ideology openly while also trying to say it's okay to be trans, since I recognize I don't have the experience of wanting to transition. I've warned about binding health risks, suggested crossdressing as an alternative to hormones for people worried about infertility, and told people to preserve their bodies for their future selves. I've also noted that exposure to trans content can increase dysphoria, that the ASD-trans link seems real to me, and that egg_irl-style 'feminine = trans' logic is no better than 'feminine = gay.' I identify as a TERF and have said so explicitly. I've described TERF beliefs as basically: transition can be medically unhealthy and doesn't always solve dysphoria, there's no such thing as male/female brains, and gender-nonconforming people should be accepted without pressure to transition. I've been antipsychiatry for years and am wary of psychiatric medication, though I've also said not to base opinions on therapists purely on what others have said since there are good ones too. I work in a male-dominated field and have a male-dominated hobby, and I've described feeling like the sole female representative in those spaces. I came out as a lesbian to myself in April 2020 and am not currently in a relationship with a woman but hope to be one day after working on myself. I have no history of medical transition, detransition, or surgeries to report because I never transitioned.