Tutte le storie

Nessuna rappresentazione, nessuna esposizione, eppure ha fatto la transizione

Femmina · Detransizionato/a51
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione, vivo nel Regno Unito e sono una millennial, e ho fatto la transizione da adulta pur non avendo mai avuto contatti con persone trans né alcuna rappresentazione, e ora credo che la mia transizione fosse basata su un trauma. Di recente ho smesso il testosterone dopo una disforia che mi accompagnava da sempre, seguita da una sensazione improvvisa e schiacciante che la detransizione potesse essere la scelta migliore, e mi sono mossa tra spazi trans e detrans per capire dove mi colloco. Sono scettica sul “contagio sociale” come spiegazione completa della transizione e temo che distragga dai problemi di salute mentale di fondo. Ho cercato attivamente di riabbracciare la femminilità e trovo utili i media con protagoniste femminili forti. Sono attiva in questa comunità detrans e ho contestato l’idea che i detransitioner siano rari.

Storia completa

I've been thinking a lot lately about the 'social contagion' theory that gets floated as the explanation for why people transition, especially around younger girls. I find it an odd theory, though I'm open to it being possible in certain social circles. What I find strange is how many people insist it's the sole reason for transition — it just doesn't work for people like me. I grew up around no trans people, didn't see any trans representation, and still ultimately transitioned as an adult. I believe my own experience was trauma-based. I also worry that by boiling transition down to 'social contagion' alone, we keep missing the mental health issues in younger people that do seem to lead to transition. I'm a millennial and UK-based, so I'm acutely aware that this may just manifest differently in the US, which is where I see most of the discussion happening — and I do wonder whether it's more of a Gen Z/Gen Alpha issue that I'm simply not seeing from my vantage point. I have had lifelong dysphoria, and then only recently I've had this sudden and overwhelming sense that detransition might be best. That shift has been disorienting. I've been spending time in both trans and detrans spaces to try to work out where I'm at mentally, because it's really easy to go down the radical path of either one — there are a lot of strong voices and compelling arguments on both sides. I've come to feel that being trans exposes us to traumas we otherwise wouldn't have to endure: social persecution, fear of certain spaces, medical trauma, fear of violence, to list only a few. It's an incredibly challenging time. I've recently gone off testosterone. I've found this detrans subreddit genuinely useful — it's been a place to learn what to watch out for, like strong emotional episodes and keeping an eye out for infections. I also think it's important to say, to anyone else in this position, that at the end of the day you have to be comfortable; only you get to live your life, not anyone else. We will experience traumas no matter who we are, so if you find that you're happier being trans, embrace it. Nothing is set in stone — we don't have one stable life identity, we're all numerous types of people throughout our lives, and if we can be happy for the most part I think that's the most important thing. On the question of how common detransition is, I pushed back on someone implying the community is tiny: I pointed out that 53k members on the subreddit seems to disagree, and even if only a third of us here were detrans, that's literally tens of thousands of people. I've also been trying to embrace femininity and feel good about being a woman again. I've found it helpful to look at movies, TV and literature with strong feminine leads — shows like Z Nation and Yellowjackets, which have loads of varied female characters and make me feel like there are so many ways to be a woman; sitcoms like The Good Place, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt and New Girl; and even cheesy movies like Charlie's Angels, Legally Blonde and Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen. I told someone else hoping to embrace their femininity that I'm going to try to do the same myself.