Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Ho fatto coming out come trans (FTM) alle superiori, poi all'università la disforia è semplicemente sparita e ho fatto detransition perché non era la strada giusta per me. Ora mi identifico forse come genderqueer o genderfluid, ma soprattutto sto bene nella mia pelle, vestendomi e comportandomi come voglio senza preoccuparmi di cosa pensino gli altri. Mi considero una persona che ha fatto detransition e che sostiene l'affermazione di genere, sostiene le transizioni altrui e rifiuta sia le agende anti-trans sia gli esterni pro-trans che parlano sopra le voci detrans. Dopo i ban dei subreddit GC di giugno 2020 sono stata preoccupata dal fatto che la comunità r/detrans venisse presa d'assalto da gruppi GC cis e pro-trans, lasciando chi ha fatto detransition e sostiene l'affermazione di genere con i downvote e riluttante a scrivere. In questo materiale non ho descritto interventi medici, condizioni di salute mentale o ideazione suicidaria.
Storia completa
I came out as trans (FTM) in high school. Then one day in college, I didn't feel dysphoric anymore. I don't really know what happened or how to define myself now — maybe genderqueer or genderfluid, I don't know how to even define it — but it doesn't bother me anymore. I dress how I want, act how I want, and don't care what anyone thinks about it. I'm comfortable with my body and who I am.
I detransitioned because it wasn't right for me, not because I wanted to push an agenda against people who were happy to transition. I describe myself as one of the gender-affirming detransitioners — I don't have a gendercritical position on other people's transitions, and I don't want to see this space used to push an agenda against people who transitioned and are happy with it.
What has occupied most of my attention since then is what happened to the r/detrans community after the gendercritical (GC) subreddits were banned in June 2020. I worried that people would try to use the subreddit to push their own agendas now that GC had been banned, because there have always been GC people flooding the sub and trying to speak for people who are detrans, which I've never been a fan of. I don't like censorship of any kind, but I also don't think cis GC people should use this subreddit as a soapbox. If you're detrans and GC, then that should absolutely be allowed because you're speaking from a detrans POV — and I feel the same about pro-trans individuals who come here. What I don't like is how the subreddit is brigaded by groups on both sides of the issue who try to push their own agendas.
I respect a detrans person here who has gendercritical views because they can speak from their own personal experiences. But when cis groups or pro-trans groups come here, it feels like they are trying to argue past us and over us instead of listening. I noticed that 'allies' were being upvoted and listened to more than actual detrans individuals, and it was clear the subreddit had already been brigaded as a result of the bannings. Detrans people who had been posting there for months were suddenly being downvoted en masse for saying they felt unsafe, while people claiming to be allies were being upvoted in scores. It was mind-boggling to see.
Because of this, I became honestly hesitant to post a lot there. And it's not detrans GC people I'm afraid of — it's the cis GC people who like to argue and speak over and past detrans folk. I feel the same way about pro-trans groups coming in. I just feel that the subreddit should be for detrans folks and that we should be able to discuss without interference from outside groups. I also pointed out that we aren't allowed on the trans subreddits and we were never really welcome on the GC subreddits either — we finally get a tiny little space meant to be about us and we're told we shouldn't even be there either. We can't win.
I worried that gender-affirming detrans people might not be welcome there anymore, and I doubted the mods cared to fix it or could even fix it. The fact that detrans folks who had been posting for months were suddenly being downvoted en masse for saying they feel unsafe was crazy to me — people want to say they are allies but they don't care what detrans people have to say if it disagrees with their views, which isn't allyship at all. I said I wished the cis GC folk would stop downvoting gender-affirming people who post there, and that detrans people should be able to freely express ourselves without fear of being silenced or argued with. I recounted one thread where a detrans person with a long post history was told they should maybe not post there if they couldn't grow tougher skin, by an individual who had never posted there before and clearly came because of the ban — I felt that wasn't okay. I also supported another detrans poster who had been downvoted for speaking about feeling uncomfortable, telling them they should be allowed to express their opinion as a detrans person without outsiders trying to shut them down, and asking what the point of even having a detrans subreddit is if we can't freely speak there.
I never described any medical interventions, surgeries, hormone use, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, sexuality, or specific regrets about my body in this transcript, so I'll leave those areas out rather than invent them. My main stated regret is not about medical details but about the process itself: detransitioning because transition wasn't right for me, and now wanting a space where detrans people can speak for themselves.