Tutte le storie

Non binario per anni, poi il concetto ha smesso di avere senso

Maschio · Desistito/a1,7K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition, che si è identificato come non binario e poi come trans per anni a partire dal 2015 circa, ma ho desistito più di cinque anni fa, prima di iniziare ormoni o interventi. Ho fatto detransition perché il concetto ha smesso di avere senso per me e sono arrivato a vedere la transizione come un'ideologia più che come un'identità. Dopo la detransition ho fatto i conti con isolamento, aumento di peso e perdita di espressione di me, e a volte mi manca l'identità creativa che avevo, ma non ho in programma di rifare la transizione. Sono critico verso l'ideologia trans e il comportamento degli attivisti, ma credo nel ricucire i rapporti con la comunità trans.

Storia completa

I was born male and identified as trans for years, starting around 2015 when trans issues mainstreamed. Before that I was already gender nonconforming — I painted my nails, grew my hair long, and wore feminine accents because androgyny felt avant garde and creative to me. I even told a friend who used it/its pronouns that I thought it was ridiculous and that we should identify by our sex but fight aesthetic norms instead. But then the political moment shifted and it felt like being trans was the only way the world would understand my self-expression. Feminist friends constantly shut me down for being a 'man,' and men didn't treat me like one of them either. I felt alone, and transition felt like an escape hatch — sold as a cure where you identify as this new thing and suddenly everyone understands and accepts you. I began identifying as nonbinary, which quickly tunneled into worsening dysphoria as I inundated myself deeper into trans discourse. Nonbinary wasn't enough; I started rejecting my body hair, bone structure, fat distribution, muscles, and grew to hate my body for every male feature it revealed. The more I involved myself in trans discourse, the worse my dysphoria got. I had never felt this way growing up — I never hated my body or sex, though I had insecurities. Seeing myself as trans encouraged me to fixate on gender insecurities and obsess with changing. I detransitioned because the concept stopped making sense to me. I couldn't rationalize it anymore and started to see transition as an ideology — it felt embarrassing and delusional. I stopped right before starting hormones and laser hair removal, so I avoided most medical changes. Being called a 'man' still feels a little off sometimes, but it's been years since I desisted and I no longer think about hormones or surgeries. I'm hairy again and have a beard, and I have no problem being male. I desisted over five years ago. I've described the feeling of detransitioning as waking up from a cult. I now think being trans is 'just an idea' — not real in the way it's presented. I've come to see transition as a practice or ritual devotion rather than an identity typology, and I think regret isn't all-or-nothing. I've struggled with the fact that no one ever really saw us as a 'gender' — they saw us as insecure in our sex and sympathized. I've also reflected that trans and queer identity became something akin to an aesthetic subculture, like being goth or emo, with body modifications signaling in-group membership. Since detransitioning I've dealt with real challenges. I gained a lot of weight, buy my clothes at Walmart, and don't groom myself well anymore — I went from high fashion to a bland dude. I moved to a tiny town and all my friends left the area, so I've been super isolated over the years. Self-expression has gone by the wayside. I sometimes miss being trans — that time had a creative and tender relationship with myself, and having a concept of self motivated me in a way that's hard to access now. But I have no plans to retransition. I've kept a few gestures of femininity but mostly look masculine now, and I don't hate it, though I've been thinking about being more femme again. I have ADHD, which I've noted gives me fixations and high anxiety. I've also experienced some hostility — I've been called the f-slur and had a truck full of men throw beer cans at me, though those moments are rare. I deleted a previous Reddit account after being targeted with hateful messages from transwomen over a post here, full of assumptions and bullying about why I detransitioned. I posted an AMA about being a desisted male that blew up unexpectedly — over 3 million views, 2.2k upvotes. Many people were genuinely curious and it felt good to get things off my chest, but some trans activists misrepresented me, dug through my old posts, called me 'fake trans,' and accused me of being a fascist propagandist. Their comments hurt more than the occasional bigot's. A journalist asked to turn the AMA into an article and I declined, saying that space should be reserved for detransitioners with medicalized experiences — as a desisted male I don't feel comfortable speaking for the whole community. I believe there's a lot of pain on both sides and that we should try to mend bridges with the trans community.