Tutte le storie

Una donna che non ha fatto la transizione sostiene prudenza e gentilezza nel dibattito

Femmina · Desistito/a42
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che non ha mai fatto la transizione e non si identifica come detrans, ma commento regolarmente in questa comunità. Sostengo che le condizioni intersex siano variazioni dello sviluppo del sesso maschile o femminile, non un terzo sesso, e paragono le comunità online sul genere al movimento fat-positive perché insegnano a ignorare gli istinti corporei in popolazioni vulnerabili. Sostengo le persone che lavorano sull'accettazione di sé e sulla detransizione, sono prudente verso procedure mediche come le protesi al seno e critica verso il linguaggio crudele o impreciso in questi dibattiti. Non ho una cronologia personale di transizione né rimpianti medici. La mia posizione è critica ma non categoricamente contraria alla transizione, sottolineando prudenza, onestà e gentilezza.

Storia completa

I was born female. I've never posted my own story here, but I've commented a number of times over the years and wanted to lay out what I've said and where I stand. I'm a woman. I've never identified as trans or detransitioned myself — I've said so plainly when replying to someone who assumed otherwise: "Not detrans but just to say that breast implants are not a minor surgery at all." I don't have a transition timeline of my own to give — no hormones, no surgeries, no coming-out dates — because I never transitioned. What I do have is a set of convictions about sex, bodies, and the communities that form around them, and I've shared those when they seemed relevant. On sex and intersex conditions, I hold that difference of sex development doesn't create a third sex. When someone generalised from their ex's experience to all intersex people, I pushed back: "Those with an intersex disorder (or DSDs) are still male or female they just have a developmental disorder. They aren't a third sex. If your ex didn't identify as male or female then that's fine but don't generalise about all intersex people and say that they aren't male or female. It can come across as offensive." I meant it as a correction offered in good faith — I even added "HTH" — because I think sloppy language around this causes real harm to people with DSDs. I've drawn a comparison between gender communities and the fat-positive movement that I think is worth spelling out. After watching a BBC programme, 'Who are you calling fat?', I wrote: "I think there is a parallel with the fat positive community with things like this. Teaching people to ignore their instincts." I described a fat-positive coach on the show telling overweight and obese people that any wish to eat healthily, lose weight, exercise, or even fear for their health was wrong and amounted to internalised fatphobia. My point was that "they are both communities that are largely online and have many vulnerable people in them." I was careful to add an apology in case the comparison offended, because I know it's a sensitive one, but I stand by the underlying observation: movements that tell people to distrust their own instincts about their bodies, and that recruit primarily online among vulnerable people, deserve scrutiny. I'm not hostile to people who detransition or to people who are sorting out their relationship with their bodies. When someone posted about their progress, I encouraged them: "I'm very happy for you! Maybe keep posting on here as things settle and you begin the next stage of your journey?" When someone else was struggling with self-acceptance and confidence, I told them I loved their curls and that they had confidence to pull off their glasses, adding: "I'm so glad you're in a better mental place, self acceptance is hard work but so worth it." I believe self-acceptance is genuinely hard work and genuinely worth it, and I try to say so when I see someone doing it. On presentation, I'm relaxed. "Nothing wrong with wearing 'female' clothes! I'm a woman and like to mix and match. As long as it fits you properly, is practical and makes you feels happy, go for it :)" I don't think clothes need to be policed, and I mix and match myself. I've also clarified terminology when it was muddled — "Yes basically. Detrans men are men who have detransitioned from being transwomen (MtF)" — because I think precision matters in these conversations. And when someone said something I thought was true but cruel, I said so: "That might be true but seems very unhelpful and unnecessary to say." Truth without kindness isn't a virtue in my book. I have no regrets about a medical transition because I never had one. I've never been on hormones, never had surgery, never identified as trans. My concerns are about the direction of certain online communities, the medical risks that get minimised — I've warned that breast implants "can cause many health issues and there have been multiple scandals about them. Not something to be undertaken lightly" — and the pressure placed on vulnerable people to reinterpret normal discomfort or normal bodily variation as proof of a deeper truth. I don't oppose transition categorically for everyone, but I think it should be approached with far more caution than it often is, and I think people should be allowed to voice doubts without being told their instincts are bigoted. I'm active in these discussions but I don't consider myself an activist. I comment when I think something needs saying, I try to be kind while being direct, and I care most about people ending up in a better mental place — which is the outcome I celebrate when I see it.