Tutte le storie

Quattro anni da adolescente trans, senza ormoni e senza rimpianti

Femmina · Desistito/aTransizione sociale 15 → Desistenza 18247
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto la transizione sociale al maschile a 15 anni e ho vissuto come uomo trans per quattro anni, ma non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi perché ero minorenne per tutto il tempo. Ho desistito all'inizio del 2023, a 18 anni, ho tagliato i ponti con la maggior parte di chi mi conosceva come trans e ora mi identifico come lesbica butch. La vergogna di essere stata una ragazzina trans è in gran parte svanita e sto dimenticando di essere mai stata trans. Non ho rimpianti medici dato che non ho mai fatto una transizione medica, anche se vivere una bugia per quattro anni è stato psicologicamente dannoso. Ora sono critica verso la transizione medica infantile e verso il modo in cui i detransitioner vengono usati da entrambi gli schieramenti attivisti.

Storia completa

I was born female and started identifying as a boy in my mid-teens. I socially transitioned and lived as a trans man for about four years, but because I was under 18 the entire time, I never took testosterone or had any surgery. I came out publicly and told people around me that I wanted to be referred to as a boy. Looking back, I don't think I was ever really trans in the way others claimed. I behaved in a stereotypical and, for a female, pretty misogynistic way — I was "acting like a real man" — and I now think that was driven by insecurity rather than by any feminist beliefs. In fact, I'm conservative and anti-modern feminism. I believe femininity is fine for those it suits, but I'm a butch lesbian and it never felt right to me. I think a lot of trans-identified females, myself included, were essentially "brainwashed into thinking our masculinity made us trans men." I desisted around the start of 2023, at 18. Coming back was easier than I expected: I had done nothing irreversible, so it was just a matter of telling people I wanted to be called a girl again. A few people asked why, but most didn't care beyond a question or two. The hardest part was coming to terms with it myself. I cut off nearly all the people who had known me as trans, and the shame and embarrassment of having been a trans kid has mostly faded — I'm forgetting I ever was trans. Now I'm just me. I haven't tried to be feminine, but I let myself be interested in whatever I'm naturally into. I still present butch and have a masculine-type face, so in public people often read me as a boy — I get mistaken for a child when I buy alcohol and have to explain I'm 18, not 12, which wears me down. I'm not ready to wear women's clothing because I don't like it, though I've considered makeup and feminine clothes just to stop being misread; it feels like it wouldn't be true to me. My hair is still growing out from the short cut I had, and I hate waiting for it. I also notice that people find my interests and music taste weird, but don't care if they think I'm a dude — I'm "weird" for a girl. I have no medical regrets because I never had hormones or surgery, though I did consider it. I've thought about testosterone's permanent effects — bottom growth, voice changes, hair loss — and I'm glad I never went down that path. I do carry some psychological scars from living a lie for four years; breaking down over the thought of faking being a man "made me feel like a complete f***ing idiot," and accepting that I'm stuck as a "weird female" was painful. I'm active in detransitioner spaces and give advice to younger people questioning transition. I tell them to find the root cause of their dysphoria — trauma, bullying, homosexuality, online communities — and to give it time, since medical transition is irreversible and there's no rush. I'm critical of how detransitioners are used politically on both sides: I argue that some activists dismiss us as "never trans" because our stories threaten the case for childhood medical transition, and I also push back against conservative audiences who only embrace straight, gender-conforming detransitioners while being uncomfortable with masculine or lesbian women. I'm skeptical of figures like Buck Angel, whom I view as a fetishist, and of Norah Vincent's experiment, which I don't find convincing. I don't seek out people whose company I probably wouldn't enjoy. I have not experienced suicidal ideation or self-harm since detransitioning. My mental health has improved as I've accepted myself, though I still deal with the social friction of being a visibly gender-nonconforming woman.