Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition, che si identificava come uomo, ha preso il testosterone per circa sei mesi, ha cambiato nome e genere a livello legale e poi ha fatto detransition intorno al 2013 dopo aver perso il lavoro, essere rimasta senza casa ed essere stata tagliata fuori dalla comunità che aveva affermato la transizione. Non ho mai fatto interventi, ma vengo ancora letta a caso come uomo o donna e di solito si presume che io sia trans, compreso l'essere stata accompagnata fuori da un bagno all'inizio del 2023. Ora ho una posizione intransigente contro la transizione (ma non contro le persone trans), dando la colpa alla negligenza medica e alla natura sociale/recitata della transizione, opponendomi però alla detransition forzata di chi ha già fatto interventi. Ho faticato ad accedere alla terapia e ho trovato sostegno nelle comunità online sulla detransition. Mi identifico come lesbica cis e dico che l'esperienza, pur non essendo qualcosa che nessuno aveva chiesto, mi ha insegnato moltissimo su me stessa.
Storia completa
I was born female. I had polycystic ovarian syndrome as a teenager, which made my periods extremely infrequent and unpredictable — roughly once a year I would bleed unexpectedly, while still getting the other hormonal mood swings, which left me feeling like "an insane person who would snap once a month for no reason." I also had a pre-existing heart condition.
I never felt that I was someone who experienced chronic oppression as a woman, and the constant insistence from hardline feminists that women are vulnerable and chronically oppressed alienated me because people were always describing how I should be feeling and what I should be doing. I was isolated and poorly socialized as a young person; I never felt I was "a girl people wanted to be friends with."
I was pressured fairly heavily into transition. Friends at the time — all of whom later abandoned me — were adamant that I was obviously a man and told me I took to testosterone better than others. I went on testosterone for roughly six months, during which I also had my legal name and gender changed. Testosterone initially felt like a relief: the hormonal turbulence ended and I felt peaceful for the first time in my life. But everything about it eventually felt wrong — I felt like a liar even when everyone else accepted it as the most true reality, and I hated having to dress up and act like something everyone else wanted. I became hyperfixated on how everyone else saw me, which worsened my health: on top of anxiety and rapidly deteriorating depression, the testosterone exacerbated my weight problems and blood pressure given my heart condition, and the risks were compounding.
I never got surgery. After about six months on testosterone and having changed my legal name and gender, I lost my job and became homeless. Because I couldn't afford it, I was forced to drop out of school and was severed from the people who validated the transition. Being entirely alone with myself — having honest conversations about what all of it was and what it meant — is what led me back to myself and to detransition. I detransitioned around 2013 (nearly ten years before March 2023), and at the time I had no word for what I was doing; as far as I knew detransition didn't exist and I was the only person it had been the wrong choice for, which felt invalidating and reinforced the sense that I was just a crazy person while everyone else was fine.
Since detransitioning I have never had surgery and did not transition in my teens, so in theory I am as close to my pre-transition self as possible apart from some unseen quirks and my voice. Even so, whether I get read as male or female is essentially a coin flip, and I am routinely assumed to be trans one way or the other; nothing I do fixes this. A few weeks before March 2023, security at a restaurant escorted me out of the restroom because a woman there thought I was a man. I generally don't correct people because I don't see the point in embarrassing myself.
I have struggled to get therapy — waiting lists are absurd and clinicians never call back. I have found community and support in online detransition spaces, and I actively welcome newcomers there. I draw anime-style wlw/yuri content for myself and used to post it online; the majority of my followers were trans women, and comments they made on my work became triggering and demeaning, which soured my feelings toward those communities even though I had nothing against trans women before. I also consume yaoi and have thought critically about how those genres are written by women for women and reduce male characters to desexed, sometimes prepubescent-reading versions of men.
I now hold a hardline stance against medical transition regardless of age or sex, given what I see as negligence by medical practitioners — noting that artificial food dyes have been better studied and regulated than HRT, and that a gynecologist would give me a very different answer about long-term low estrogen and high testosterone in a female body than an endocrinologist selling HRT. I am anti-transition but explicitly not anti-trans-person: I don't disbelieve that for some people it may be a legitimate life experience, but I don't believe medical/cosmetic intervention is the answer. I also oppose forcing people who have already had surgery and lived as their chosen gender to detransition, arguing it would cause more trauma and push people toward unsafe hormones obtained online. I have become wary of the broader LGBT community's tendency to gaslight and bully when you don't agree with everything, and I have said I would rather be "a lesbian alone with no friends" than endure that; I have also acknowledged I may be developing some transphobia from constant boundary-pushing, which I don't handle well. I am wary of lesbian apps like Lex and Her dropping policies excluding cis men, and I've noted the sharp rise in self-identified LGBT percentages (4.5% in 2017, 7.2% in 2022, 19.7% in 2023) as an incentive for those apps to be maximally inclusive.
On the whole process, I frame detransition as having given me hard-won wisdom — comparing it to Odin giving up an eye to see further — and I believe I've seen through the sexist and self-destructive teachings that led me down that path, coming out a better person. I think the social dimension of transition is the core trap: "perhaps I am trans" became "you are trans" because other people breathed life into it, and being suddenly seen felt the most valid I'd ever felt, even though I now recognize it as performative. I wish someone had asked me, "Who is this for? Is this really for you? Or are you doing it for them?" — because I was fully conscious I wanted to be a man other people would be proud to know. I identify as a cis woman and a lesbian.