Tutte le storie

Non è detrans lei stessa, ma è grata alla comunità

Femmina · Desistito/a121
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un'alleata della comunità detrans più che una persona che ha fatto detransition: sono femmina, non ho mai fatto la transizione e nei miei post non c'è nulla che descriva disforia, ormoni, interventi o una detransition personale. Nel 2019-2020 ho sostenuto con coerenza che la disforia di genere è una malattia mentale come l'anoressia e richiede terapia anziché transizione medica, criticando l'industria medica, l'«ideologia trans» e i suoi effetti sui diritti delle donne basati sul sesso. Ho suggerito a una persona psichedelici come Ayahuasca o DMT per risolvere l'ossessione per il corpo e ho espresso gratitudine per la comunità r/detrans come spazio sicuro. Oggi mi identifico come donna critica verso la transizione, in particolare per i bambini, e non ho rimpianti personali né una cronologia medica da riportare.

Storia completa

I was born female and I have never transitioned; my account here is that of a woman who posts in detrans spaces as an outside ally rather than as someone who went through transition myself. I first started writing in these communities in September 2019. From the beginning I framed gender dysphoria as a mental illness comparable to anorexia — "a person sees himself as something he isn't, it's mental and sexual" — and argued that cognitive/behavioral therapy is what is needed rather than hormones or what I called "medical mutilations." I believe the medical industry and surgeons profit from a lifetime of pills and surgeries, which is why I think children are being encouraged to transition. I encourage the young men I reply to to embrace reality, love themselves as male, and find a good therapist rather than "poisoning" themselves. I also give practical, low-stakes advice, like experimenting with hair because it grows back. By January 2020 my comments had broadened into a wider critique. I wrote that I was heartbroken for women generally, and described myself as "the opposite of a white man," saying I could not identify my way into privilege and instead had to "work with what I've got in a healthy way, this is the only real option, anything else is living a lie." I argued that most people can tell when a trans-identified male is male but stay quiet to avoid backlash, and that drugs and surgery cannot change hand size, height, foot size, gait, strength, mannerisms or "socially/biologically ingrained male thought patterns." I said trans-identified men pose more of a threat to women and girls than trans-identified women, "like wolves in sheep's clothing," and I argued at length with another commenter about whether radical feminism and transition are compatible, insisting a radfem would never transition because gender is a sexist social construct. In March 2020 I thanked someone for sharing a "harrowing cautionary experience" about surgery, saying it would help others. In April 2020 I suggested to a dysphoric person that they try an Ayahuasca or DMT trip, believing a psychedelic breakthrough could sort out an obsession with a "temporary body"; I described their situation as "a form of extreme body dysmorphia" and said gender is purely cultural stereotypes. I told them I am a woman with no "femaleness," that I am "just female by biological chance," and that I would be fine in a male body because I am not fixated on mine. In May 2020 I asked a detransitioned person directly why they detransed — first guessing osteoarthritis, then asking again — and whether women's sex-based rights or what I called the misogyny of trans ideology factored into their decision. In a long reply I set out my overall position: that the real issue is the psychiatric "treatment" of what I see as a mental illness or an unhealthy reaction to personal trauma, that professionals instead encourage the delusion and prescribe hormones and surgeries irresponsibly, that transracialism is condemned while transgenderism is accepted despite sexism, and that the situation forces people to live under a lie, "2+2=5 like in Orwell's 1985." I also said I am very grateful for the detrans subreddit as a safe space, and that I notice so many detransitioners there are women, which to me shows girls pick up on cultural misogyny and see transitioning as an escape from being female. I support adding single-unit unisex bathrooms. In July 2020 I made short, derisive comments about being labeled a TERF for any disagreement. I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, coming out, hormones, surgery, or detransition in this transcript, and I have not described therapy, mental health diagnoses, or adversity of my own.