Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first got into trans stuff at age 13, around 2013, and began socially transitioning that same year. My coming out was partly accidental — my mom caught me looking at trans-related websites, and her reaction, while not the worst, was somewhat traumatic, so I closed down after that. I had already learned about transgenderism from the internet and presented myself that way. I was professionally diagnosed with GID and Asperger's syndrome simultaneously; I rejected the autism diagnosis for years, though I have come to suspect it is correct. I have also come to suspect anxiety, depressive, and dissociative disorders, though I lack professional diagnoses for those.
During my social transition I restricted my expression and activities in an effort to pass — binding, slouching, dressing in unnecessary layers even in the heat of summer. I learned to be deeply ashamed of my body and my feminine aspects, and I cared far too much about what other people thought. I was afraid to wear women's clothes again; the last time I had done so was at 13. I tried to destroy that part of me, the feminine side, and I came close. I was killing myself slowly, fading.
My mom pulled me out of eighth grade, the year after I began social transition. After that I did some homeschooling, got my GED, and enrolled in community college part-time. I have yet to complete my degree due to issues with self-regulation and the fallout from my transition/detransition. My dad was always against my transition while my mom flip-flopped. My dad blocked me from medical transition, and it's mostly because of his efforts that I have any college experience at all and that I was unable to take testosterone until I was over 18. My mom decided to "homeschool" me. My parents have issues and I was largely neglected, left to my own devices, developing an over-reliance on the internet. My anxiety increased a lot and I hardly went anywhere.
I began testosterone at age 19. I took it for roughly 8 months and stopped. I had waited all those years for testosterone, and it wasn't as I'd hoped — I was devastated. I had been mostly ambivalent about the changes; I was hoping the masculinization process would be slow. It wasn't slow enough. I kept telling myself, "It's fine. It's just hair." Then I realized my voice had dropped a lot more than I was comfortable with, and I stopped. At that point I considered myself non-binary and had some awareness that I didn't really want all the effects of T. HRT turned out to be a huge letdown after waiting years imagining it would be the solution. I don't remember much excitement; it didn't feel real. I felt sorrow at losing who I was. I didn't hate myself before transition. I hated myself after.
I began detransition at age 20, around 2016. I didn't announce my detransition; I just stopped taking testosterone and things spiraled from there. I was distraught and my family had to deal with the fallout along with me. I think they were relieved I ceased pursuit of medical transition; I suspect they also felt betrayed on some level. We hardly talk about these things.
I was not highly disgusted with my biology except by association with internalized misogyny, especially prior to transition. I accepted my body. During transition, I became increasingly disgusted. I don't think I hated my body before transition — I hated being unable to control how I was perceived, and I strongly disliked certain associations with femaleness and femininity. I suspect I adopted transgender ideology in a misguided attempt to make sense of myself and belong somewhere. I always had doubts, but I was scared to change course.
Recently I have come to understand that some sort of trauma likely plays a significant role. I have found it difficult to identify the trauma, as I imagine trauma to be far worse than anything I've experienced. However, it remains that I experience some effects, e.g., dissociation. I have come to suspect I am unusually sensitive. I have a conflicted relationship with my mother from a very young age; last year I figured out she's narcissistic and therefore emotionally abusive. She cannot see me as a person of my own. A mentally ill woman was one of the last things I wanted to be, especially because that's what my mother is. I'm autistic, though I denied it for years in reaction to the way my mom used it — she disliked it because it differed with her expectations, and so I became a scapegoat. She uses it as an excuse to infantilize me. I appear to have more in common with my dad, personality-wise; he has his own issues and is emotionally distant. I'm the first of three children; my brother was my best friend, and I didn't get along with my sister, who is more than 5 years younger than me.
I have come to suspect I have BPD and maybe OSDD-1b — secondary structural dissociation. I knew early on that I had parts who felt different ways, but I was in denial about the trauma. My parts are more dissociated than average, and we have become increasingly dysfunctional. Parts of me beat down and suppressed other parts. I experience chronic dissociation, which got worse after I started social transition.
I tried therapy once back then, and it was a struggle simply to communicate my problems. I saw a few therapists over the years, but not regularly. Some tried to talk me out of being trans, which I did not appreciate. The therapist who provided my HRT letter might have been willing to explore my issues, but I was uncooperative — I was there to get hormones and surgery, and that was that. I trusted no one. I was not screened for trauma exactly; the subject arose once or twice but was dismissed quickly.
I regret most the lost time and opportunities. Second, what this did to me psychologically and the conflict it caused in my relationships. Third, the lingering effects of my time on testosterone. I grew quite a bit of body hair and some facial hair, and my voice deepened considerably. Most of these changes have been permanent, though I believe the hair and voice have somewhat lightened/thinned over time. In the beginning I did voice training to be more passable, which worked but felt uncomfortable; I don't bother with it anymore. I haven't particularly noticed any major health effects from T except some menstrual problems. I'm glad I didn't get a hysterectomy.
I did end up briefly hospitalized and required blood transfusions for heavy bleeding when I went off T years ago. It eventually stopped after they messed with my hormones and gave me tranexamic acid. I still sometimes take that or high dose (between 400-800 mg) ibuprofen when I get heavy bleeding. Earlier, birth control pills made things worse — the bleeding was so heavy it limited my activities, interrupted my sleep, and made me anemic. These problems seem to have cleared up since I stopped taking testosterone.
I have never dated and don't think I ever will. I guess it's somewhat related to my transition, in addition to being homeschooled. I started socially quite young, so I sort of lost my chance. I'm not too bothered about it, though.
I don't subscribe to trans ideology anymore, so I don't think in terms of "trans" and "cis". I rely on biological definitions: woman is an adult human female. Personally, I don't call myself a woman, but female, sure. I think much of my discomfort with "woman" comes from feeling not grown-up — I'm sort of stuck in between child and adult in various ways. I've always been female, it's a biological reality, but I'll never be much of a woman in my view. I've never felt comfortable calling myself a man either.
To me, detransition is simply what happens when I finally accept that transition doesn't work. I'm done. My transition consisted largely of unlearning lessons that had served me well in life before, and contorting myself into unnatural positions. I've spent years going in circles, getting more and more lost. This has been self-destructive and a huge waste of time.
I was sold a lie and I bought it. I remember writing in my journal around the time I began social transition, "Wouldn't it be better to accept my situation and make the best of it, rather than get medical treatments I don't really need?" I wasn't completely indoctrinated then. I knew it wasn't right, but I still allowed myself to be misled. I was lured by the idea that people would finally see the real me. The trans community taught and reinforced a lot of BS to me. I learned that detransitioners were virtually nonexistent, and if they did exist, they were transphobic, crazy, and in denial. It really seems cult-like. I was alienated from everyone, terrified and ashamed of my own thoughts and feelings. Deep down, I knew it was wrong. My family mostly disapproved, but I wanted so badly to belong.
I felt pressured to pass and follow a trans narrative, learned to suppress my feelings constantly and overdeveloped a false self. I didn't know who I was anymore. I felt trapped in this role. My true self has withered under these conditions. I have to relearn who I am and how to be.
I was afraid if I'd got this wrong it would make me a bad person with irredeemable shortcomings, so I persisted. If I'd believed in myself, I think I would have desisted within the first few years. I was trying too hard to fit in somewhere, and ended up trading one box for another, more restrictive box.
In the first few years of my detransition I was repeatedly told things like "we all did the best we could with what we knew at the time." I felt very guilty and ashamed of my actions and was told there was nothing to forgive. I just couldn't agree, not with the knowledge of having spent the whole time going against my better judgment. I still put most blame on myself, but let's be honest, it was not all my fault. Some of it was my parents. Some of it was other people.
I was feeling terrible for several years. I dragged it out longer than necessary, as I was very self-punishing. I wish I'd listened to those who told me that this would pass and that I could recover if I were kind and gentle with myself. Instead, I was unduly harsh, and it only worsened and prolonged the torment.
As of April 2023, being 6 years off testosterone, I wish I could say my life were better. Some things have improved, others have worsened. I'm still dealing with permanent effects. I don't remember why it used to bother me so much, and I don't think this is entirely a good thing. The pain isn't so raw anymore, but I didn't really deal with it properly. It's just faded into the background. I feel there was another big opportunity missed, early on, when that pain was active. I was waking up. But nobody seemed to know how to help me. And I've failed to help myself. And so I continue dissociating my life away. I used to feel more scared, angry, ashamed. Right now I feel mostly tired and sad.
I'm only a little older than some people I advise, and I'm somewhat ashamed to admit I've never actually sorted out my presentation. I still wear hoodies and jeans/sweatpants all the time. I still have this feeling as if I gave up my right to wear feminine things when I started social transition, and masculine things don't often fit me. Since I started social transition as a young teen, I never really developed my own style.
I don't get angry usually, but being sold this lie gets to me. I have struggled a lot with regret — guilt, shame, despair — over this whole thing, and I think it's taking me an especially long time to get over it because my life tends to be stagnant. Time does take the edge off; at this point I'm mostly OK with the changes from T. Detransition was extremely stressful at first, but things settled down eventually and I slowly stopped caring so much. I don't have to worry about passing anymore. I can have casual interactions more easily than before. However, I still haven't really allowed myself to heal and do things such as making friends.
I still struggle to live with myself and the consequences of decisions I've made. I feel like a monster, or as if I'm already dead, destroyed inside. I'll never be normal. But I could be healthier. I'm learning to accept how I feel and take better care of myself. Self-compassion really is the answer. I have to coax myself out with kindness.
I think transitioning can be very damaging to young people especially. I suggest looking into the various factors that may contribute to dysphoria and see what else you can do to manage it before taking medical steps. My advice to my past self would be to GET OUT ASAP. It's really not worth the sacrifice. I don't think about it so much anymore, since it did get better to some extent and eventually become the new normal.