Tutte le storie

A 18 anni, tra uomini molto più grandi, ho smesso di essere trans

Femmina · Desistito/a439
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Ero un «ragazzo trans» che si identificava come maschio e ha desistito dopo aver capito, a 18 anni, lavorando tra uomini molto più anziani, di non rientrare né nell'archetipo trans né nella vita da uomo, e col tempo ho superato l'essere trans. Ora mi identifico come donna e mi considero detransizionata, anche se ho ancora amici trans e ho opinioni contrastanti e in evoluzione sulla transizione. Penso che molto del desiderio di transizione FTM nasca dalla voglia di sfuggire all'essere percepite attraverso la lente dell'essere donna più che da un vero desiderio di essere maschio. Sono critica verso il concetto di «passing» e verso l'ideologia trans, e metto in guardia dal cadere troppo nell'estremo opposto, in camere dell'eco contrarie. In questo materiale non ho descritto interventi medici specifici, diagnosi di salute mentale né operazioni.

Storia completa

I desisted, but I still have many friends who are trans and wonderful. I have internal conflict with some aspects of transition but am still developing my knowledge on the entire subject. I just respect them and their choice to transition. I think it's unhealthy to go too far in the opposite direction with your views — don't spend too much time in echo chambers or you're no better than the far far woke mob. If you're too pro trans, criticism is fascism. If you're too far right, criticism is cancelling. Can't win. I've spent a lot of time thinking about what I call the archetypal FTM persona. Almost every popular FTM YouTuber or figure has a sort of impish, chaotic, cheeky personality that I feel is a representation of their perception of boyhood. Many younger trans guys emulate this sort of energy, but I find it interesting that it doesn't seem to be something that is grown out of but rather gets doubled down on as time goes on — like a Peter Pan style vision of perpetual boyhood. I don't doubt that a lot of these people have had intense dysphoria throughout their lives, but I find it interesting that many FTM people just happen to share such similar interests and mannerisms. The archetypal trans male personality also seems to be entirely distinct from the way that cis men of the same age group generally act. It's genuinely a bizarre thing I've noticed in recent years, like being a trans guy is in and of itself its own subculture with its own aesthetic. It makes me think that a lot of the desire to transition doesn't come from a genuine desire to be interpreted as male, but rather from a desire to be accepted as they are without being perceived through the lens of womanhood and the associations that accompany it. It's much easier to have fun and be goofy when you are emulating a boy, than it is to be a girl acting the same way. When someone suggested FTM figures are mostly bearded muscle jocks, I disagreed — definitely not the majority of FTM people, far from it. Even people like Ty Turner still act closer to boys than they do men. What actually led me to detransition was that I was an 18-year-old female "trans guy" in an industry of 40-something-year-old men and felt ridiculous calling myself a man in their wake. It's what led me to detrans: I didn't fit the archetype of a trans person, but also didn't fit in as a real guy. So I found out being a woman is actually fine, and basically just grew out of the trans over time. I've commented on medical and developmental questions too. When someone described changes they seemed stuck with, I suggested looking into FMS or possibly TRT, and noted that if they feel it is too much, the hairline will recede naturally with age, but the rest sounds pretty hard pressed to change back naturally — I hoped whatever the outcome they could be happy with their natural sex. On the question of a 10-year-old going through something, I pushed back: sexual maturity at a biologically appropriate time — nature has made 8-13 the time girls mature into women for a reason. It's not about "going through" it, it is what it is. I've also expressed blunter views, at one point stating flatly that "trans people don't exist," and at another complaining that the worst part of this trans stuff is you can't understand if it's trans girls (female) and trans boys (male) or vice versa — just say male children are at risk compared to female children. When a poster shared photos pre- and post-transition, I told them that regardless of how they dress, they are female in both sets of pictures. The difference being in the first set they don't look like they're putting on an act, they look more at peace with the world and like they're expressing themselves genuinely. There is nothing wrong with being female and expressing in a more masculine way — they can keep all the things they love about androgyny and masculine fashion sense and still be perfectly valid without feeling the need to put on a costume or be another person. In a follow-up I noted that a common theme with trans FTM people is that regardless of how much T they take they retain such soft and lovely facial features, and I said I thought they'd look very pretty when they detransition. I told them they still look female to me already, just like a butch girl, so if they detrans and chose to present as they are now they'd just look like a tomboy — they'd look attractive if they were more feminine too, but just as they are now is already decently feminine. More recently I've thought a lot about passing. Being the sex you are isn't about others' perception of you, it's about reality. The concept of "passing" as a detransitioner is odd because to pass you have to be faking something — when I was underage I would wear makeup to pass as over 18, and it's inherently rooted in appearing as something you aren't. To be a woman you don't need to dress feminine or be girly, you just have to be female. To be a male you don't need to dress masculine or be manly, you just have to be male. If we could separate those concepts it might actually help people, because encouraging detransitioners to keep the trans idea of obsessing how others identify you isn't sustainable and conducive to good mental health.