Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I am a cis gay man, not trans myself, and I came to these communities because a close friend of mine is FTM and I wanted to understand what he was going through and be able to talk with him about it. I have never transitioned, so I have no personal medical timeline of my own — my involvement has been as a researcher, a question-asker, and eventually an outspoken critic of how transition is being pushed on young people.
Growing up I always knew I was different from other guys. Around age ten, my male friend was chasing our female friend and I was chasing my male friend. I didn't understand why at the time. I matured into my male body and eventually accepted that I'm attracted to men and men only, and I've been comfortable with that. I've described myself publicly as a cis gay male and, at one point, as a cis male, and I've said I'm not trans. I'm in my thirties or forties — I've said "I'm 30-40" when talking about how I don't judge people on presentation.
I had a bit of depression growing up, like I think most people do, but I look back on it now as minor compared to adult problems — paying for a safe place to live, a car, insurance, food, phone, internet, and working 40 hours a week just to afford the things I actually want to enjoy. I've never had what I'd consider serious mental health struggles of the kind I see described in these forums, though in 2020 I mentioned that I couldn't find a job during the pandemic and was becoming depressed myself.
My involvement started in earnest in September 2019, when I waded into a debate about whether therapists should be sued for approving transition decisions that people later regretted. I took a hard line: I argued that you shouldn't make life-altering decisions while depressed, that you should find the root cause of the depression first, and that people who seek out the most approving therapist and then get what they asked for can't turn around and blame the provider. I compared it to suing a tattoo artist or body piercer for giving you exactly what you asked for. I called much of the regret "buyers remorse" and theorized that social media was the culprit — someone posts "I'm depressed, what do I do?" and gets answered "You're trans!" I was careful to say I wasn't personally attacking anyone and that I love everyone in the community, but I was firm that after you make a decision, there's only one person to blame, and that it's up to you to show up to that surgery or swallow that pill. I also worried that if every therapist whose patient later detransitioned could be sued, therapists would simply stop approving anyone, and I asked whether we could agree that there's a level of mental illness going on in the trans community.
Throughout late 2019 I asked detransitioners a lot of practical questions — how long they were on HRT, whether they did electrolysis, whether there was anything physical that had been affected by transitioning and then detransitioning, what specifically made them want to reverse, whether an FTM detransitioner wanted to grow their hair out. I told one person I hoped my questions would bring answers to anyone else who was considering transitioning and might have doubts. I explicitly said I was gathering information because my good friend was transitioning and I wanted to have answers ready that he might not have.
My views hardened over time. In October 2019 I was furious about parents allowing a child to transition, saying the child has no idea what's going on. I recounted being banned from a trans subreddit simply for recommending that someone talk to a therapist about how they felt, and I said that unless you 100% tell people in the trans subs to transition, you're treated as the enemy. I got banned from r/askgaybros for criticizing the trans movement, and later I was banned for advising someone to seek therapy before binding and possibly disfiguring their body. I described the whole thing as a huge scam that could ruin people's lives.
My central theory, which I said I was still working on, is that over-access to information is harming young people. A twelve-year-old with internet access can google why they feel weird about growing into their body and find fifty pages on Reddit telling them they're transgender. I believe most people go through some depression growing up, and the over-access to information lets them throw a label on everything. I've theorized that a lot of people who present as trans are actually on the autism spectrum, and that what they're feeling is a new sensation of "I don't fit in with societal norms," which is scary for someone on the spectrum, so they feel they have to be one sex or another to be acceptable instead of gay, lesbian, or bi. I also noted that I have luckily experienced dysphoria temporarily myself, which gave me some window into it. I believe only a very small percentage — around 5% — of people who claim to be trans actually are, and that the rest are bandwagon jumpers or social media leeches. I've compared the community to a cult, where a manly person with facial hair puts on a dress and gets forty comments about how beautiful they are, gets used to that treatment, and fears leaving because they'll be cast out.
I've been vocal about the sexual dimension too. I once relayed a detransition comment about someone not getting the chance to use their assigned-sex organs for sex before transitioning and regretting it, which I said was a whole new thought for me. I've also argued that a woman I heard about who wanted to appear bigger and stronger after a rape was trying to mask being a woman to prevent another rape, rather than being genuinely trans.
On policy, I'm not against trans rights in principle — I've said I believe people as a whole have equal rights from the get-go — but I'm against paying for someone else's personal anything. If you want top or bottom surgery, go pay for it yourself. I've said encouraging and allowing children to transition is immoral and unethical because they're still developing and should have no idea what trans is; they should make their own decisions when they're legally able to. I've raised concerns about puberty blockers, asking what happens if a teen goes on them and then transitions later — would they go through puberty as an adult, in college or in a job? I've also said surgery may be a little extreme in some cases and that I'd encourage a non-gender therapist for anyone questioning, to avoid label-stamping from Google.
In 2020 I started actively trying to intervene. I said I speak to trans teens and encourage them to grow up in their body, telling them it's perfectly okay to feel weird growing up. I suggested to a detransitioning 17-year-old that they talk to their supportive parents about their doubts and not make any big decisions hastily, and that medical advances are being made every day. I told someone they could be a big key voice in encouraging younger people not to even approach the idea of transitioning and in getting laws enacted to protect younger people, and I floated the idea of speaking at schools or starting a YouTube channel to talk about progress. I even joked about managing someone's content launch, saying no one else is talking about this on a larger scale.
I've also been personally supportive in a quieter way — offering to help someone out if they were nearby were it not for COVID, telling people to do whatever makes them happy, and advising a detransitioning person on how to navigate living arrangements and a partner situation while they got back on their feet.
As for sexuality, I'm a cis gay man married to a man. I've said my husband and I have been more accepted by the right than the left, with people saying "Cool, you two are married and don't force anything on anyone else." I've never experienced internalized homophobia that I've described — I accepted being gay — and I don't experience misogyny or misandry as a driver of anything in my own story. My involvement comes from loyalty to a trans friend, curiosity, and then genuine alarm at what I came to see as a medical and social failure being inflicted on confused young people.