Tutte le storie

Gli dissero che amare un uomo significava diventare donna

Maschio · Detransizionato/a600
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono nato maschio e sono cresciuto gay, volendo essere una donna perché mi avevano detto che amare un uomo lo richiedeva; ho vissuto una «tripla vita» da etero, da gay e da persona trans per lo più online. La mia transizione medica si è limitata a un breve periodo di creme a base di fitoestrogeni, di cui mi pento, e non sono mai arrivato a interventi o ormoni prima di desistere, più o meno quando ho iniziato l'università. Ora mi identifico come uomo gay desistito/detransizionato e resto critico verso quella che vedo come la medicalizzazione dei giovani e verso gli spazi detrans moderati da persone trans anziché da detransizionati. Affronto l'odio per me stesso con l'umorismo («mi odio comunque ed è molto più economico!»), evito le persone ostili, bevo un sacco di Pepsi e mi nascondo nei vecchi videogiochi.

Storia completa

I was born male, and as far back as second grade I knew I 'favored guys' — I remember a dude in blue shorts in those Bowflex commercials. Growing up I was shown and told you had to be a woman to love a man, and being gay was 'a sinny sin sin' (I know trans people weren't accepted either, but I'm talking about the WANT to be a woman, not that it was easier to be trans than gay). That upbringing led me to live what I called a triple life: my normal 'straight' life, my 'gay' life, and then the trans side, which I only pursued out of the way — driving to another state so nobody who knew me would see — before having to return to 'straight' life. My actual 'transition' was very limited: a brief period of phytoestrogen creams. I regret using those creams. The damage to my body has not been as severe as it has been for other people. I never got to the point of surgery or hormones; I had to take a few years off between high school and college to work up the money to afford it, and college loans absolutely scared me. By the time I was in college I was more or less desisting. Most of my interactions while 'trans' were online. I'm part Asian, and without a lot of surgery or makeup it was pretty easy at the time for me to look the part, since a lot of those features come off as 'femme' if people think you're just white. My interaction with trans people as a community was the second persona where I still was 'cis', which was mostly furry circles around me and the LGBT group on my college campus. Those furry circles distorted my view of it — it was hardly accepting unless you did EVERYTHING they said and believed everything they did, and since a lot of the beliefs were very similar in method to Christianity it put me off immensely: the whole 'believe something that you can obviously see isn't true based on faith' sort of thing. The only time I felt validated there was because before I had surgery and got fat (the weight gain not related to anything here) I was considered very hot, especially in a community of furries not well known for attractive members. In my 'boy' mode I was still wanted, until it became clear I wasn't okay with the overly sexual nature of it all. My experience with trans people on campus was even worse. One person told me 'more people are trans if you just tell them' and went around asking people things like, since I liked rain, that I was pluviogender and thus trans. It didn't sit well with me how they were going about it. Then there were attacks on me because I wouldn't sleep with people. They never made me feel special, only attacked. I can see where it could be accepting — if you were willing to pretend or easily manipulated into it. It took some time for me to condense it all and realize I'm just gay. I didn't want to be a trans woman, even if at times I still wanted to be a 100% cis woman — being a trans woman was not what I wanted to be. I still think that if I had been born a woman, not a trans woman, I'd be happier, but that's not going to happen so it's not really something to think about. Being told trans women and cis women are the same doesn't make it feel the same either — I know it's not. I've spent a lot of time in detrans and gender-critical discussion spaces. I posted about how the 'actual' detrans support sub is not really for detrans support: I had wondered why all the moderators for the place were trans, not detrans. I said nothing offensive, got dogged on by transgender people who then claimed it was THEIR space and inserted TERF dogwhistle claims. The post that got me deleted there argued that girls are extremely susceptible during puberty to hating their bodies to an extreme degree, and that some people use that hate to say 'oh, you hate it BECAUSE you're trans, and this is the cure for you' — which is why detransitioning is much more of a female problem. I also pointed out that getting breasts cut off is suggested more often than having a penis cut off, that breast growth in males can be kind of reversed without a lot of damage but is considered cosmetic so you have to pay for it, and so a lot of desist/detrans MTFTM people are not represented in the severe levels of harm, while most surgery regrets are done by detransitioned women. I view the other sub as radical when it encourages retransition or staying trans about addressing detrans issues and literally calls it a 'trans space' over detrans. On another post they claimed saying 'MALE' was a dogwhistle. I've thought a lot about the statistics: the famous 2% detransition rate came from ONE gender clinic where the numerator was how many people came back to that clinic to get help detransitioning, while the denominator included EVERY person who ever came in, neglecting to mention that over half never came back after two or three visits — and most of those would be where your detransitioners are, because why would most detrans come back to a gender clinic? I said the people who put that number together KNEW they were being deceptive. I've cited other sources suggesting detransition/desisting rates for those handled with an 'affirm and medicalized' first approach, and the push on minors, are closer to 30%, while acknowledging these are people still around gender and hormone therapy. I also argue it's hypocritical to say 2% is meaningless for detrans when trans people are also at most 2% of the population. On attitudes: I don't direct hostility at people being trans, but I do toward people who use being trans as a shield for accountability, and those who use things like blockers to lie to the public. I think a lot of people who detrans are met with extreme vitriol from the QIA community — not because our experience devalues transgenders, but because it devalues the push for medicalization on younger people, which they conflate as an attack on 'all trans and identities under the trans umbrella'. My practical view is that it comes down to not exactly believing it's true but helping people feel better about it: if someone wants to be a woman, we both acknowledge they're not, but I call them that anyways — kind of like how, being around a lot of furries, I call people a wolf or kitty even though we both know they're not. But I don't think they should demand acknowledgment because of a new definition they told me to accept, and I don't think they should get Title IX benefits for being a woman, though maybe for being trans or gay. I've also reflected on how the direction of transition desire has changed: we used to understand transitioning as the best, if not perfect, solution for dysphoria — we wanted to be the 'other sex' — whereas now games have nonbinary options and top scars on playable characters, and people seem to WANT to roleplay as being trans rather than as the sex they wanted to be. I wonder how much of it is that people wanted to be trans rather than wanted to be cis other-sex. As for my own wellbeing, I've said bluntly 'I hate myself regardless and it's a lot cheaper!' — a joke I make instead of paying for therapy. I avoid hostile people anymore. I drink a lot of Pepsi and hide in old video games because the new games suck. I've talked to lawyers, though not over this issue, and I've advised someone else that if a procedure was a 'rush to transition' they could use a friend as a witness and that it's sometimes better as a class action to paint a pattern of malpractice. Current status: I identify as gay — a gay man who once pursued a limited, cream-based medical 'transition' I regret, and who now considers himself desisted/detransitioned.