Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nato maschio, ho fatto la transizione da adolescente con i bloccanti della pubertà e poi con gli ormoni, e all’inizio del 2022 ho deciso di fare detransition dopo anni in cui mi sentivo osservato, provavo disgusto allo specchio e non potevo mai essere una ragazza biologica. Oggi mi identifico come ragazzo femminile, anche se sono ancora incerto e non credo più davvero nel transgenderismo. Mi pento del danno al mio corpo causato dalla transizione medica precoce e del danno al rapporto con la mia famiglia, compresa la reazione violenta di mio padre al mio coming out. Ho trovato la comunità detrans più accogliente della comunità trans quando ho espresso dei dubbi. Nei miei post più recenti mi sto ancora interrogando sulla mia identità.
Storia completa
I was born male and, for as long as I can remember, I wanted to be a girl. Looking back, I think a lot of that may have come from my childhood and life experiences — my parents repressed any kind of "feminine" attitude, which taught me that I could only wear certain clothes, use makeup, or sit and walk a certain way if I was a woman. I transitioned as a teenager with puberty blockers; the truth was a mess. My coming out and acceptance was not the easiest — my father yelled and punched me — and I feel that I hurt my whole relationship with my family by doing so. I also took hormones at an early age and, because I didn't develop as a teenager, I feel I ruined a big part of my own body.
I transitioned socially as a girl (MtF) about two and a half years before February 2022, and those were the happiest years I'd ever had. But the looks of people around me wore me down. I felt like I was hurting my family and my close circle, and I knew I could never be a biological girl — "that's only in my dreams that will hardly ever be fulfilled." In February 2022 I posted that I just couldn't pretend anymore and had decided to detransition, asking for advice. Around the same time I also posted, "I give up, I cant keep going with this."
By June 2022 I wrote that I was tired and didn't know how to express myself. Outside, I always felt watched — every place I went I felt stares and whispers, and I said I knew it wasn't just social anxiety because several people had confirmed it to me. Even looking in the mirror I felt disgusted. I wrote, "I know I will never be a girl and that hurts like shit." After several years of transitioning I began to regret it. I did a lot of research on various forums and, after what I called a kind of awakening, realized I could no longer keep fooling myself and pretending to be something I'm not. Maybe I'm more like a feminine guy. I started to seriously doubt whether trans people exist in the scientific sense — "I do not know what to think." I said I didn't want to be told it was okay to transition because I would never feel like a real woman; I just wanted to feel good with myself being a guy. I described feeling trapped and desperate, saying I had ruined my relationship with my family and my body.
In October 2022 I related to someone else who had transitioned as a teenager, noting that people tend to perceive me as a young trans guy. In December 2022 I told someone else considering detransition: "Detransition is not for everyone. Nowadays I don't truly believe in transgenderism, but that's only my opinion." I suggested they go to therapy to clarify their mind before deciding. I also described how, as a teenager, I was told about the irreversible and bad changes my body would have from HRT and puberty blockers, but I didn't trust those warnings. Now I've seen more research about side effects and detransition communities, but when I raise it with trans or supportive people they show me contradicting studies, and I find other studies proving my point — "I usually end up desisting because people will always believe what it's convenient to them."
I came to believe that stereotypes are what make people think they're trans: "Oh, so man shouldn't like cute things or can't use the clothes they want, I wish I was a woman so I can be free." For me it's something of self-acceptance rather than trying to change yourself. I suggested to others that maybe they were raised in a conservative culture that didn't allow them to express who they are, and that being a gay man or having girlish attitudes isn't bad — you don't have to change to fit in society.
In March 2023 I encouraged someone worried about their doctor's reaction to detransition: "He's a doctor, not your friend. I highly doubt he won't consider you as a patient because you wanna take back a decision you made." In April 2023 I described my own experience of community: trans people usually get mad when I say I'm not completely sure about transitioning or that I'd rather be called by my birth pronouns. I thought the detrans community would be the same, but when I expressed my insecurity about being trans, they helped me and told me everything would be okay and that I should search for my happiness and comfort whether living trans or detrans.
I have not described any specific therapy I've undergone, any surgeries beyond my reference to "you chose your surgery" in a general comment (which may not be about myself), fertility testing, or a formal detransition date. As of my most recent activity in December 2023 I was still questioning, leaning toward identifying as a feminine guy and doubting the scientific basis of transgenderism, while acknowledging that detransition isn't for everyone.