Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I've spent a lot of time on these forums over the years, and I want to lay out where I've come from and what I think now.
I've never really fit neatly into the boxes people tried to put me in, but I've also never been convinced that the answer was to blow up those boxes entirely. I've been 'one of the guys' my whole life, and honestly, that's been a comfortable place for me. I've never been told a rape joke, which apparently puts me at odds with a lot of women's experiences online. I don't know if that says more about the circles I've moved in or the circles other people have, but it's my reality.
I've watched a lot of people, especially young people, go through the process of identifying as trans or as a lesbian and then later changing their minds. When I've seen someone post that after getting to know themselves better they're more attracted to men than women, I've asked bluntly whether it was all a phase and whether they really have it figured out while their mom is the idiot. I know that comes across harsh, but I've genuinely wondered about the certainty people express at young ages about identity questions that used to be understood as more fluid.
I've thought a lot about parents in this situation. I've defended parents who hold the view that there are only two genders, arguing that it's possible they just wanted what they thought would make their kid happiest in the end. I've suggested that they might believe teenage behavior is typical rebelliousness, that identifying as lesbian or transgender could be a result of pressure to fit into a group and feel like you belonged, and that eventually it would fade away. The worst thing, in my view, is making permanent changes that linger long after someone outgrows those feelings.
I've been critical of gendercritical spaces too. When someone said men aren't inherently good for women, I pushed back and asked what that even means and whether it's a bad thing to have a father. I've called it blind rage and suggested 'genderhypocritical' would be a better name for what some of those spaces are about. I don't think hating men is a coherent feminist position.
I've also been skeptical of the framing around trans identity in ways that have gotten me downvoted. I've compared being trans to a 'pseudoscientific, contagious mental disorder' where someone destroys their body's natural state by ingesting or injecting chemicals and having their body mutilated to achieve comfort promised by 'other miserable and confused people.' I've agreed with the comparison to dance mania, and I've said I'm pretty convinced the witch trial situation was caused by ergot-infected rye grain. I've described the trans community as preying on the weak, saying 'like crabs in a bucket they want everyone else to share in the misery' and calling it 'the only contagious mental illness I've ever heard of.'
I've been annoyed by what I see as hypersensitivity online. When someone complained about men being overly nice to them, I pointed out that there are people dying of famine, disease, congenital defects, and cancer, and that if you're mad because strangers are nice to you, you might be the one with a problem. When someone complained about not wanting to smile, I pushed back that smiling makes people happier and there's no reason to have a dramatic pouting face all the time. I did walk that back a bit when the person said it was good to hear I wasn't trying to be a jerk.
On policy, I've opposed Canadian Bill C-8, linking to the legislation and saying it's horrifying to see the word 'cisgender' in a proposed bill — that's enough for me to oppose it standing alone.
I've also made a cryptic comment about a scar being 'done by an artist rather than an injury,' which I'll leave as I said it.
As for my own story, the transcript doesn't include much explicit detail about my own transition or detransition timeline, so I won't fill in gaps that aren't there. What I can say is that my views have been shaped by watching others go through this, by being someone who's always been comfortable around men rather than alienated by them, and by a general skepticism about permanent medical interventions made during periods of psychological precarity. I don't advocate against other people's choices so much as I advocate for caution, for pushing back on online groupthink, and for taking seriously the possibility that young people might outgrow identities they're certain about in the moment.