Tutte le storie

Un gay femminile che ha trovato la risposta in un bar, non in una clinica

Maschio · Desistito/a283
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo gay che ha fatto detransition e che oggi rifiuta la transizione medica come soluzione al disagio di essere un gay femminile, e consiglio agli altri di cercare la comunità gay di persona invece degli spazi trans online. Metto in guardia dal lasciare che la detransition diventi una nuova transizione incentrata sulla ricerca della convalida dell’aspetto da parte di sconosciuti. Vedo l’essere trans e l’omosessualità come cose distinte e sono critico verso il movimento trans online come fuga dalla realtà ordinaria. Attribuisco al fatto di aver frequentato comunità gay nel mondo reale sui vent’anni il cambiamento della mia prospettiva. In questo materiale non descrivo interventi medici, chirurgici né diagnosi di salute mentale.

Storia completa

I am a gay man who has come out the other side of identifying as trans, and I want to be honest about what I've learned. In my view, hormones, surgeries, and behavioural training only allow you to achieve a crude facsimile of the opposite sex, usually one that reflects outdated stereotypes. There is no "becoming" something else; it is an elaborate performance dependent on powerful drugs, money, and mental endurance. Transition used to be an absolute last possible resort to relieve debilitating dysphoria in transsexuals. When I read posts from young men who seem to be trying to escape the realities of being a gay man, I recognise the impulse — I've certainly been there myself. I think "transgenderism," as a social movement rather than a meaningful diagnosis, is now often used as a way of escaping basic realities that make us uncomfortable, including the completely normal feelings people experience during pubescence. There are plenty of issues and problems amongst gay men, but I'm not sure subscribing to a lifetime of medicalization is going to solve the problem — because, fundamentally, you don't have a problem. There is a long recorded history of successful feminine men, both gay and straight. Nothing stops you from finding love beyond the limitations you're placing on yourself. My advice is to join an in-person meet-up or community of gay men; you'll get a much better perspective than any online space can give you. I speak from experience about how much time I wasted in curated online worlds. A lot of people's illusions are maintained by bending the reality around themselves, no matter how ridiculous it gets. They've decided certain things in their minds to support the conclusions they reach about their own identity, and encountering someone else whose mere existence breaches that flawed logic will be seen as a threat. They are trying to foist their flimsy, arts-and-crafts-made brain math onto you to maintain the infrastructure of their own delusion — not only is their answer to the problem wrong, but they're actively changing the numbers in the equation to "solve" it. I also want to speak to the fear that keeps people locked in online spaces. You will be fine. If you're concerned, you don't need to disclose anything about trans or detrans history — it has very little to do with being a homosexual male. Go with the intention of observing and listening. The LGBTQ community is not as mono-minded as it sometimes seems. Transness and homosexuality are not interchangeable; they are distinct and separate things, conflated only because of a catch-all label that becomes more and more meaningless every day. The rhetoric of online communities enforces the paranoid belief that we should live in a permanent state of fear about how others perceive us. Most people don't give a fuck — they're just living their lives and trying to get through their days, and they aren't going to give you a second thought. This is why it's important to engage with actual communities rather than sitting in the curated reality of Discord servers, online interfaces, and the endless social media scroll. That isn't reality. It really wasn't until my early 20s, when I started going out and actively participating in actual gay communities, that I realised how diverse they inherently are. I always operated on the assumption that I would be rejected for some reason, but that sense of unworthiness is almost the connective tissue of gay communities — a lot of gay men grow up feeling it. I spent way too much time in gay bars, and I knew plenty of gender non-conforming gay men who were always getting far more action and attention than me. I also feel strongly about how people conduct themselves after detransition. I think it's important that people don't let detransition become their new transition. There's been an influx of selfies in the sub of people asking for critiques of their appearance, and while I understand the desire for an opinion outside the umbrella of trans affirmation, relying on the validation of strangers is how a lot of people end up in this mess to begin with. The best part of walking away from all of this is the freedom it offers, but you have to choose that freedom, and that requires some fundamental habit-changing. Having complete strangers scrutinise your accessories, your neck, your hair, and so on is just going to keep you on a path to nowhere. If you want opinions about your appearance, ask close friends or family members you trust — or a colleague who sees you every day. These people know what you look like, and it isn't based on a curated selfie. The nitpicking in the replies in some of these threads reads like it's based on immature stereotypes, a lot of which are outdated and unworldly to begin with. If your goal is just to "blend in," that isn't something that necessitates a community of faceless strangers hyper-analysing your appearance on the internet. Ultimately, many of the battles people fight are entirely in our minds.