Tutte le storie

Il femminismo radicale le disse che essere donna non era essere femminile: è rimasta piatta e arrivata…

Femmina · Desistito/a117
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition: ho fatto coming out come bi, poi lesbica, poi di nuovo bi, e alla fine ho capito che sarei sempre stata femmina a prescindere dall'intervento. La mia detransition è stata guidata da un pensiero femminista radicale che separava la femminilità dall'essere donna, e non ho mai preso testosterone. Ho un ADHD grave (prima diagnosticato per errore come ASD) e sono stata critica verso la teoria del genere e verso le donne trans che si identificano come lesbiche. Sono attiva nel sostenere chi sta facendo detransition o si interroga, e al momento mi identifico come donna butch/cis con il petto piatto, a mio agio con questa identità.

Storia completa

I came out several times in my late teens and early twenties — first as bi, then as a lesbian, then back to bi — and I've told others that you can come out as many times as you need because you're still learning who you are and you're ever changing and growing. I'm a flat chested, 6'2" woman, and I've described myself as reading as a butch female, like a pre-T trans boy. I was very sure of myself at 15, but by 22 I was completely different. My detransition was driven by a few realizations. I described 'low, under the radar signs' like realizing that no matter how much surgery I got I would still be female. My biggest 'aha moment' was becoming a radical feminist and understanding that feminine does not equal woman and masculine does not equal man — once I had beaten into my head that I could be a flat chested, makeup-less, short-haired woman and still be a woman, I became a lot more comfortable with myself. I've questioned whether some people want to be women because it feels more acceptable to be a trans woman than a feminine man, and I've criticized gender theory as rooted in gender roles, arguing that it reinforces stereotypes (what I called 'lady brain'). I've also been critical of trans women identifying as lesbians, calling it an opposite-sex attraction — 'a straight relationship branded as gay' — which I see as harmful. On the medical side, I have never taken testosterone, though I've advised others that stopping and starting T would be rough on the body and recommended stopping completely for health reasons, noting my belief that it can cause cancer. I've also told people that a lot of women with PTSD have dysphoria, and I've noted that someone's post history showed PTSD and fear of disappointing their parents. I've been supportive of people detransitioning, telling them that being 'not in the right mental state' proves their thoughts on detransition are valid and that detransitioning doesn't make them 'less trans' now. I was diagnosed with severe ADHD (not ASD), though I was previously misdiagnosed as ASD, and I've noted that ADHD and ASD are very similar in terms of brain function — difficulty turning thoughts into words, getting overstimulated, lashing out in anger, enjoying routine and repetition, hyperfocus, and very emotional responses. I went through something similar to a girl a parent was asking about, and what helped me most was a new environment away from trauma. I've advised parents to encourage their child to love their body, talk about their own struggles, and give it time and positive distractions. I've been open about family difficulties — my stepdad is 50 and going back to school for a different career and separated from my toxic mother — and I've used that to tell people it's okay to discover yourself, change, and grow at any age, and that anyone who says 'well you USED to be X so you were really faking it' can eat rocks. I've been active in supporting others in the detrans community, offering to PM people, thanking people for coming from /all and not being trolls, and complimenting others on looking healthier, happier, and like their eyes look happy. I've also told someone they 'gave me butterflies.' I've encouraged people to live life for themselves rather than for their parents.