Tutte le storie

Bullizzato per essere maschio, poi un manga lo ha riportato indietro

Maschio · Detransizionato/a1,1K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition: ho vissuto come donna trans per tre anni prima della detransition e ora mi identifico come maschio e sono in pace con l'essere maschio. Ho fatto la transizione in gran parte per il bullismo e la vergogna di essere maschio, oltre alla convinzione che le donne stessero meglio, e ho fatto detransition dopo aver capito che la transizione non risolveva i miei problemi di fondo e dopo che un manga mi ha aiutato ad accettare di essere maschio. La mia famiglia mi ha sostenuto sia nella transizione sia nella detransition, e ho scritto lunghi saggi analitici e gestisco un server privato di sostegno per maschi detrans e un canale YouTube come attivismo. Ho accennato a stati mentali pericolosi del passato e al fatto di aver quasi messo fine alla mia vita per il dolore di essere trattato male in quanto maschio, ma non ho descritto ideazione suicidaria dopo la detransition. Sono critico sia verso le narrazioni della comunità trans sia verso certe cornici anti-maschili presenti in alcuni discorsi femministi e detrans.

Storia completa

I am a detransitioned male — I transitioned male-to-female and lived that way for about three years before detransitioning. I shared my experience publicly in January 2021 in a post titled 'My experience as a Detrans Male (3 years of transition),' which I described as hard to make but cathartic. I live in Belgium, and my local transition organization bluntly told me I was 'one of the first to go through detransition' here, which shocked me and motivated me to help build support structures for others. On what led me to transition: I have identified two main vectors in my own case. The first was trauma — I was bullied a lot, including for being male, and I developed a shame of being male. Growing up during the rise of third-wave feminism in the media, I heard women making blanket statements about men, and I remember internally wondering 'What did I ever do to these women?' and sincerely starting to hate myself for being male. The second vector was rebellion: I perceived that women had it better, and I was frustrated at being rejected by women, which fed a need to transition as a rejection of the downsides of being a man. I also described how, in my head, my 'man archetype' was so horrible that I wished to be anything but that — it had nothing to do with physical attributes per se, but rather a 'wretched idea of what a man is.' I have said that 'my transition was trying to be a man, without being a man.' I also experienced a period during my trans identification where I came dangerously close to being raped, which I described as a pretty traumatizing experience, and which gave me a great deal of empathy for women. During my transition I talked to many women, learned about their experiences, and lived some experiences from that point of view, and the main thing I learned was that I had been blatantly wrong about many things I used to think — including the belief that women had it easier. On the process of detransition: I have said that I don't regret my transition all that much or feel guilty about it, because I know nobody in the world at the time could have convinced me not to transition — I was 'as stubborn as a bull' and refused to listen to anyone who might make me doubt my beliefs, and I only let it go after three years. A specific turning point was reading a manga called 'My Wife Is A Man,' which despite not being meant seriously, contained powerful lines about the male condition that taught me being male is okay and started me on a path of examining my past to mend the hurt in it. I also described how, after a while of transition, I started to 'fetishize' being male again — wanting to be seen as a man in sexual situations — and that it felt very good. On therapy: I said I had plenty of therapists in the past who were really not good and were only there to 'get it over with,' but that I got lucky with my current therapist, who just lets me talk and only asks questions when I stop. I also recommended the IATDD (International Association of Therapists for Desisters and Detransitioners) as a resource for others seeking support. On medical details: I have referenced taking hormones and changing my legal name and sex during my transition, but I have not specified which hormones, dosages, durations beyond the overall three years, or any surgeries. I have not mentioned any medical complications or fertility concerns. On mental health: I have referenced having been in 'dangerous mental states' and 'almost ending my own life' at points connected to the pain of being treated badly for being born male, but I have not given specific diagnoses or timelines for these periods. I have not described any suicidal ideation or attempts since detransitioning. On family: My family has been amazing and supportive throughout. When I transitioned they accepted it and stood behind me; when I detransitioned they accepted it and stood behind me. They had questions and were not sure what I was doing in either case, but ultimately said their own point of view didn't matter that much and trusted me. Some family members said they had always more or less believed I was not really a woman, which initially annoyed me — I felt they were downplaying it as an error and didn't understand how real it felt at the time — but after showing them two videos on my YouTube channel explaining my reasoning, we had good discussions and that feeling vanished. My dad called me 'the best actor he has ever known' because he said I managed to fool everyone including myself, which we both laughed about. On sexuality: I have said I happen to be bisexual, though I never really identified with gay/bi communities — it doesn't feel like a home, just a thing I happen to be. I have not described internalized homophobia specifically. On my current identity and views: I now identify as a detransitioned male and am at peace with being male — I described 'coming to peace with the fact that I am male and that it's okay to be male.' I have written two long analytical essays for the r/detrans community: one titled '"You were never really trans": How this sentence hurts trans people, detransitioners, and society as a whole; or the conceptual problem of transgenderism,' and another titled 'Why there are more openly detrans females than detrans males; or the current problem with outsider detransitioner discourse.' In these I argued that there is no scientific basis for a biological distinction between transgender and non-transgender people, that the term 'transgender' is poorly chosen, and that the more useful framing is 'sex-related dysphoria' affecting anyone who has ever felt distress over their birth sex. I was previously a transmedicalist and identified with the 'trutrans' position but have since rejected it. On advocacy: I have been active in advocating for detransitioners, particularly detransitioned males. I called for 'Give. More. Space. To. Detransitioners' and argued that detransition is 'OUR issue' that we should reclaim. I pushed back strongly against the reduction of male transition to a sexual fetish (AGP), calling such framing hurtful and counterproductive. I started a private detrans male Discord server and have a YouTube channel where I discuss these issues. I also reacted angrily to posts within the detrans community that dismissed male dysphoria or male privilege, arguing that such views hurt detransitioned males and drive them away from the community. On my broader views: I hold a Buddhist-influenced pessimistic view that life involves attachment and suffering, and I believe the key to resolving dysphoria is accepting that 'there is no wrong way to be a man or woman and there is no wrong way to be yourself' — that man and woman are roles we are free to interpret as we wish. I am critical of both trans community pressure and certain feminist framings of male experience, while stating I have no objection to feminism's mission of ensuring women's rights.