Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio desistito che a 6 anni ha espresso per la prima volta il desiderio di essere una bambina, e i miei genitori cristiani, contrari alla transizione, mi hanno portato in terapia. All'inizio dei vent'anni ho tentato una transizione sociale, ma alla fine ho scelto di non iniziare gli ormoni dopo aver riflettuto sul passing, sulla mia comprensione superficiale dell'essere donna e sui rischi per la salute a lungo termine. Ora mi identifico come un uomo desistito che accetta il proprio corpo, difendo attivamente r/detrans criticando l'attivismo trans mainstream e sostenendo il gatekeeping. Non ho fatto alcuna transizione medica.
Storia completa
I was born male. My journey with gender identity has been a nearly 20-year struggle, beginning around age 6 when I told my parents I wanted to be a girl. My parents held Christian beliefs and disagreed with the idea of me being transgender, so they took me to therapy. I saw a series of therapists over the years, and several of them considered it would work and be best for me to transition. My parents, whom I later described as 'christian nationalist,' blocked that path. Looking back, I am glad they did, because I feel my therapists were too affirming and I never realized the gravity of becoming a lifelong medical patient, that my gender dysphoria was related to childhood trauma, and how damaging the surgeries could have been.
I viewed femininity and the idea of becoming a woman as an escape from the expectations of living as a male, particularly in a religious school environment. The pressure to conform to traditional male roles was overwhelming, and my resistance fueled my desire to stand out against societal norms. As a teenager I was very convinced I was a trans woman, though I never consciously wanted to be one.
At 18 I had the opportunity to start hormone replacement therapy at a nearby Planned Parenthood, but familial opposition and negative experiences in an LGBT support group made me question my path. I persevered and eventually scheduled an HRT appointment for myself. In the weeks leading up to the appointment I grappled with doubts and self-reflection, which led to three major concerns. First, uncertainty about passing: starting at 24 there is no guarantee of achieving the desired appearance even with surgeries and laser sessions, and I observed that trans timelines often use specific angles or filters. Second, understanding womanhood: I realized transitioning wouldn't transform me into a woman, and that my understanding of womanhood was flawed, rooted in stereotypes like being submissive, having long hair, and wearing makeup. Third, long-term health concerns: the lack of long-term studies on the health implications of prolonged hormone therapy worried me, and I did not want to become an unwitting experiment for the pharmaceutical industry. Ultimately I chose not to start hormones and to desist, accepting my body and embracing a journey toward a healthy understanding of masculinity and femininity.
About a year before my October 2023 timeline post, I had attempted a social transition. In a photo from that period I was smiling, though it was forced, and the image was adorned with filters. I was grappling with the daily stress of convincing myself I was successfully transitioning into a woman, and gaining social recognition as a woman was incredibly important to me; sharing such pictures in trans circles or on Instagram momentarily eased my inner turmoil. I eventually realized the captivating transgender narratives online could lead others down a path they may not fully comprehend, and that my pursuit of transition seemed never-ending as I constantly compared myself to others. What finally snapped for me was that passing is not a guarantee, my understanding of womanhood was surface level, and long-term health is a gamble that isn't necessary even if I were a 'passing mtf.' In my more recent picture I was on my way to the gym, feeling genuine self-confidence and no longer needing to pretend. I consider overcoming decades of trauma and misguided advice from 'affirming therapists' a personal victory.
I have been active in the r/detrans community, defending it against what I see as slander from online trans communities and allies who label it a 'cult' or 'hate group.' I have been called a 'trans woman in denial' and a liar by others, which I find disgusting. I wrote that I am glad to be part of older Gen Z, as I likely would have been on a medical transition very early had I grown up in this era. I hold critical views of the mainstream trans community, stating plainly that I do not like the trans community, at least most of them. I find merit in transmedicalist perspectives and believe gatekeeping is crucial so individuals fully understand the implications of their decisions. I am unable to support those advocating for the liberalization of hormone therapy for minors and individuals transitioning solely based on identity without adequate therapy. I have also written critically about male influence into lesbian spaces and the erosion of language affecting women, acknowledging it may seem unconventional for a male voice to engage in that conversation. I have expressed annoyance at MTF individuals who work in OnlyFans and degrade themselves on NSFW subreddits. I have advocated for the existence of an r/mtftm subreddit to help 'confused bros' and suggested radical self-acceptance as the way forward for others considering detransition.