Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I am Nate, a 41-year-old Christian video editor and YouTuber. I have suffered gender dysphoria for most of my life, but I never took any steps toward transitioning — I believe the most likely reasons are my age and the fact that I have had very little exposure to social media. I have never medically transitioned, and I am grateful I have not made any permanent decisions about my body because of my dysphoria.
For years I experienced a strong desire to become a trans woman, and I made videos explaining my reasons for wanting to transition as well as why I could not go through with it. Earlier in 2022 I began making videos about why I felt gender dysphoria. Initially I thought the reason I hated my sex was simply societal norms — films, TV and video games constantly telling us how men and women are supposed to look and act, with women needing to be cute and men needing to be strong. I constantly felt triggered by the implications that I wasn't aligning to my sex's definitions, and anytime I saw a man being kicked in the balls I wanted to tear my own testicles off.
I physically harmed myself for over 10 years and mentally harmed myself for 20 years. I thought the reason I was cutting and burning myself was simply that I had gotten used to pain or maybe that I wanted attention. Two years ago (around 2020), I began self-authoring because I really wanted to understand why I had such a strong desire to ruin my own life. On a daily basis I had fantasies about putting my hands into a blender, crushing my testicles in a drawer, or even killing myself so that my family could stumble upon my body.
Early into my writing I realized that my childhood abuses were the cause of my self-destructive desires. My father had been physically abusive to me throughout my childhood, until the day I became stronger than him. But in my writing I discovered that the sexual abuses I experienced from other adults were the most detrimental traumas of my childhood. When I was 12, a man who was a trusted family friend asked me to help him bathe his daughters — he was teaching me how to masturbate them. This interaction sabotaged my ability to genuinely interact with women and set up a system of over sexualization; I am always working towards getting a woman naked or reminding her of her nakedness, and manipulation is one of the only ways I feel comfortable speaking with women. Later that same year, a different man had me and another younger boy interact with one another while naked, which made me constantly uncomfortable interacting with men. The last major molestation I experienced was when I was 13: a female teacher paddled me on several different occasions while I was naked, positioning me so she was able to hit my testicles with the paddle. This left me feeling constantly insecure about my genitals and constantly triggered by any reference to men being hit in the balls — any time a film or TV show portrayed a man attacked in the groin, I spiraled into a pornographic-fueled frenzy, desperately searching for a story or video that could make sense of my rage and frustration.
After spending time writing down my stories, I now know that my gender dysphoria and my desire to become a trans woman had been created by these sexual traumas and related insecurities. I came to believe that transgender identity is very much tied to traumas and possibly specifically sexual abuse. I hold the view that transgenderism is an extension of self harm — that the medical establishment has found a way to monetize self-destructive behaviors, and that transgender is self harm but with a medical professional as an advocate. I am not trying to imply that everyone who identifies as transgender has also suffered sexual abuse, but I have seen many accounts of transgender people who have gone through bouts of self-harming habits, so I wonder if transgender might be related to self-harm, perhaps with a correlation or even a causation.
Throughout spring 2022 I spent a lot of time in the r/detrans and desister communities, reading other people's stories and offering questions and feedback. I repeatedly asked people whether they had been abused or traumatized sexually as a child, whether they struggled with self-harm, video game pornography or character creators, and whether they understood why they had gender dysphoria. I also repeatedly offered to send people a link to my own video essay, 'Have you ever wanted to become someone else?' (youtu.be/C0FoWpv9Mdw), which is not a detrans story but rather my thinking and writing expanded into an explanation of why I could not transition. I benefited greatly from disclosing my own stories of childhood trauma and sexual abuse in YouTube video essays, and I believe being open about abuses is probably the best approach to resolving traumatic responses — the only people who benefit from people being silent about their childhood abuses are the abusers.
I have tried to be supportive of others: I told one person I was happy they had not made any permanent decisions about their body because of gender dysphoria, and I recommended that they be honest with their mother and tell her that their dysphoria had been dissipating. I have a good friend who identifies as a man and got top surgery two years before; before her surgery I was very supportive and called her the name she wanted, and when she told me she was thinking of getting top surgery I became worried that her identity might change or alter, resulting in her regretting her decision. She has not changed her mind yet, and I try to remain supportive of her by calling her the name she feels comfortable with.
In July 2022 I made a post titled 'Help me reach my Trans friend - before she sterilizes myself,' showing concern about a friend's medical transition. I also posted 'Was your transition a form of self harm?' in the community, introducing myself and asking people directly whether they had practiced self-harm and whether their transition had something to do with a desire to harm themselves.
I have not described any surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers of my own, since I never transitioned. I have not described a formal diagnosis. My self-harm history (cutting and burning for over 10 years, mental self-harm for 20 years) and daily suicidal fantasies are the most severe mental health issues I have described; I have not stated whether these have resolved. I have not described my current sexuality beyond the difficulties with women and men that resulted from my childhood abuse. I have not described a romantic partner or children. My current identity is that of a dysphoric Christian man who chose not to transition, and I now understand my dysphoria as rooted in childhood physical and sexual abuse.