Tutte le storie

Quattro anni di disforia, senza ormoni né interventi

Femmina · Desistito/a418
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/si interroga, nata femmina, che si è identificata come trans per circa quattro anni senza mai prendere ormoni né fare interventi, e che ha desistito in gran parte per l'ambiente transfobico del mio paese del terzo mondo e per i costi sociali e psicologici del presentarsi come maschio. La mia disforia è iniziata verso i 14 anni, in mezzo a un padre controllante e a volte fisicamente aggressivo, all'ansia sociale e al desiderio di essere forte e autorevole invece di essere vista come debole. L'esercizio di un terapeuta non focalizzato sul genere, che consisteva nel ribattezzare la mia «disforia», la ricerca sulla detransition, gli scritti di Scott Peck e il podcast «Gender: A Wider Lens» mi hanno aiutata a prendere le distanze. A volte provo ancora disforia e non sono sicura della mia identità, ma ho scelto di accettare il mio corpo femminile e di astenermi dalla transizione. Sono critica verso la transizione medica dei giovani e verso gran parte del discorso della comunità trans, pur insistendo che sia una decisione di ciascuno.

Storia completa

I was born female and I'm from a third-world country with a lot of ignorance and homo/transphobia. I first started questioning my gender around age 13 — I didn't have childhood dysphoria, but I really liked having short hair and liked when people called me a boy because of it, and I liked more masculine things for as long as I can remember. Dysphoria only started for me at 14 and after, when I saw guys growing taller and getting deeper voices; I tried to deepen my own voice, and when the boys started to look distinctly different from me it became painful. Somewhere deep down I felt an immense sense of comfort when I could see an actual boy in the mirror, and it hurt seeing my small frame even though I was a decent height and very flat-chested. Sexually, I could seldom imagine having sex with my vagina — it was mostly about me having a dick/strapon, and that continues to this day; I feel it has less to do with being a top, I just wanted a dick. I identified as trans for about 4 years (I described myself as being in and out of the trans community for about 5 years by early 2020). I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers. I did socially transition/present as male for a time, and I found it extremely stressful: I faced social isolation, rejection, people talking behind my back, and the knowledge that I would be disowned by many people dear to me. Presenting as male made me more insecure and obsessive about my looks, appearance and behavior, and definitely more depressed compared to when I was closeted. Those tradeoffs led me to stop what I was doing temporarily, and eventually I desisted. I've said plainly: "I desisted because of the transphobic environment I live in. Life happened." I had to give up my identity for safety. I also described myself as a lesbian ("I'm ftm so I always imagine his dick was mine...(btw I'm lesbian but it's a long story)"), while also saying "I never liked men or penises. I was always attracted to females, my bf is just someone I experiment with." I later mentioned a girlfriend: "I never knew how feminine I could be until I met my gf, someone who accepted and appreciated me as I am and for my past." My sexuality has been a factor in my gender feelings — I experienced porn addiction, which for me was in part an escape mechanism through which I felt I could imagine having the anatomy I always wanted; it felt affirming. I've said that in a way my sexuality (not sexual orientation) is the reason I still believe I am trans. Contributing factors I've identified include a controlling father who would sometimes physically get aggressive, and my feeling physically weak in his presence. I always wanted to be stronger than him — not to hurt him, just not to feel powerless. It led me to indulge in sadistic (nothing too bad) fantasies/behavior. I felt I needed to be more masc and commanding to have people listen to me, and thought that if I were more massive and intimidating people wouldn't see me as weak or an easy target. I've also had bad social anxiety that masked as gd, and dyslexia and ADD. I'm a STEM-oriented student and a biology nerd. I've written about how underlying trauma can disguise itself as gd, and how alienation from femaleness can produce feelings of gd that are "something completely else." I've also noted that misogyny-induced dysphoria is incredibly common in queer circles, and that I sometimes comfort myself in my masculinity when I can't perform my role as a woman. I dissociate "all the time when I have to put on a female mask." I used to feel there was a block between me and the world. What moved me toward desisting: a therapist once asked me to stop calling the discomfort I was feeling "dysphoria" for a period of time and find another word to describe the emotions as accurately as I could — it helped me actively find the cause of the discomfort and factor out issues I had been labeling as dysphoria because I didn't want to address the actual pain. Visiting a non-gender therapist was the only solution that helped me. I read Scott Peck's The Road Less Traveled, which opened my eyes to how ignoring problems just causes mental illness. Over about a year I dug through detrans videos, sites and blogs, and I frequent detrans communities to re-read posts and reassure myself. The podcast 'Gender: A Wider Lens' by two therapists working with dysphoric teens helped me recognize red flags and patterns in my own behavior. I also described having "confusion episodes" where I wished someone could sit beside me and tell me I'd be okay. I never hated my body and never felt it was the wrong body. I decided I would not let other people's perception of me determine how I feel about my gender or how valid I am. I stopped caring about passing, which I described as "hopes and prayers and the mercy of practical nobodys in my life," and accepted my physical reality because I was tired of being a split person leading a double/triple life. I accept that if I have to live as my natal gender for the rest of my life, I accept that. On transition for others: I don't tell people to try it or not — "I don't feel like it's my place or job to say it." I support people thinking critically and asking not just "am I trans" but "is transition what I need and is it worth it for me?" I don't think kids/teens should take puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones, because the brain doesn't fully mature until 25. I find bottom surgeries quite barbaric even though I experience substantial bottom dysphoria — removing a perfectly functioning organ and making yourself dependent on drugs for life isn't a fair tradeoff to me. I've said medical transition shouldn't feel like the only option and shouldn't be glamorized as the cure. I've also been critical of the trans community, saying "there is so much bs going on in the trans community" and that "validity completely lost all meaning." I've offered to PM and help others who are questioning. I do not consider myself detrans — my flair reflected that I was still questioning — but I have described myself as abstaining from transition and as having desisted because of my environment. I still get dysphoric and want to transition at times, but I've chosen to wait it out and work on other aspects of my life, believing there is much more to life than gender.